Let Us Take Up the Sword
Eight days after Fort Sumter, a Black Philadelphian tells his brethren to prepare for a war the Union army would not yet let them fight, and to renew their claim to citizenship by fighting it.
Free, all of it. No ads, no account, no paywall, no trial, nothing to cancel.
📖 Read the full text on this pageEvery paragraph numbered, so you can cite itOn April 20, 1861, eight days after Confederate guns opened fire on Fort Sumter, Alfred M. Green of Philadelphia signed an address to the Black men of his city. The Union army would not take them as soldiers. Pennsylvania had taken away their vote in 1838, and the Supreme Court had ruled in 1857 that no Black American could be a citizen of the United States. Green told them to get ready to fight anyway. In under five hundred words he admits every wrong the nation has done them, refuses to dwell on it, and argues that taking up the sword is how they will renew their claim on the Republic. The AP exam printed almost all of it, from the first sentence to “equality to all men” (paragraphs 1 to 5 here). It left out only the closing sentence, the signature and the date, and it smoothed the punctuation, so the text below is the address as Green himself collected it in 1862.
The claim
Black Americans should prepare now to fight for the Union, despite the injuries the nation has done them. The war is a fight between freedom and slavery, their fathers’ courage in 1776 and 1812 must not be disgraced by their sons, and service will renew their claim to the citizenship and justice the Republic owes them.
The rhetorical situation who, to whom, when, and why
Philadelphia, Pennsylvania
A free state city with one of the largest free Black communities in the country, where Black men had lost the vote under the state constitution of 1838. The Press reported that two regiments were forming at the Masonic Hall on South Eleventh Street.
April 20, 1861
Eight days after the attack on Fort Sumter and five days after Lincoln’s call for volunteers, when Northern cities were filling with recruits and no one knew how long the war would last.
What Let Us Take Up the Sword says
The pamphlet in which Green collected the address prints it under a headline from the Philadelphia Press, “The Colored Philadelphians Forming Regiments,” with the paper’s note that hundreds of men were ready to fill two regiments if the State would accept them. Green’s own words begin in paragraph 1. The time has come, he says, for Black Americans to show the world again the bravery and patriotism of a race that loves country, freedom and toleration, and these principles let even proscribed men say that they love their country, right or wrong. Paragraphs 2 and 3 concede the hard facts. The deeds of Black soldiers in the Revolution and the War of 1812, vouched for by Washington and by Jackson, did not win their sons recognition as citizens. Their injuries are great: fugitive-slave laws, the Dred Scott decision, indictments for treason and months of imprisonment. That, Green says bitterly, is the pay they received for their help in the days that tried men’s souls. Paragraph 4 turns. Their duty is not to quarrel over past grievances. They should remember the past and regret that their position gives them less reason for zeal than other men have, but hope for the future and use this favorable moment to create their claims on the Republic’s justice anew. Above all, the sons must not disgrace the honor their fathers won. “Let us, then, take up the sword,” he says, trusting God and remembering that the world now stands for freedom and political equality. Paragraph 5 describes the enemy: the secessionists’ war cry is more slave territory and a stronger system of slavery. It ends with a promise that the very presence of Black men in Northern armies would give the enslaved of the South zeal and confidence. Green closes with his hope for their zeal, signs himself theirs “for God and humanity,” and dates the address April 20, 1861.
The line of reasoning how the argument moves
- Opens on the world stageParagraph 1 speaks of “the great Republic” and “the world,” and the word “again” reminds readers that Black Americans have proved their patriotism before. Starting large lifts the call above Philadelphia politics and makes loyalty, not grievance, the first thing the audience hears.
- Concedes the recordParagraphs 2 and 3 begin “It is true” and list what loyalty has earned: no citizenship, harsh laws, a hostile court, prison. Green says the objection before his listeners can, so they hear that he knows the case against fighting as well as they do.
- Turns grievance into dutyParagraph 4 opens “Our duty, brethren, is not to cavil over past grievances.” He does not ask them to forget. He moves them through time: remember the past, hope for the future, improve the present moment.
- Calls on fathers and sonsThe middle of paragraph 4 sets the honor won by “our fathers” against the danger of “a want of true heroism among their sons.” Refusing to serve would not punish the nation, he implies, it would disgrace the dead.
- Names the enemy’s aimParagraph 5 gives the secessionists a war cry of three “let us” clauses, all about extending slavery. The war Green asks his audience to join is defined as a war over their own people’s bondage.
- Ends with the enslavedThe last argument looks south. The presence of Black soldiers would inspire “your oppressed brethren of the South” with zeal and confidence. Serving becomes an act of solidarity, not only of patriotism, and the address closes on “God and humanity.”
The full text paragraphs numbered for citation
¶1The time has arrived in the history of the great Republic when we may again give evidence to the world of the bravery and patriotism of a race, in whose hearts burns the love of country, of freedom, and of civil and religious toleration. It is these grand principles that enable men, however proscribed, when possessed of true patriotism, to say: “My country, right or wrong, I love thee still!”
¶2It is true, the brave deeds of our fathers, sworn and subscribed to by the immortal Washington of the Revolution of 1776, and of Jackson and others, in the War of 1812, have failed to bring us into recognition as citizens, enjoying those rights so dearly bought by those noble and patriotic sires.
¶3It is true, that our injuries in many respects are great; fugitive-slave laws, Dred Scott decisions, indictments for treason, and long and dreary months of imprisonment. The result of the most unfair rules of judicial investigation has been the pay we have received for our solicitude, sympathy, and aid in the dangers and difficulties of those “days that tried men’s souls.”
¶4Our duty, brethren, is not to cavil over past grievances. Let us not be derelict to duty in the time of need. While we remember the past, and regret that our present position in the country is not such as to create within us that burning zeal and enthusiasm for the field of battle, which inspires other men in the full enjoyment of every civil and religious emolument, yet let us endeavor to hope for the future, and improve the present auspicious moment for creating anew our claims upon the justice and honor of the Republic; and, above all, let not the honor and glory achieved by our fathers be blasted or sullied by a want of true heroism among their sons. Let us, then, take up the sword, trusting in God, who will defend the right, remembering that these are other days than those of yore—that the world to-day is on the side of freedom and universal political equality.
¶5That the war-cry of the howling leaders of Secession and treason is, let us drive back the advance guard of civil and religious freedom; let us have more slave territory; let us build stronger the tyrant system of slavery in the great American Republic. Remember, too, that your very presence among the troops of the North would inspire your oppressed brethren of the South with zeal for the overthrow of the tyrant system, and confidence in the armies of the living God—the God of truth, justice, and equality to all men.
¶6With a knowledge of your zeal and patriotism, and a hope of its early development, I am yours, for God and humanity,
¶7A. M. GREEN.
¶8Philadelphia, April 20, 1861.
Text: Alfred M. Green, Letters and Discussions on the Formation of Colored Regiments (Philadelphia: Ringwalt & Brown, 1862), pp. 3-4, from the Library of Congress copy scanned by the Internet Archive.
Paragraph by paragraph what each part does
- 1
Paragraph 1: A race that loves its country
Green announces that the time has come to give the world fresh evidence of the bravery and patriotism of a race that loves country, freedom, and civil and religious toleration. These principles, he says, let men who are proscribed, shut out from rights, still declare with true patriotism that they love their country, right or wrong.
Why it mattersThe opening claims the language of national patriotism for people the nation excluded. The famous phrase about loving one’s country right or wrong usually celebrates uncritical loyalty, but here “right or wrong” has a pointed meaning: the country has been wrong to them, and they love it anyway.
- 2
Paragraphs 2 to 3: What loyalty has earned
Green grants that the brave deeds of Black soldiers in the Revolution and the War of 1812, vouched for by Washington and by Jackson and others, did not bring their descendants recognition as citizens. He lists the injuries since: fugitive-slave laws, the Dred Scott decision, indictments for treason and long months in prison. Unfair trials, he says, were the pay they received for their sympathy and aid in “days that tried men’s souls.”
Why it mattersThe two paragraphs are a concession, and an honest one. By naming the wrongs in concrete legal terms Green earns the trust of listeners who might suspect a recruiter of glossing over them. The bitter word “pay” turns the grievance into an unpaid debt that the nation still owes.
- 3
Paragraph 4: Duty, hope and the sword
Their duty, he says, is not to cavil over past grievances or fail in a time of need. They may remember the past and regret that their position does not fire them with the zeal of men who enjoy every civil right, but they should hope for the future and use the present moment to create their claims on the Republic anew. Above all, the sons must not let a lack of heroism blight their fathers’ glory. “Let us, then, take up the sword,” trusting God and remembering that the world is now on the side of freedom and equality.
Why it mattersThis is the turn and the heart of the address. Green treats service as an argument for rights, a way of “creating anew our claims.” The long sentence moves through past, future and present before it reaches the sword, so the call to arms arrives as the conclusion of a reasoned case.
- 4
Paragraphs 5 to 8: The enemy, the enslaved and the signature
Green describes the war cry of the secession leaders as driving back freedom, gaining more slave territory and strengthening slavery. He tells his readers to remember that their presence among Northern troops would give the enslaved of the South zeal for overthrowing slavery and confidence in the armies of God. He closes with his hope that their zeal and patriotism will soon show themselves, signs “A. M. Green,” and dates the address Philadelphia, April 20, 1861.
Why it mattersParagraph 5 answers a question his audience would ask: is this our war? Green defines the Confederacy by slavery, months before most Northern leaders would. The letter-style ending, “I am yours, for God and humanity,” places the whole appeal under a cause larger than any one government.
Rhetorical choices what the writer does, and why it works
Concession
Paragraphs 2 and 3 open with “It is true,” granting the strongest objections to his own case: unrewarded service, cruel laws, unjust trials. Admitting the facts first makes the turn in paragraph 4 more believable, because Green cannot be accused of hiding them.
Hortatory “let us”
Green’s calls to action are framed as “let us”: “Let us not be derelict,” “let us endeavor to hope,” “Let us, then, take up the sword.” The form includes the speaker in the danger he urges. Paragraph 5 gives the secessionists three “let us” clauses of their own, so two calls to arms face each other.
Allusion
“Days that tried men’s souls” echoes Thomas Paine’s famous line from 1776, “These are the times that try men’s souls.” Green claims the Revolution’s darkest hour for the Black soldiers who served in it, and reminds readers what they received for it.
Appeal to ancestry
The “fathers” of 1776 and 1812 and their “sons” frame the address. Green borrows the authority of Washington and Jackson for Black courage, then makes the present a test of whether the sons deserve their fathers’ name.
Past, present and future
Paragraph 4 moves deliberately through time: “remember the past,” “hope for the future,” “improve the present auspicious moment.” The pattern shows the audience a way to keep their grievances without being ruled by them.
Religious appeal
Green trusts “in God, who will defend the right” and calls the Union forces “the armies of the living God—the God of truth, justice, and equality to all men.” The biblical phrase turns a government army into a cause, and defines God by the very equality the nation denied.
People & audiences
Alfred M. Green
Writer and speaker
A free Black Philadelphian who wrote and lectured for Black enlistment from the first days of the war. He speaks as one of the brethren, and his “let us” puts him in the ranks he is calling for.
The brethren
Audience
The Black men of Philadelphia, free but denied citizenship and the vote. Green expects them to doubt him, and he answers their doubts before he asks for their service.
Our fathers
Black soldiers of 1776 and 1812
The men who fought in the Revolution and the War of 1812. Their service is the ground of Green’s argument and the honor he warns the sons not to stain.
Washington and Jackson
Witnesses
The two generals whose testimony to Black bravery Green invokes. Their names carry the authority of the nation’s most honored commanders.
The leaders of Secession
The enemy
The “howling leaders of Secession and treason,” whose war cry Green sums up as more slave territory and a stronger system of slavery.
The oppressed brethren of the South
The enslaved
The people held in slavery in the Confederate states. Green argues that Black soldiers in Northern armies would give them zeal and confidence, which makes enlistment an act of solidarity.
Big ideas in Let Us Take Up the Sword
Loyalty without recognition
Green’s audience has served the nation and been refused citizenship. The address asks them to keep faith with a country that has not kept faith with them, and it is honest about how much that asks.
Service as a claim to rights
Fighting is not presented as gratitude. It is a way of “creating anew our claims upon the justice and honor of the Republic,” a public act that would make denial of citizenship harder to defend.
Honor across generations
The fathers’ deeds in 1776 and 1812 create an obligation for the sons. Green makes the present war a test of family and racial honor, not only of national loyalty.
A war about slavery
In April 1861 Lincoln described the war as a fight to preserve the Union. Green insists from the start that it is a fight between freedom and slavery, and that the enslaved of the South are watching it.
Seizing the moment
“The time has arrived,” “the present auspicious moment,” “other days than those of yore”: Green argues that this moment is different and must be used before it passes.
Key images
The sword
The sword stands for active citizenship. To take it up is to stop petitioning from outside and to claim a place inside the nation’s defense, where the claim to its rights is hardest to refuse.
The great Republic
Green names the Republic at the start and in paragraph 5. It stands for the ideal nation of equal rights that Black Americans were asked to defend and had not yet been allowed to belong to.
Repeated words and ideas
Fathers and sons. The fathers of the Revolution and the War of 1812 appear in paragraphs 2 and 4, and their sons are the audience. The pairing turns a political choice into a question of inheritance.
Let us. The phrase runs through Green’s call and returns in the enemy’s war cry. The repetition shows two sides urging their followers forward, one toward freedom and one toward slavery.
Tensions and counterarguments
Loyalty vs. grievance. The audience has every reason to refuse a nation that denied them citizenship. Green does not deny the grievance; he argues that duty and self-interest both point toward service.
Freedom vs. slavery. Green frames the war as freedom and equality against the secessionists’ program of more slave territory, a reading of the war that the Union government did not openly adopt until the Emancipation Proclamation.
Key quotes
“It is these grand principles that enable men, however proscribed, when possessed of true patriotism, to say: “My country, right or wrong, I love thee still!””
“It is true, the brave deeds of our fathers, sworn and subscribed to by the immortal Washington of the Revolution of 1776, and of Jackson and others, in the War of 1812, have failed to bring us into recognition as citizens, enjoying those rights so dearly bought by those noble and patriotic sires.”
“Our duty, brethren, is not to cavil over past grievances. Let us not be derelict to duty in the time of need.”
“let not the honor and glory achieved by our fathers be blasted or sullied by a want of true heroism among their sons.”
“Let us, then, take up the sword, trusting in God, who will defend the right, remembering that these are other days than those of yore—that the world to-day is on the side of freedom and universal political equality.”
“Remember, too, that your very presence among the troops of the North would inspire your oppressed brethren of the South with zeal for the overthrow of the tyrant system,”
The conclusion of Let Us Take Up the Sword, explained
The last stretch of the address has a strange shape that the exam’s version hides. In Green’s pamphlet, paragraph 5 begins “That the war-cry of the howling leaders of Secession and treason is, let us drive back the advance guard of civil and religious freedom.” That is not a complete sentence. It continues the list of things the audience should be “remembering” at the end of paragraph 4: remember that these are other days, that the world is on the side of freedom, and that the enemy’s war cry is slavery. The exam joined the two paragraphs with a semicolon and put the secessionists’ words in quotation marks, which makes the logic easier to follow. The original is rougher, and it shows Green building one long chain of reasons. The war cry he invents for the Confederacy uses three clauses beginning “let us,” and the effect is to set two calls to arms side by side, his own and the enemy’s. Then comes his final reason: the presence of Black soldiers in Northern armies would give the enslaved of the South zeal and confidence. The audience is asked to see themselves through the eyes of people still in bondage. The address ends as a letter, “I am yours, for God and humanity,” and is signed and dated. “Humanity” is the last word of the argument. Green does not close on the Union or the flag but on a cause wider than either, the one that would make service worth it even if the nation again failed to repay it.
Common misreadings
MythBlack men could join the Union army when Green wrote.
ActuallyThey could not. In 1861 the army and Pennsylvania refused Black volunteers. Congress authorized their service in July 1862, the Emancipation Proclamation of January 1863 announced it, and Black regiments were organized in numbers from 1863.
MythGreen tells his audience to forget the nation’s injustices.
ActuallyHe lists them in paragraphs 2 and 3 and tells them to “remember the past.” What he rejects is letting grievance stop them, because service is the way to press their claims.
MythThe quotation marks around the secessionists’ war cry are Green’s.
ActuallyThey are the exam’s. In the 1862 pamphlet the war cry is not in quotation marks, and it starts a new paragraph with “That,” continuing the sentence before it.
MythThe text is a reporter’s transcript of a speech.
ActuallyThe exam calls it a speech delivered in Philadelphia, but the 1862 pamphlet prints it as an address carried by the Philadelphia Press, signed and dated April 20, 1861, like a letter. Whatever was said aloud, this is the text Green chose to publish.
AP practice a rhetorical analysis prompt in the exam's style
In April 1861, days after the Civil War began, Alfred M. Green published an address calling on the Black men of Philadelphia to prepare to fight for the Union, although the army would not yet accept them. Read the address carefully. Then write an essay that analyzes the rhetorical choices Green makes to persuade his audience to take up arms for a nation that denied them citizenship.
What a strong response notices
- The opening in paragraph 1, which speaks to “the world” and borrows a patriotic saying, giving “right or wrong” a pointed meaning.
- The concessions in paragraphs 2 and 3, introduced by “It is true,” which name the nation’s injuries in legal detail before any call to action.
- The turn at the start of paragraph 4 and its movement through past, future and present toward “take up the sword.”
- The appeal to “our fathers” under Washington and Jackson and to the honor of “their sons.”
- The enemy’s “let us” war cry and the appeal to the enslaved of the South in paragraph 5, and the closing “for God and humanity” in paragraph 6.
Practice prompt written by StoryBites, not taken from a College Board exam. See the AP Language free-response guide for how answers are scored.
Test yourself
1. When did Green date the address?
The dateline reads “Philadelphia, April 20, 1861,” and Confederate batteries fired on Fort Sumter on April 12. Report a mistake
2. What do paragraphs 2 and 3 mainly do?
Both begin “It is true” and list the failures and injuries, from denied citizenship to fugitive-slave laws and the Dred Scott decision. Report a mistake
3. Whose famous words does “days that tried men’s souls” echo?
Paine’s The American Crisis of 1776 begins “These are the times that try men’s souls.” Report a mistake
4. According to Green, what would serving do for Black Americans?
Paragraph 4 urges them to “improve the present auspicious moment for creating anew our claims upon the justice and honor of the Republic.” Report a mistake
5. How does Green describe the goal of the secession leaders?
Paragraph 5 gives their war cry as “let us have more slave territory; let us build stronger the tyrant system of slavery.” Report a mistake
Flashcards flip, self-grade, and the deck remembers what you know
When the Civil War started in April 1861, Black men in the North wanted to fight, but the Union army said no. Alfred M. Green, a Black man in Philadelphia, wrote to them anyway. He admitted that the country had treated them badly: their grandfathers fought in the Revolution and still weren’t treated as citizens, and the courts were unfair to them. But he said complaining wasn’t enough. If they got ready to fight, they would honor their fathers, help free enslaved people in the South, and make a strong case that they deserved to be citizens. About two years later the army finally let Black men join.
Compare & connect
The American Crisis, Number 1
Green borrows Paine’s “times that try men’s souls” for the Black soldiers of the Revolution. Paine also writes to rally reluctant people in a dark hour, so the two make a natural pair on how to call an audience to arms.
What to the Slave Is the Fourth of July?
Nine years earlier Douglass set out the same injuries Green concedes, at full length and in open anger. Reading them together shows how one grievance can support a refusal to celebrate or a decision to fight.
The Gettysburg Address
By November 1863 Lincoln was calling the war a test of a nation dedicated to equality and promising “a new birth of freedom.” Green had framed the war that way in its first week.
Discussion and essay prompts:
💬 Discussion questions
- What is Alfred M. Green’s argument in his 1861 speech
- Why did Green urge Black men to fight when the Union army would not accept them
- What rhetorical strategies does Green use in Let Us Take Up the Sword
- How does Let Us Take Up the Sword explore the theme of loyalty without recognition?
- How does Let Us Take Up the Sword explore the theme of service as a claim to rights?
- What is the central conflict in Let Us Take Up the Sword, and how does it shape the ending?
✎ Essay prompts
- Analyze how Alfred M. Green develops the theme of loyalty without recognition in Let Us Take Up the Sword. Support your argument with specific evidence from the text.
- Examine the significance of the sword in Let Us Take Up the Sword. What does it represent, and how does it deepen the work’s meaning?
- How does Alfred M. Green use concession to shape the reader’s experience of Let Us Take Up the Sword?
- Some readers assume that black men could join the Union army when Green wrote. Argue for or against this interpretation, using evidence from the text.
Key questions students ask
- What is Alfred M. Green’s argument in his 1861 speech
- Why did Green urge Black men to fight when the Union army would not accept them
- What rhetorical strategies does Green use in Let Us Take Up the Sword
- What injuries does Green list in his speech
- Why does Green mention Washington and Jackson
- When were Black soldiers allowed to join the Union army
Analysis is original StoryBites commentary. The full text and quotations follow the address as Green first collected it, in his pamphlet Letters and Discussions on the Formation of Colored Regiments, and the Duty of the Colored People in Regard to the Great Slaveholders’ Rebellion (Philadelphia: Ringwalt & Brown, 1862), pages 3 and 4, transcribed from the Library of Congress copy scanned by the Internet Archive and checked against the Project Gutenberg transcription of the same scan. The pamphlet reprints it from the Philadelphia Press of April 22, 1861; the newspaper’s introduction is described here but not reproduced, and the title is ours, taken from Green’s own words. The exam’s text differs in small ways: it reads “by Jackson” for “of Jackson” and “today” for “to-day,” drops several commas, and joins the paragraph that begins “That the war-cry” to the sentence before it, putting the secessionists’ words in quotation marks. The address is in the public domain. An excerpt from the speech was the passage for the rhetorical analysis question on the 2003 AP English Language exam (College Board free-response questions, 2003).