AP Language · letter · 12 min

Letter to Thomas Jefferson

A free Black astronomer sends Thomas Jefferson his almanac and holds the author of the Declaration of Independence to his own words about equality and liberty.

⏱ 12 min to understand the letter 6 steps of reasoning · 6 rhetorical choices Public domain text
📖 Read the full text on this pageEvery paragraph numbered, so you can cite it
0% explored
The whole letter in 60 seconds

In August 1791 Benjamin Banneker, a free Black farmer and self-taught astronomer in Maryland, mailed a handwritten almanac to the Secretary of State, Thomas Jefferson. With it he sent a letter. Jefferson had written that all men are created equal, and he had also written, in his Notes on the State of Virginia, that he suspected Black people were naturally inferior in mind. Banneker answers both. He is courteous in every paragraph, and in the middle of the letter he quotes the Declaration of Independence back to its author and asks how the man who wrote it can hold people in slavery.

The claim

If Jefferson truly believes what he wrote in the Declaration, that all men are created equal and have the same rights, he cannot keep supporting slavery and prejudice. God made all people one family with the same faculties, and Banneker’s own almanac is proof of what a Black man’s mind can do.

The rhetorical situation who, to whom, when, and why

SpeakerBenjamin Banneker, born free in Maryland in 1731 and nearly sixty when he wrote. He taught himself mathematics and astronomy, and that year he had helped survey the land for the new federal capital. In a note he adds that his father was brought from Africa enslaved.
AudienceThomas Jefferson, Secretary of State, author of the Declaration of Independence, and himself an enslaver. Banneker writes to him privately, but the letter reached a much wider public once it was printed the next year.
OccasionBanneker was sending Jefferson a manuscript copy of his almanac for 1792, the astronomical calculations he had made for the year ahead. He says he meant only to send the almanac and was led into the rest.
ExigenceMany white Americans believed that Black people were incapable of serious intellectual work, and Jefferson had given that belief his support in print. Meanwhile slavery continued in a nation founded on a declaration of equal rights.
PurposeTo persuade Jefferson to work against prejudice and slavery, by appealing to his reputation, his religion and his own words, and to offer the almanac as evidence against the claim that Black people lacked mental ability.
ContextJefferson replied on August 30, 1791, saying he hoped for proof that nature had given Black people talents equal to others, and that he had sent the almanac to the Academy of Sciences in Paris. In 1792 the two letters were printed together in Philadelphia.
Place

Near Ellicott’s Lower Mills, Baltimore County, Maryland

Banneker’s home, where he farmed and studied the sky. Maryland was a slaveholding state, so he wrote as a free man surrounded by slavery.

Time

August 19, 1791

Fifteen years after the Declaration of Independence, in the first years of the new federal government, when Jefferson was Secretary of State.

What Letter to Thomas Jefferson says

Banneker opens by admitting that writing to a man of Jefferson’s rank is a liberty, especially given the prejudice against people of his complexion. He says Black people have long been treated with contempt and thought more brutish than human. But he has heard that Jefferson is friendlier toward them than many others. If so, he says, Jefferson will want to get rid of the false ideas that surround them, and will agree that one universal Father made everyone of one flesh with the same senses and faculties. Anyone who claims the rights of human nature and professes Christianity should extend those rights to the whole human race. Banneker then states plainly that he is of the African race and the deepest color, and thanks God that he is free, not held in slavery as so many of his brethren are. Next he asks Jefferson to remember the Revolution, when British power threatened to reduce Americans to servitude and only Providence preserved them. At that time, he says, Jefferson saw the injustice of slavery clearly, and wrote that all men are created equal and have unalienable rights to life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness. Yet Jefferson now holds many of Banneker’s brethren in captivity by fraud and violence, guilty of the very act he condemned when it was done to Americans. Banneker will not lecture him on how to free them. He only asks Jefferson to put his soul in their souls’ place, as Job told his friends. In the last part Banneker explains the almanac. He made it through years of study in his old age, almost gave it up when he was called away to the federal survey, and finished it for printers who were expecting it. He sends it in manuscript so Jefferson can see it in his own handwriting. Two postscripts give an address for replies and ask Jefferson not to publish the almanac, and a short note records that his father was brought from Africa enslaved.

The line of reasoning how the argument moves

  1. Opens with humilityParagraphs 4 and 5 apologize for the freedom of writing and name the prejudice Black people face. Beginning modestly earns a hearing from a powerful reader and puts the problem on the table at once.
  2. Assumes good willParagraphs 6 and 7 say Banneker has heard Jefferson is friendly toward Black people. By crediting Jefferson with a good reputation, Banneker makes it hard for him to act against it without seeming to fall short of himself.
  3. Builds on shared beliefsParagraphs 7 to 9 argue from principles Jefferson already holds: one Father of all, the rights of human nature, Christian duty. If Jefferson accepts them, the conclusion follows.
  4. Presents himself as evidenceIn paragraph 10 Banneker names his race and color and gives thanks for his freedom. The writer of this careful letter becomes living proof against the idea that Black people lack mental gifts.
  5. Turns Jefferson’s words on himParagraphs 11 to 13 recall the Revolution, quote the Declaration, and then accuse Jefferson of doing to others what he condemned when it was done to Americans. This is the heart of the letter.
  6. Closes with the almanacParagraphs 15 to 17 return to the almanac, which shows a Black man’s learning in his own handwriting. The ending turns from argument back to proof.

The full text paragraphs numbered for citation

¶1Maryland. Baltimore County. Near Ellicotts Lower Mills

¶2August 19th: 1791

¶3Sir

¶4I am fully sensible of the greatness of that freedom which I take with you on the present occasion; a liberty which Seemed to me scarcely allowable, when I reflected on that distinguished, and dignifyed station in which you Stand; and the almost general prejudice and prepossession which is so prevailent in the world against those of my complexion.

¶5I suppose it is a truth too well attested to you, to need a proof here, that we are a race of Beings who have long laboured under the abuse and censure of the world, that we have long been looked upon with an eye of contempt, and that we have long been considered rather as brutish than human, and Scarcely capable of mental endowments.

¶6Sir I hope I may Safely admit, in consequence of that report which hath reached me, that you are a man far less inflexible in Sentiments of this nature, than many others, that you are measurably friendly and well disposed toward us, and that you are willing and ready to Lend your aid and assistance to our relief from those many distresses and numerous calamities to which we are reduced.

¶7Now Sir if this is founded in truth, I apprehend you will readily embrace every opportunity to eradicate that train of absurd and false ideas and oppinions which so generally prevails with respect to us, and that your Sentiments are concurrent with mine, which are that one universal Father hath given being to us all, and that he hath not only made us all of one flesh, but that he hath also without partiality afforded us all the Same Sensations, and endued us all with the same faculties, and that however variable we may be in Society or religion, however diversifyed in Situation or colour, we are all of the Same Family, and Stand in the Same relation to him.

¶8Sir, if these are Sentiments of which you are fully persuaded, I hope you cannot but acknowledge, that it is the indispensible duty of those who maintain for themselves the rights of human nature, and who profess the obligations of Christianity, to extend their power and influence to the relief of every part of the human race, from whatever burthen or oppression they may unjustly labour under, and this I apprehend a full conviction of the truth and obligation of these principles should lead all to.

¶9Sir, I have long been convinced, that if your love for your Selves, and for those inesteemable laws which preserve to you the rights of human nature, was founded on Sincerity, you could not but be Solicitous, that every Individual of whatsoever rank or distinction, might with you equally enjoy the blessings thereof, neither could you rest Satisfyed, short of the most active diffusion of your exertions, in order to their promotion from any State of degradation, to which the unjustifyable cruelty and barbarism of men may have reduced them.

¶10Sir I freely and Chearfully acknowledge, that I am of the African race, and in that colour which is natural to them of the deepest dye,* and it is under a Sense of the most profound gratitude to the Supreme Ruler of the universe, that I now confess to you, that I am not under that State of tyrannical thraldom, and inhuman captivity, to which too many of my brethren are doomed; but that I have abundantly tasted of the fruition of those blessings which proceed from that free and unequalled liberty with which you are favoured and which I hope you will willingly allow you have received from the immediate hand of that Being, from whom proceedeth every good and perfect gift.

¶11Sir, Suffer me to recall to your mind that time in which the Arms and tyranny of the British Crown were exerted with every powerful effort in order to reduce you to a State of Servitude, look back I intreat you on the variety of dangers to which you were exposed, reflect on that time in which every human aid appeared unavailable, and in which even hope and fortitude wore the aspect of inability to the Conflict, and you cannot but be led to a Serious and grateful Sense of your miraculous and providential preservation; you cannot but acknowledge, that the present freedom and tranquility which you enjoy you have mercifully received, and that it is the peculiar blessing of Heaven.

¶12This Sir, was a time in which you clearly saw into the injustice of a State of Slavery, and in which you had just apprehensions of the horrors of its condition, it was now Sir, that your abhorrence thereof was so excited, that you publickly held forth this true and invaluable doctrine, which is worthy to be recorded and remember’d in all Succeeding ages. “We hold these truths to be Self evident, that all men are created equal, and that they are endowed by their creator with certain unalienable rights, that among these are life, liberty, and the pursuit of happyness.”

¶13Here Sir, was a time in which your tender feelings for your selves had engaged you thus to declare, you were then impressed with proper ideas of the great valuation of liberty, and the free possession of those blessings to which you were entitled by nature; but Sir how pitiable is it to reflect, that altho you were so fully convinced of the benevolence of the Father of mankind, and of his equal and impartial distribution of those rights and privileges which he had conferred upon them, that you should at the Same time counteract his mercies, in detaining by fraud and violence so numerous a part of my brethren under groaning captivity and cruel oppression, that you should at the Same time be found guilty of that most criminal act, which you professedly detested in others, with respect to yourselves.

¶14Sir, I suppose that your knowledge of the situation of my brethren is too extensive to need a recital here; neither shall I presume to prescribe methods by which they may be relieved; otherwise than by recommending to you and all others, to wean yourselves from these narrow prejudices which you have imbibed with respect to them, and as Job proposed to his friends “Put your Souls in their Souls stead,” thus shall your hearts be enlarged with kindness and benevolence toward them, and thus shall you need neither the direction of myself or others in what manner to proceed herein.

¶15And now, Sir, altho my Sympathy and affection for my brethren hath caused my enlargement thus far, I ardently hope that your candour and generosity will plead with you in my behalf, when I make known to you, that it was not originally my design; but that having taken up my pen in order to direct to you as a present, a copy of an Almanack which I have calculated for the Succeeding year, I was unexpectedly and unavoidably led thereto.

¶16This calculation, Sir, is the production of my arduous Study in this my advanced Stage of life; for having long had unbounded desires to become acquainted with the Secrets of nature, I have had to gratify my curiosity herein thro my own assiduous application to Astronomical Study, in which I need not to recount to you the many difficulties and disadvantages which I have had to encounter.

¶17And altho I had almost declined to make my calculation for the ensuing year, in consequence of that time which I had allotted therefor being taking up at the Federal Territory by the request of Mr. Andrew Ellicott, yet finding myself under Several engagements to printers of this state to whom I had communicated my design, on my return to my place of residence, I industriously apply’d myself thereto, which I hope I have accomplished with correctness and accuracy, a copy of which I have taken the liberty to direct to you, and which I humbly request you will favourably receive, and altho you may have the opportunity of perusing it after its publication, yet I chose to send it to you in manuscript previous thereto, that thereby you might not only have an earlier inspection, but that you might also view it in my own hand writing.—And now Sir, I shall conclude and Subscribe my Self with the most profound respect your most Obedient humble Servant,

¶18Benjamin Banneker

¶19NB any communication to me may be had by a direction to Mr. Elias Ellicott merchant in Baltimore Town.

¶20B B

¶21As an Essay of my calculation is put into the hand of Mr. Cruckshank of philadelphia, for publication I would wish that you might neither have this Almanack copy published nor give any printer an opportunity thereof, as it might tend to disappoint Mr. Joseph Cruckshank in his sale.

¶22B B

¶23*My Father was brought here a S[lav]e from Africa.

Text: Benjamin Banneker to Thomas Jefferson, 19 August 1791, The Papers of Thomas Jefferson, vol. 22 (Princeton University Press, 1986), via Founders Online, National Archives.

Paragraph by paragraph what each part does

  1. 1

    Paragraphs 1 to 5: A careful opening

    Banneker dates the letter from Baltimore County, near Ellicott’s Lower Mills, and addresses Jefferson as ‘Sir’. He says he knows that writing to a man in Jefferson’s distinguished station is a great freedom, given the prejudice against people of his complexion. He then states that Black people have long suffered abuse and contempt and been considered more brutish than human.

    Why it mattersThe humble tone is strategic. Banneker shows that he understands the rules of polite correspondence, which already undercuts the prejudice he describes, and he names that prejudice in his first sentences so the reader cannot miss what the letter is about.

  2. 2

    Paragraphs 6 to 9: One Father, one family

    Banneker says he has heard Jefferson is less rigid than many others and friendly toward Black people. If that is true, Jefferson will want to clear away false ideas about them and will agree that one universal Father made everyone of one flesh, with the same sensations and faculties. People who claim human rights and profess Christianity must extend them to everyone, and if Jefferson’s love of liberty is sincere he cannot rest until every individual enjoys it.

    Why it mattersThe argument depends on conditions: ‘if this is founded in truth’, ‘if these are Sentiments of which you are fully persuaded’. Each ‘if’ lets Banneker praise Jefferson while setting a test that Jefferson’s own conduct fails.

  3. 3

    Paragraph 10: Of the African race

    Banneker freely acknowledges that he is of the African race, of the deepest color. With deep gratitude to God he says that he is not held in the cruel captivity that so many of his brethren suffer, and that he has enjoyed the blessings of liberty. A short note at the end of the letter adds that his father was brought from Africa enslaved.

    Why it mattersThis is the turning point in Banneker’s self-presentation. He claims his identity openly and with pride, and makes himself the evidence for his argument: a free Black man writing to the Secretary of State as an equal in learning.

  4. 4

    Paragraphs 11 to 14: The Declaration turned around

    Banneker asks Jefferson to recall the Revolution, when British power tried to reduce Americans to servitude and only Providence preserved them. Then, he says, Jefferson saw the injustice of slavery and wrote that all men are created equal with unalienable rights. Yet Jefferson now keeps so many of Banneker’s brethren in captivity by fraud and violence, guilty of the act he condemned in others. Banneker will not prescribe a remedy, only ask Jefferson to put his soul in their souls’ place, as Job said to his friends.

    Why it mattersBanneker uses Jefferson’s most famous words as the measure of Jefferson’s conduct. The phrase ‘how pitiable is it to reflect’ keeps the tone polite while the charge underneath it, hypocrisy, is as direct as any in the letter.

  5. 5

    Paragraphs 15 to 23: The almanac and the postscripts

    Banneker says his sympathy for his brethren led him further than he intended, since he first took up his pen to send the almanac. He describes years of astronomical study in his old age, an interruption for the federal survey with Andrew Ellicott, and his promise to printers. He sends the almanac in manuscript so Jefferson can see it in his own hand. He signs, adds two postscripts with his address and a request not to publish it, and a note about his father.

    Why it mattersThe ending returns from argument to evidence. The almanac in Banneker’s handwriting is the practical answer to the doubts about Black intellect, and its careful, businesslike description reminds Jefferson that the writer is a working man of science.

Rhetorical choices what the writer does, and why it works

Direct address

Banneker writes ‘Sir’ more than a dozen times, often to open a paragraph. The repeated address is respectful, but it also keeps Jefferson personally in view at every step, so he cannot treat the argument as being about someone else.

Conditional reasoning

Paragraphs 7 to 9 rest on ‘if’ clauses: if the report of Jefferson’s kindness is true, if he holds these sentiments, if his love of liberty is sincere. Each condition flatters Jefferson and traps him, since admitting the premise commits him to the conclusion.

Allusion to the Declaration of Independence

In paragraph 12 Banneker quotes Jefferson’s own words, that all men are created equal with unalienable rights. Quoting the reader to himself is the letter’s strongest move: Banneker needs no new principle, only Jefferson’s.

Biblical allusion

Banneker echoes Scripture throughout: God as the Father of all, ‘every good and perfect gift’ (from the Letter of James), and Job’s words in paragraph 14. These appeals share ground with a Christian reader and place equality under God’s authority, not only Banneker’s.

Juxtaposition

Paragraphs 11 to 13 set Jefferson’s fear of British ‘Servitude’ beside his own ‘detaining by fraud and violence’ of enslaved people. Placing the two side by side lets the contradiction speak for itself.

Parallelism

Repeated structures drive the key passages: ‘we have long’ three times in paragraph 5, and ‘you cannot but’ in paragraphs 8 and 11. The repetition builds pressure while the sentences stay measured and calm.

People & audiences

Benjamin Banneker

Writer

A free Black farmer, mathematician and astronomer in his sixtieth year. He presents himself as both a petitioner for his brethren and the living proof of his case.

Thomas Jefferson

Recipient

Secretary of State and author of the Declaration of Independence. Banneker treats him as a man of good reputation whose conduct contradicts his own principles.

My brethren

The enslaved

The Black people held in slavery, whom Banneker calls his brethren. They are the people the letter pleads for, kept in ‘groaning captivity and cruel oppression’.

The universal Father

God

The creator who gave all people the same flesh and faculties. Banneker makes him the ground of human equality and the source of the liberty Jefferson enjoys.

Job

Biblical figure

The sufferer of the Book of Job, whose words Banneker borrows to ask Jefferson to imagine himself in the place of the enslaved.

Andrew Ellicott

Surveyor

The surveyor who brought Banneker to work on the survey of the federal territory, which took time away from the almanac.

Big ideas in Letter to Thomas Jefferson

EqualityHypocrisyIntellect and prejudiceReligion and dutyLiberty as a gift

Equality

Banneker’s argument begins and ends with equal creation: one Father, one flesh, the same faculties. He shows that the principle Jefferson wrote into the Declaration cannot be limited to white Americans.

Hypocrisy

The center of the letter accuses Jefferson of condemning servitude when the British threatened it and practicing slavery himself. Banneker frames this with pity rather than anger, which makes the charge harder to dismiss.

Intellect and prejudice

Banneker answers the claim that Black people lack mental gifts with his almanac and with the letter itself. The writing is the evidence.

Religion and duty

Banneker argues that Christianity and gratitude to Providence require Americans to share the blessings they received. Religious duty becomes a reason to end slavery.

Liberty as a gift

Americans’ freedom, he says, came from ‘the immediate hand’ of God. Those who received liberty as a gift cannot justly deny it to others.

Key images

The almanac

Banneker’s astronomical tables stand for Black intellectual ability. Sending them in his own handwriting makes the proof personal and impossible to credit to anyone else.

The Declaration of Independence

Jefferson’s own words stand for the nation’s promise. Banneker holds them up as the standard that Jefferson’s conduct fails to meet.

Repeated words and ideas

Sir. The respectful address returns in paragraph after paragraph. It keeps the letter formal, and it keeps the accusation aimed at one reader.

Captivity and liberty. Words for bondage (‘thraldom’, ‘captivity’, ‘Servitude’, ‘oppression’) alternate with words for freedom (‘liberty’, ‘blessings’, ‘rights’). The pairing shows that Jefferson’s freedom and his brethren’s captivity exist side by side.

Tensions and counterarguments

Principle vs. practice. Jefferson wrote that all men are created equal yet held people in slavery. Banneker’s letter is built to make that gap impossible to ignore.

Prejudice vs. evidence. The general belief that Black people lack mental ability meets one Black man’s almanac and letter. Banneker sets his own work against the prejudice.

Key quotes

“we are a race of Beings who have long laboured under the abuse and censure of the world, that we have long been looked upon with an eye of contempt, and that we have long been considered rather as brutish than human, and Scarcely capable of mental endowments.”
Paragraph 5. Three parallel clauses built on ‘have long’ name the prejudice in plain terms. The last one, about mental endowments, is the charge the almanac answers.
“one universal Father hath given being to us all, and that he hath not only made us all of one flesh, but that he hath also without partiality afforded us all the Same Sensations, and endued us all with the same faculties”
Paragraph 7. The religious foundation of the argument. If God gave everyone the same faculties, a claim of natural inferiority cannot stand.
“Sir I freely and Chearfully acknowledge, that I am of the African race, and in that colour which is natural to them of the deepest dye,”
Paragraph 10. Banneker claims his identity openly. ‘Freely and Chearfully’ turns what prejudice treats as a mark of shame into a statement of pride.
“that you should at the Same time counteract his mercies, in detaining by fraud and violence so numerous a part of my brethren under groaning captivity and cruel oppression, that you should at the Same time be found guilty of that most criminal act, which you professedly detested in others, with respect to yourselves.”
Paragraph 13. The accusation of hypocrisy. ‘At the Same time’, said twice, ties Jefferson’s principles and his practice together so he cannot separate them.
“to wean yourselves from these narrow prejudices which you have imbibed with respect to them, and as Job proposed to his friends “Put your Souls in their Souls stead,””
Paragraph 14. Instead of a plan, Banneker asks for imagination: Jefferson should picture himself in the place of the enslaved, as Job asked his friends to do.
“that thereby you might not only have an earlier inspection, but that you might also view it in my own hand writing.”
Paragraph 17. The almanac in Banneker’s handwriting is the final proof. It is meant to show that the work is his own.
How it ends

The conclusion of Letter to Thomas Jefferson, explained

After the hardest paragraphs, Banneker steps back. He says his sympathy for his brethren carried him further than he meant to go, because he first took up his pen only to send the almanac. That explanation is gracious, but it is not a retreat. The almanac is the argument in another form. Banneker describes the years of study it took, in his ‘advanced Stage of life’, the many difficulties of teaching himself astronomy, and the interruption when Andrew Ellicott asked him to help survey the federal territory. He finished it anyway, because printers were expecting it. Then he explains why he sends it in manuscript: so that Jefferson can see the work ‘in my own hand writing’. In a world where people suspected that any learned work by a Black man must really be a white man’s, the handwriting matters. The letter ends with the formal closing of the period, ‘your most Obedient humble Servant’. Readers often notice the irony of a free Black man signing himself ‘Servant’ to an enslaver after a letter about servitude, though the phrase was the ordinary closing of the time. Two postscripts add practical details, an address and a request not to publish the almanac before its printer could sell it. The last line is Banneker’s own note: his father was brought here from Africa enslaved. Placed at the very end, it reminds Jefferson that the man who made the almanac is one generation away from the captivity the letter protests.

Common misreadings

MythBanneker was enslaved.

ActuallyHe was born free in Maryland in 1731 and says in paragraph 10 that he is not in ‘tyrannical thraldom’. His own note says it was his father who was brought from Africa enslaved.

MythThe letter is mainly about the almanac.

ActuallyBanneker says the almanac was his first reason for writing, but most of the letter argues against prejudice and slavery. The almanac becomes the evidence for that argument.

MythJefferson never answered.

ActuallyJefferson replied on August 30, 1791, politely, and sent the almanac to the Academy of Sciences in Paris. He went on enslaving people at Monticello.

MythBanneker attacks Jefferson in an angry tone.

ActuallyThe letter is consistently polite, full of ‘Sir’ and expressions of respect. The force comes from logic and Jefferson’s own words, not from insults.

AP practice a rhetorical analysis prompt in the exam's style

In 1791 Benjamin Banneker, a free Black astronomer and mathematician, sent Secretary of State Thomas Jefferson a copy of his almanac along with a letter. Read the letter carefully. Then write an essay that analyzes the rhetorical choices Banneker makes to argue against slavery.

What a strong response notices

  • The humble, respectful opening in paragraphs 4 and 5 and the repeated address ‘Sir’, which earn a hearing and keep the argument personal.
  • The conditional ‘if’ clauses in paragraphs 7 to 9, which praise Jefferson’s reputation while committing him to Banneker’s conclusion.
  • The appeals to God as ‘one universal Father’ and to Christian duty, which ground equality in a shared faith.
  • The quotation of the Declaration of Independence in paragraph 12 and the accusation of hypocrisy in paragraph 13.
  • The return to the almanac in paragraphs 15 to 17, offered in Banneker’s own handwriting as evidence against prejudice.

Practice prompt written by StoryBites, not taken from a College Board exam. See the AP Language free-response guide for how answers are scored.

Test yourself

1. What was Banneker sending Jefferson along with the letter?

2. Which document does Banneker quote back to Jefferson?

3. What does Banneker accuse Jefferson of in paragraph 13?

4. Why does Banneker mention Job?

5. Why does Banneker send the almanac in manuscript rather than waiting for the printed copy?

Flashcards flip, self-grade, and the deck remembers what you know

tap to flip
Answer

Explain it like I’m 12

Benjamin Banneker was a free Black man in Maryland who taught himself astronomy and math. In 1791 he made an almanac, a book that predicts things like sunrises and the moon, and sent it to Thomas Jefferson. Jefferson had written that all men are created equal, but he also owned enslaved people and had written that Black people might not be as smart as white people. Banneker’s letter is very polite, but it points out that Jefferson was not living up to his own words. The almanac, in Banneker’s own handwriting, showed what a Black man’s mind could do.

Compare & connect

The Declaration of Independence

Thomas Jefferson

Banneker quotes the Declaration to its author. Reading the source shows exactly which promise he holds Jefferson to.

What to the Slave Is the Fourth of July?

Frederick Douglass

Sixty years later Douglass also measures the nation against its founding words. Where Banneker is courteous, Douglass is openly scornful, so the two show very different ways to make the same charge.

Letter from Birmingham Jail

Martin Luther King Jr.

Another letter to powerful readers who claim to share the writer’s values. Like Banneker, King argues from their own principles and religion, and keeps a respectful tone while making a hard charge.

Discussion and essay prompts:

💬 Discussion questions

  • What is the main argument of Banneker’s letter to Jefferson
  • Why did Benjamin Banneker write to Thomas Jefferson
  • How does Banneker use the Declaration of Independence
  • How does Letter to Thomas Jefferson explore the theme of equality?
  • How does Letter to Thomas Jefferson explore the theme of hypocrisy?
  • What is the central conflict in Letter to Thomas Jefferson, and how does it shape the ending?

✎ Essay prompts

  1. Analyze how Benjamin Banneker develops the theme of equality in Letter to Thomas Jefferson. Support your argument with specific evidence from the text.
  2. Examine the significance of the almanac in Letter to Thomas Jefferson. What does it represent, and how does it deepen the work’s meaning?
  3. How does Benjamin Banneker use direct address to shape the reader’s experience of Letter to Thomas Jefferson?
  4. Some readers assume that banneker was enslaved. Argue for or against this interpretation, using evidence from the text.

Key questions students ask

  • What is the main argument of Banneker’s letter to Jefferson
  • Why did Benjamin Banneker write to Thomas Jefferson
  • How does Banneker use the Declaration of Independence
  • What rhetorical strategies does Banneker use in his letter
  • How did Jefferson respond to Banneker
  • Why does Banneker mention his almanac

Analysis is original StoryBites commentary. The full text and quotations follow the letter Jefferson received, as transcribed in The Papers of Thomas Jefferson, volume 22, and published on Founders Online by the National Archives; the editors’ notes are not reproduced. The letter is in the public domain. An excerpt from the letter was the passage for the rhetorical analysis question on the 2010 AP English Language exam (College Board free-response questions, 2010).

Share this guide

Continue exploring

Follow a thread — every work connects to others through what they share.