Toussaint L'Ouverture
Eight months into the Civil War, a Boston abolitionist tells the story of the Haitian general Toussaint L’Ouverture and offers it as proof that Black people can match any race in courage, statesmanship and honor.
Free, all of it. No ads, no account, no paywall, no trial, nothing to cancel.
📖 Read the full textThe complete speech, paired with the StoryBites version of every sectionIn December 1861, with the Civil War eight months old and the Union army still turning away Black volunteers, the abolitionist Wendell Phillips gave audiences in New York and Boston a lecture about Toussaint L’Ouverture, the formerly enslaved general who led the revolution in the French colony of Saint-Domingue, now Haiti. Phillips calls it ‘at once a biography and an argument’. The life of one Black soldier and statesman is his evidence that the race most white Americans despised deserved a place beside their own. The lecture is long and theatrical, with the crowd’s cheers printed in brackets, and it ends in a famous peroration. The AP exam printed three short pieces of it: the passage where Phillips says he must tell the story from the lips of his subject’s enemies (paragraph 13 in our text), the ‘thunderbolt’ comparison with Cromwell (the end of paragraph 15), and the close, from ‘I would call him Cromwell’ to the end (paragraphs 38 and 39).
The claim
Judged by the facts of history, Black people are entitled to a place beside the white ‘Saxon’ race, and Toussaint L’Ouverture proves it. An enslaved man who built an army, defeated three European powers, governed with mercy and foresight, kept his word, and died betrayed in a French prison deserves to be ranked above Cromwell, Napoleon and even Washington.
The rhetorical situation who, to whom, when, and why
Saint-Domingue (Haiti), 1789 to 1804
France’s wealthiest colony, built on sugar and the labor of about half a million enslaved people, which became the independent nation of Haiti.
Fort de Joux, eastern France
The mountain fortress near the Swiss border where Toussaint was imprisoned and died in April 1803. Phillips calls it the Castle of St. Joux.
December 1861
When Phillips gave the lecture in New York and Boston, during the first winter of the Civil War, before emancipation and before Black men could enlist in the Union army.
What Toussaint L'Ouverture says
Phillips opens by saying that races like to be judged by their great men and by the average of their people, and by three tests: courage, purpose and endurance. He will try to prove that the Black race deserves a place beside the white. He describes Saint-Domingue around 1789: the wealthiest colony in the French empire, about thirty thousand whites, a large class of free people of mixed race who were educated and propertied but denied equal rights, and half a million enslaved people. When the French Revolution came, the free men of color asked Paris for equal rights. Phillips tells how the colonists tore up the decree and broke Vincent Ogé on the wheel, and he insists that if later violence followed, white people set the example. With the colony divided and invaded, he says, the governor armed the enslaved to support the old government, and the rising of August 1791 followed. Then Toussaint appears: born enslaved, self-taught, nearly fifty, merciful to his old master and to prisoners. Phillips measures him against Cromwell and finds him greater, since he made an army out of people degraded by slavery and beat Spain, France and Britain. As a statesman, Phillips says, he invited exiled planters home, sent his soldiers back to the fields, opened the ports to free trade and promised religious freedom. Napoleon, jealous or ambitious, sent a great army to restore slavery. Toussaint resisted, burned the land, submitted to save lives, and was seized by treachery and shipped to France, where he died in a mountain prison. Phillips describes the cruelty of the war that followed and the final French defeat, and argues that the Haitians’ courage and their sixty years of independence pass every test. He ends by naming Toussaint above Napoleon, Cromwell and Washington and predicting that history will someday write his name above them all. Phillips tells this history as a partisan, and several of his facts are wrong or overstated; the chapters below note where.
The line of reasoning how the argument moves
- Sets the terms of the trialParagraphs 1 and 2 frame the lecture as a contest of races judged by great men, masses, and three tests: courage, purpose and endurance. Phillips borrows his audience’s own measure of ‘Saxon’ greatness so that he can turn it.
- Assigns the blame for violenceParagraphs 3 to 11 describe the colony and the Revolution and stress white cruelty, above all the execution of Ogé. Paragraph 10 asks ‘Who set the example?’ before any Black violence appears, so listeners cannot use it against his hero.
- Introduces the man through his mercyParagraphs 12 to 14 show Toussaint saving his former master and fifteen hundred prisoners. Leading with character rather than battles answers the stereotype of the savage before it can be raised.
- Measures him against heroesParagraphs 15 to 20 compare Toussaint with Cromwell, Napoleon, Robert Peel and Roger Williams, and challenge the ‘blue-eyed Saxon’ to name a white statesman as great. The audience’s own heroes become the yardstick.
- Tells the betrayalParagraphs 21 to 30 follow Napoleon’s invasion, Toussaint’s surrender and arrest, and his death in prison. Phillips makes the white emperor the liar and the Black general the man of honor.
- Applies the tests and crowns himParagraphs 31 to 39 apply the three tests to the Haitian people, then reach the famous close, ‘I would call him Napoleon … Cromwell … Washington’, which places Toussaint above them all.
Section by section what each part does
- 1
Races on trial and an island in revolt
Phillips states his aim: to prove that the Black race deserves a place close beside the white. He describes Saint-Domingue around 1789, its luxury, its enslaved majority, and the free people of mixed race who held property but were barred from office and humiliated by law. He tells how the free men of color appealed to revolutionary France, how the colonists defied the decree and executed Ogé, and how, with the island divided among royalists, republicans, Spain and Britain, the governor appealed to the enslaved. Fifteen thousand rose in August 1791 under Jean-François and Biassou, and Phillips argues that whites taught the lesson of bloodshed. The section ends with the island at war on every side and Toussaint about to appear.
Why it mattersPhillips builds a courtroom before he calls his witness. Several details are his own reading or are compressed: the body in Paris was the National Assembly, not the Convention, which first met in 1792, and while the rebels of 1791 did fly royalist banners and rumors of royalist plotting spread, the rising is generally described as a revolt planned by the enslaved themselves, not a force raised by the governor. His race language (‘unmixed negro’, ‘Saxon’) is the vocabulary of 1861, and his argument accepts the idea of ranking races even as it attacks the ranking.
- 2
The soldier and the statesman
Toussaint is introduced as born enslaved, taught to read by an old man, a reader of Epictetus and Plutarch, a coachman and herb doctor who joined the army at about fifty after sending his master’s family to safety. Phillips says he must tell the story from his enemies’ testimony. He describes Toussaint saving fifteen hundred French prisoners, driving out Spain, defeating the British general Maitland, and rescuing the French governor Laveaux, and explains the name L’Ouverture, ‘the opening’. He then compares him with Cromwell and finds him greater, and praises his statesmanship: inviting planters home, sending soldiers back to work, opening the ports to the world, and declaring that he knew no difference between religions.
Why it mattersThe section holds the passages the exam printed from the middle of the lecture, and its rhetoric is comparison. The history is shaded. Records found in the 20th century show Toussaint was free by the 1770s; Phillips leaves out that he fought for Spain against France in 1793 and 1794, changing sides after France abolished slavery; the British lost most of their men to disease and left in 1798 under an agreement Maitland made with Toussaint; Toussaint’s labor rules tied former slaves to the plantations; and his constitution of 1801 made Catholicism the only religion practiced in public, which does not match the tolerant line Phillips quotes. The story of the name is one of several.
- 3
Napoleon’s army
By 1801, Phillips says, the island was peaceful and prosperous. Napoleon decided to retake it, perhaps to occupy idle republican troops, perhaps from jealousy of ‘the Black Napoleon’. Phillips lists the likenesses between the two men, from their plain coats to their power over soldiers, and tells how Toussaint had his own nephew Moïse shot to keep his promise to protect returning whites. Leclerc arrives with a great fleet to restore slavery. Toussaint orders the land burned, Christophe sets fire to Cap-Français rather than surrender it, and the French are beaten in the field and turn to lies, winning over Toussaint’s officers until he too agrees to submit. Phillips defends him for trusting the French and tells how Toussaint once warned the British general Maitland of a French plot.
Why it mattersThe Napoleon comparison lets Phillips rank the two by character, and character favors Toussaint: the Frenchman breaks his word, the Black general keeps his. The broad outline is right. Leclerc landed in February 1802, Christophe burned Cap-Français, and after Christophe went over to the French that spring, Toussaint made peace in May. Napoleon did restore slavery in Guadeloupe and French Guiana in 1802, so the fear Phillips describes was justified. His numbers of ships and men are speaker’s round figures.
- 4
The dungeon and the verdict of history
Toussaint is seized at a meeting with French officers and shipped to France, telling the captain that he is only a branch of a tree of liberty planted too deep to uproot. Phillips describes his cold stone cell, his unanswered letters to Napoleon, his reduced allowance, and his death, which Phillips blames on deliberate starvation. He tells of the war that followed: the drowning of Maurepas and his men, Dessalines’s reprisal, French tortures and bloodhounds, the death of Leclerc, and the final French surrender. He then applies the three tests to the Haitian people, mentions John Brown’s raid on Virginia, notes that Haiti has kept its independence for sixty years, and closes by placing Toussaint above Napoleon, Cromwell and Washington.
Why it mattersThis is the emotional climax, and it is where Phillips is least reliable. Toussaint was arrested on June 7, 1802, held at Fort de Joux, not in Paris, and questioned there by Napoleon’s aide Caffarelli; he died on April 7, 1803, of illness made worse by cold and poor treatment, and the story of deliberate starvation is not established. The last French commander surrendered at Cap-Français, not Samana, in November 1803, and Phillips says nothing of the killing of most of the remaining French on Dessalines’s orders in 1804. The famous close, the part the exam printed, works by elimination: each white hero is named and set aside for a flaw Toussaint does not have.
Rhetorical choices what the writer does, and why it works
Comparison with great men
Phillips sets Toussaint beside Napoleon, Cromwell, Washington, Peel and Roger Williams. Measuring him with the audience’s own heroes forces listeners to apply their usual standard of greatness to a Black man.
Rhetorical questions
In paragraph 15 Phillips asks ‘out of what?’ and ‘at what?’ again and again, then answers each himself. The question-and-answer rhythm lets him stage the contrast between Cromwell’s English recruits and Toussaint’s enslaved ones.
Anaphora and elimination
Paragraph 38 repeats ‘I would call him’ three times, naming Napoleon, Cromwell and Washington and rejecting each for a fault. The pattern builds to the claim that Toussaint has no equal, and the last rejection, Washington held slaves, hits hardest in an American hall.
Appeal to hostile witnesses
Paragraph 13 says that all his evidence comes ‘from the lips of his enemies’. Admitting the weakness of his sources turns it into strength: if even Toussaint’s enemies praise him, the praise must be earned.
Direct address
Phillips speaks to his listeners as ‘blue-eyed Saxon, proud of your race’ and tells them ‘You think me a fanatic’. Naming their pride and their suspicion out loud disarms both.
Personification and prophecy
The close imagines the Muse of History choosing heroes for each nation and then writing Toussaint’s name in the sky. The image moves the judgment from the present audience, with its prejudices, to a future that Phillips claims will see clearly.
People & audiences
Toussaint L’Ouverture
Haitian general and governor
The hero of the lecture, born enslaved around 1743. Phillips presents him as soldier, statesman and martyr, and above all as a man who never broke his word.
Napoleon Bonaparte
First Consul of France
Toussaint’s rival and betrayer. Phillips uses him as the measure of genius and then as the model of a great man without honor.
Charles Leclerc
French commander
Napoleon’s brother-in-law, sent with the army of 1802. In the lecture he swears a false oath on the crucifix and dies of fever.
Henri Christophe
Toussaint’s general
Burns Cap-Français rather than let the French land unopposed. He later went over to the French, as Phillips admits, and after independence ruled northern Haiti.
Jean-Jacques Dessalines
Toussaint’s general
Answers French atrocities with reprisals and drives out the last French army. Phillips defends him; he became Haiti’s first ruler in 1804.
Vincent Ogé
Free man of color
Executed by breaking on the wheel after demanding equal rights. Phillips uses his death to show that whites began the cruelty.
Big ideas in Toussaint L'Ouverture
Prejudice and evidence
Phillips’s whole method is to set a documented life against a belief. He tells listeners they read history ‘with your prejudices’ and offers Toussaint as the fact that should change their minds.
Courage, purpose and endurance
The three tests from paragraph 1 return in paragraph 37: ‘these are the tests.’ The lecture is built to show the Haitian people passing each one.
Mercy and revenge
Phillips repeatedly shows Toussaint sparing enemies and insists that whites began the cruelty. Even when he defends Dessalines’s reprisals, he frames them as answers to French atrocities.
Honor and betrayal
Toussaint keeps his word to Maitland and to returning planters; Leclerc swears falsely and Napoleon breaks oaths. Honesty becomes the measure that sets the Black general above the white emperor.
Who writes history
Phillips notes that Toussaint left almost no writing and that his story survives only in his enemies’ accounts. The close hands the final judgment to a future ‘Muse of History’.
Key images
The thunderbolt
In paragraph 15 Toussaint forges his army into a thunderbolt, the weapon of Zeus, and hurls it at Spain, France and Britain. The image turns despised raw material into irresistible force.
The tree of liberty
Toussaint, carried off to France, calls himself only a branch of a tree planted too deep to uproot. The tree stands for Haitian freedom outliving its founder, and Phillips repeats the image in paragraph 37.
Repeated words and ideas
Measuring. Phillips keeps weighing and measuring: races in scales, Cromwell against Napoleon, the future Plutarch weighing whites against blacks. The lecture presents itself as a fair trial by evidence.
The audience’s response. The bracketed ‘[Cheers.]’ and ‘[Applause.]’ printed in the text show where the crowd reacted, and they show Phillips building agreement step by step.
Tensions and counterarguments
Freedom vs. reenslavement. The historical conflict: people who had freed themselves against a European power determined to restore slavery.
Speaker vs. audience. The rhetorical conflict: Phillips against his listeners’ assumptions. He expects them to call him a fanatic and builds every section to answer that charge.
Key quotes
“My sketch is at once a biography and an argument,—a biography, of course very brief, of a negro soldier and statesman, which I offer you as an argument in behalf of the race from which he sprung.”
“I am about to tell you the story of a negro who has left hardly one written line. I am to glean it from the reluctant testimony of Britons, Frenchmen, Spaniards,—men who despised him as a negro and a slave, and hated him because he had beaten them in many a battle.”
“Yet out of this mixed, and, as you say, despicable mass, he forged a thunderbolt and hurled it at what?”
“You think you have rooted up the tree of liberty, but I am only a branch; I have planted the tree so deep that all France can never root it up.”
“I would call him Washington, but the great Virginian held slaves. This man risked his empire rather than permit the slave-trade in the humblest village of his dominions.”
“You think me a fanatic to-night, for you read history, not with your eyes, but with your prejudices.”
The conclusion of Toussaint L'Ouverture, explained
The close is the most quoted part of the lecture and the part the AP exam printed. In paragraph 38 Phillips works by elimination. He would call Toussaint Napoleon, but Napoleon rose by broken oaths and bloodshed; Cromwell, but Cromwell was only a soldier whose state died with him; Washington, but Washington held slaves. Each great man is offered as a compliment and then withdrawn because of a flaw, and the last flaw is the one this audience cannot argue with. Against all three Phillips sets two facts about Toussaint: he never broke his word, and he risked his power rather than allow the slave trade. Then he answers the charge he knows is coming. ‘You think me a fanatic’, he says, because you read history with your prejudices. Paragraph 39 moves the verdict to the future: in fifty years, when ‘Truth gets a hearing’, the Muse of History will choose a hero for each nation, Phocion for Greece, Brutus for Rome, Hampden for England, Lafayette for France, Washington and John Brown for America, and will then write Toussaint’s name above them all in the sky. Including John Brown, hanged two years earlier for the raid on Harpers Ferry, was a provocation, and the printed text records ‘thunders of applause’. The last words list three roles, ‘the soldier, the statesman, the martyr’, which sum up the three parts of the lecture. History has not ranked Toussaint above Washington, but the Haitian Revolution is now widely studied as the only successful revolt of enslaved people to found a nation, which is the claim at the center of paragraph 36.
Common misreadings
MythPhillips was a Black speaker telling the story of his own people.
ActuallyPhillips was a white Bostonian from a prominent family. He speaks to white listeners as a fellow ‘Saxon’, which is part of his strategy.
MythEverything Phillips says about Toussaint is accurate history.
ActuallyHe is an advocate. He leaves out Toussaint’s service with Spain, credits him with British defeats that disease did most to cause, describes religious tolerance his constitution did not grant, and repeats an unproven story that he was starved to death.
MythToussaint led Haiti to independence.
ActuallyHe was seized in June 1802 and died in France in April 1803. Dessalines defeated the last French army and declared Haiti independent on January 1, 1804.
MythToussaint was enslaved until the revolution.
ActuallyPhillips says so, but documents found in the 20th century show that Toussaint had been freed by the mid-1770s, years before the uprising of 1791.
MythThe exam printed the speech in full.
ActuallyIt printed three short selections from a lecture of about 8,700 words, joined by ellipses: parts of paragraphs 13, 15 and 38, and all of paragraph 39.
AP practice a rhetorical analysis prompt in the exam's style
In December 1861 the white abolitionist Wendell Phillips lectured in New York and Boston on Toussaint L’Ouverture, the formerly enslaved leader of the Haitian Revolution. Read paragraphs 13, 15, 38 and 39 carefully. Then write an essay that analyzes the rhetorical choices Phillips makes to honor Toussaint and to challenge his audience’s view of race.
What a strong response notices
- The opening comparison with Napoleon and Washington in paragraph 13, and the admission that every source is an enemy, which makes their testimony a form of praise.
- The repeated questions ‘out of what?’ and ‘at what?’ in paragraph 15, and the list of three European nations, each given its proud label and its defeat.
- The appeal to proportion in paragraph 15: a small territory, like Attica, judged by quality and not quantity.
- The pattern ‘I would call him … but’ in paragraph 38, which raises each white hero and rejects him, ending with Washington’s slaves.
- The direct charge ‘You think me a fanatic’ and the prophecy of the Muse of History in paragraph 39, which move the verdict from the audience to the future.
Practice prompt written by StoryBites, not taken from a College Board exam. See the AP Language free-response guide for how answers are scored.
Test yourself
1. What does Phillips say his lecture is, besides a biography?
Paragraph 1 calls it ‘a biography … which I offer you as an argument in behalf of the race from which he sprung’. Report a mistake
2. Why does Phillips stress that his sources are Toussaint’s enemies?
If men who ‘despised him’ and ‘hated him’ still record his greatness, the audience cannot call the praise biased. Report a mistake
3. How does Phillips measure Toussaint against Cromwell in paragraph 15?
Cromwell built an army of Englishmen; Toussaint built one from people degraded by slavery and beat Spain, France and Britain. Report a mistake
4. Why does Phillips refuse to call Toussaint Washington?
Paragraph 38 says ‘the great Virginian held slaves’, while Toussaint would not allow the slave trade. Report a mistake
5. Where did Toussaint actually die?
He was held at Fort de Joux, which Phillips calls the Castle of St. Joux, and died there on April 7, 1803. Report a mistake
Flashcards flip, self-grade, and the deck remembers what you know
Toussaint L’Ouverture was born enslaved in the French colony that became Haiti. In the 1790s he led formerly enslaved people to defeat armies from Spain, Britain and France, and he governed the island until Napoleon tricked him, arrested him and left him to die in a cold French prison. In 1861, during the Civil War, Wendell Phillips, a white abolitionist, told Toussaint’s story to Northern audiences to prove that Black people were as brave and smart as anyone. He compares Toussaint to famous heroes like Napoleon and Washington and says Toussaint was greater. Some of Phillips’s facts are exaggerated, but his point was to fight prejudice.
Compare & connect
What to the Slave Is the Fourth of July?
Douglass, speaking nine years earlier, also tells white Northerners that their national heroes and holidays condemn slavery. Comparing the two shows a formerly enslaved speaker and a white ally making related charges in very different voices.
Letter to Thomas Jefferson
Banneker offers his own almanac as evidence against the claim that Black people lack ability; Phillips offers Toussaint’s life. Both argue from proof, seventy years apart.
Pericles’ Funeral Oration
A classic speech of praise that turns honoring the dead into an argument about a people’s character. Phillips’s close, with its Greek and Roman heroes, works in the same tradition.
Discussion and essay prompts:
💬 Discussion questions
- What is Wendell Phillips’s argument in his speech on Toussaint L’Ouverture
- Why does Phillips compare Toussaint to Napoleon, Cromwell and Washington
- What rhetorical strategies does Phillips use to praise Toussaint L’Ouverture
- How does Toussaint L'Ouverture explore the theme of prejudice and evidence?
- How does Toussaint L'Ouverture explore the theme of courage, purpose and endurance?
- What is the central conflict in Toussaint L'Ouverture, and how does it shape the ending?
✎ Essay prompts
- Analyze how Wendell Phillips develops the theme of prejudice and evidence in Toussaint L'Ouverture. Support your argument with specific evidence from the text.
- Examine the significance of the thunderbolt in Toussaint L'Ouverture. What does it represent, and how does it deepen the work’s meaning?
- How does Wendell Phillips use comparison with great men to shape the reader’s experience of Toussaint L'Ouverture?
- Some readers assume that phillips was a Black speaker telling the story of his own people. Argue for or against this interpretation, using evidence from the text.
Key questions students ask
- What is Wendell Phillips’s argument in his speech on Toussaint L’Ouverture
- Why does Phillips compare Toussaint to Napoleon, Cromwell and Washington
- What rhetorical strategies does Phillips use to praise Toussaint L’Ouverture
- Is Wendell Phillips’s history of Toussaint L’Ouverture accurate
- Why did Phillips give the Toussaint L’Ouverture lecture in 1861
- How did Toussaint L’Ouverture die
Analysis is original StoryBites commentary. The full text and quotations follow the lecture as printed in Wendell Phillips, Speeches, Lectures, and Letters (Boston: James Redpath, 1863), pages 468 to 494, from the Internet Archive scan of that edition, corrected against a second scan of the 1864 printing and checked against page images. The lecture is in the public domain. The exam printed three selections with cuts between them, and its text differs from the 1863 book in a few places: it spells the name ‘Toussaint-Louverture’, prints a comma where the book has a semicolon after ‘your hearts’, and writes ‘[Toussaint] forged’ where Phillips said ‘he forged’. An excerpt from the lecture was the passage for the rhetorical analysis question on the 2007 Form B AP English Language exam (College Board free-response questions, 2007 Form B).