AP Language · letter · 10 min

Letter to John Quincy Adams

Writing to her twelve-year-old son, newly sent abroad with his father in the middle of the Revolution, Abigail Adams argues that hard times are what make great characters.

⏱ 10 min to understand the letter 6 steps of reasoning · 6 rhetorical choices Public domain text
📖 Read the full text on this pageEvery paragraph numbered, so you can cite it
0% explored
The whole letter in 60 seconds

In November 1779 John Quincy Adams, aged twelve, sailed for Europe a second time with his father, John Adams, who had been sent to negotiate peace with Britain. He had not wanted to go, and his mother, Abigail, had pushed him. Two months later she wrote to him from home in Massachusetts. Her letter is short, but it packs a whole philosophy of growing up into a few paragraphs: travel improves the mind, difficulty forms character, and the boy who would rather have stayed home is living in exactly the kind of times a great mind should want.

The claim

Hardship and challenge, not comfort and ease, form great characters. John Quincy should use the advantages of travel and the dangers of a revolutionary age to improve himself, master his temper, and become a citizen worthy of his country and his family.

The rhetorical situation who, to whom, when, and why

SpeakerAbigail Adams, aged thirty-five, running the family farm and household in Braintree, Massachusetts, while her husband served abroad. She writes with a mother’s authority and a patriot’s pride.
AudienceHer eldest son, John Quincy Adams, twelve years old and on his way to Europe with his father and younger brother Charles. He grew up to become the sixth president of the United States.
OccasionA letter written soon after John Quincy left on his second voyage with his father. Letters crossed the Atlantic slowly and could be lost, so she sent more than one copy.
ExigenceJohn Quincy had been reluctant to go, and his mother had urged him to. She wants him to see the trip as an opportunity, and she wants to correct a fault she knows he has, a quick temper.
PurposeTo encourage her son to make the most of his travels and his times, to measure himself against great figures of history, and to build the self-control that good character requires.
ContextThe Revolutionary War was still being fought, with France as America’s ally since 1778. John Adams had been sent to Europe to negotiate peace with Britain, the ‘important Embassy’ the letter mentions.
Place

Braintree, Massachusetts, and the Atlantic crossing

Adams writes from home while her son travels toward France. The distance between them shapes the letter, which must give months of advice in a single sheet.

Time

January 1780

The middle of the Revolutionary War, about two months after John Quincy and his father sailed for Europe.

What Letter to John Quincy Adams says

Abigail Adams opens by hoping her son has met no enemies or dangers at sea that make him regret his second voyage to France. She admits she would not have pushed him if she had thought his reluctance came from careful thought, but she trusts he will never regret obeying her. His knowledge of French will give him more advantages now than on his first trip, and his understanding will open as he grows. She quotes an unnamed author who compares a wise traveler to a river that grows as it flows from its source, or to springs that pick up good qualities from the minerals they run through. Since he has the advantage of travelling under his father’s eye, she expects his improvement to match his opportunities. Nothing is lacking but attention, diligence and steady work. Then comes the most famous paragraph. These are times in which a genius would wish to live, she writes. Great characters are not formed in calm and peace. Cicero would not have become so great an orator without the tyranny of the men he opposed. A strong mind is formed by struggling with difficulties, and wisdom comes from experience, not from retirement and leisure. Great necessities call out great virtues, and minds stirred by events develop the qualities of heroes and statesmen. War and tyranny are scourges of God, she admits, but it is his lot to witness them while belonging to a people who have defended their liberties with the help of a powerful ally. His father’s role in that struggle should spur him on. Before she closes, she reminds him of a failing: an impetuous temper. He must correct it himself, because a fault indulged in youth grows stronger with age and becomes your conqueror. She ends by praising his regard for truth and hoping he will add justice, fortitude and every manly virtue, to honor his country and make his parents happy.

The line of reasoning how the argument moves

  1. Reassures and assertsParagraphs 3 and 4 acknowledge the boy’s reluctance but defend her decision to send him. She opens with care, then makes clear the choice was right.
  2. Names the advantagesParagraphs 4 and 5 list what the trip offers: the language, a father’s guidance, the improvements of travel. The river comparison makes growth sound natural and expected.
  3. Raises the stakesParagraph 6 makes the central claim, that difficult times form great characters. The example of Cicero gives the claim the weight of history.
  4. States the principleParagraph 7 compresses the argument into a maxim, ‘Great necessities call out great virtues’, and names the goal: the character of the hero and the statesman.
  5. Applies it to his lifeParagraphs 8 and 9 bring the principle home. The war, the alliance with France and his father’s embassy are the particular trials of his own life.
  6. Corrects and blessesParagraphs 10 and 11 turn to his temper and then to his love of truth. The letter ends by asking for self-discipline and holding out the reward of honor and his parents’ happiness.

The full text paragraphs numbered for citation

¶1Janry. 19 1780

¶2My dear Son

¶3I hope you have had no occasion either from Enemies or the Dangers of the Sea to repent your second voyage to France. If I had thought your reluctance arose from proper deliberation, or that you was capable of judgeing what was most for your own benifit, I should not have urged you to have accompanied your Father and Brother when you appeared so averse to the voyage.

¶4You however readily submitted to my advice, and I hope will never have occasion yourself, nor give me reason to Lament it. Your knowledge of the Language must give you greater advantages now, than you could possibly have reaped whilst Ignorant of it, and as you increase in years you will find your understanding opening and daily improveing.

¶5Some Author that I have met with compares a judicious traveller, to a river that increases its stream the farther it flows from its source, or to certain springs which running through rich veins of minerals improve their qualities as they pass along. It will be expected of you my son that as you are favourd with superiour advantages under the instructive Eye of a tender parent, that your improvements should bear some proportion to your advantages. Nothing is wanting with you, but attention, dilligence and steady application, Nature has not been deficient.

¶6These are times in which a Genious would wish to live. It is not in the still calm of life, or the repose of a pacific station, that great characters are formed. Would Cicero have shone so distinguished an orater, if he had not been roused, kindled and enflamed by the Tyranny of Catiline, Millo, Verres and Mark Anthony. The Habits of a vigorous mind are formed in contending with difficulties. All History will convince you of this, and that wisdom and penetration are the fruits of experience, not the Lessons of retirement and leisure.

¶7Great necessities call out great virtues. When a mind is raised, and animated by scenes that engage the Heart, then those qualities which would otherways lay dormant, wake into Life, and form the Character of the Hero and the Statesman.

¶8War, Tyrrany and Desolation are the Scourges of the Almighty, and ought no doubt to be deprecated. Yet it is your Lot my Son to be an Eye witness of these Calimities in your own Native land, and at the same time to owe your existance among a people who have made a glorious defence of their invaded Liberties, and who, aided by a generous and powerfull Ally, with the blessing of heaven will transmit this inheritance to ages yet unborn.

¶9Nor ought it to be one of the least of your excitements towards exerting every power and faculty of your mind, that you have a parent who has taken so large and active a share in this contest, and discharged the trust reposed in him with so much satisfaction as to be honourd with the important Embassy, which at present calls him abroad.

¶10I cannot fulfill the whole of my duty towards you, if I close this Letter, without reminding you of a failing which calls for a strict attention and watchfull care to correct. You must do it for yourself. You must curb that impetuosity of temper, for which I have frequently chid you, but which properly directed may be productive of great good. I know you capable of these exertions, with pleasure I observed my advice was not lost upon you. If you indulge yourself in the practise of any foible or vice in youth, it will gain strength with your years and become your conquerer.

¶11The strict and invoilable regard you have ever paid to truth, gives me pleasing hopes that you will not swerve from her dictates, but add justice, fortitude, and every Manly Virtue which can adorn a good citizen, do Honour to your Country, and render your parents supreemly happy, particuliarly your ever affectionate Mother,

¶12AA

Text: Abigail Adams to John Quincy Adams, 19 January 1780, Adams Family Correspondence, vol. 3 (Harvard University Press, 1973), via Founders Online, National Archives.

Paragraph by paragraph what each part does

  1. 1

    Paragraphs 1 to 4: The voyage he did not want

    Adams dates the letter and addresses ‘My dear Son’. She hopes he has met no enemies or dangers at sea to make him regret the voyage, and admits that she urged him to go though he was unwilling. She trusts he will never regret obeying, and says his knowledge of French will give him more advantages now than on his first trip.

    Why it mattersThe opening is tender but firm. Adams acknowledges his feelings without apologizing for her decision, and she quickly shifts from what he gave up to what he will gain.

  2. 2

    Paragraph 5: The traveller and the river

    Adams cites an unnamed author who compares a wise traveler to a river that grows as it flows from its source, or to springs improved by the minerals they pass through. She expects his improvement to match his advantages, since he travels under a tender parent’s eye. Nature has given him ability; he needs only attention, diligence and steady application.

    Why it mattersThe comparisons make growth a natural process, but the paragraph also sets a standard. ‘It will be expected of you’ places responsibility on the boy: talent is given, and effort is his to supply.

  3. 3

    Paragraphs 6 to 7: Times that make great characters

    Adams writes that these are times in which a genius would wish to live, and that great characters are not formed in calm and peace. She asks whether Cicero would have become so great an orator without the tyranny of the men he opposed. A vigorous mind is formed by contending with difficulties; wisdom comes from experience, not leisure. Great necessities call out great virtues and form the hero and the statesman.

    Why it mattersThis is the heart of the letter and the passage most often quoted. Adams turns the war, which might seem only a danger, into an opportunity. Her one slip, listing Milo among Cicero’s enemies when Cicero actually defended him, does not weaken the point for her son.

  4. 4

    Paragraphs 8 to 9: A country at war, a father abroad

    Adams calls war, tyranny and desolation scourges of the Almighty that should be deplored. But it is his lot to witness them in his native land while belonging to a people who have gloriously defended their liberties, helped by a generous ally. His father’s large share in the contest, and his honored embassy, should push him to use every power of his mind.

    Why it mattersAdams balances honesty about war’s horror with pride in the cause. Pointing to his father gives the boy a model close to home and adds family duty to patriotic duty.

  5. 5

    Paragraphs 10 to 12: The failing, and the farewell

    Adams says she cannot finish without reminding him of a failing: his impetuous temper, which she has often scolded but which, properly directed, could do great good. He must correct it himself, since any fault indulged in youth grows stronger with age and becomes your conqueror. She praises his regard for truth and hopes he will add justice, fortitude and every manly virtue, honoring his country and making his parents happy. She signs as his ever affectionate mother.

    Why it mattersThe criticism comes late and is wrapped in praise on both sides. Adams treats the temper as raw energy to be directed, not simply a flaw, and the closing joins private virtue to public service.

Rhetorical choices what the writer does, and why it works

Simile

In paragraph 5 Adams borrows an author’s comparison of a wise traveler to a river that grows as it flows from its source, and to springs that gain good qualities from the minerals they pass through. The images make learning from travel sound natural and steady, and they suggest that John Quincy should come home with more than he took away.

Historical allusion

Paragraph 6 asks whether Cicero would have been so great an orator without the tyranny of Catiline, Milo, Verres and Mark Antony. The famous Roman gives her claim the authority of history and offers her son a model of greatness forged in conflict.

Rhetorical question

The Cicero question in paragraph 6 needs no answer; the obvious ‘no’ proves her point. She ends it with a full stop rather than a question mark, which makes it read almost as a statement.

Antithesis

Adams contrasts the ‘still calm of life’ and ‘the repose of a pacific station’ with being ‘roused, kindled and enflamed’, and the ‘fruits of experience’ with ‘the Lessons of retirement and leisure’. The contrasts make the choice between comfort and growth unmistakable.

Aphorism

Short, quotable maxims carry the argument: ‘Great necessities call out great virtues’, and the claim that a strong mind is formed ‘in contending with difficulties’. A twelve-year-old can carry such lines in his head long after the letter is put away.

Personification

In paragraph 10 an indulged vice will ‘become your conquerer’, and in paragraph 11 truth has ‘dictates’. Turning a bad habit into an enemy army fits the wartime setting and makes self-control a kind of battle.

People & audiences

Abigail Adams

Writer and mother

She writes with love but also with authority, setting high expectations and naming her son’s faults. Her letter blends a mother’s advice with a patriot’s vision of the times.

John Quincy Adams

Her son

Twelve years old, reluctant to travel, quick-tempered and truthful. His mother urges him to rise to the opportunities of his age.

John Adams

His father

Never named, he is the ‘tender parent’ and the man honored with ‘the important Embassy’. His service gives the boy a model and a duty.

Cicero

Historical example

The Roman orator whose greatness, Adams says, was called out by the tyrants he opposed. He stands for character formed in crisis.

The generous and powerful ally

France

The nation whose help, Adams writes, will let Americans hand their liberty down to ages yet unborn.

Big ideas in Letter to John Quincy Adams

Adversity forms characterEducation through experienceSelf-disciplineDuty to country and familyParental love and expectation

Adversity forms character

The central claim of the letter is that difficult times produce great people. Calm and comfort leave abilities asleep, while crisis wakes them.

Education through experience

Adams values the lessons of travel and events over the lessons of ‘retirement and leisure’. The world itself is John Quincy’s school.

Self-discipline

Talent needs to be governed. Adams asks her son to master his temper himself before a youthful fault becomes a lifelong master.

Duty to country and family

Adams ties personal virtue to public service. Becoming a good citizen and honoring his country is also the way to honor his parents.

Parental love and expectation

The letter is affectionate and demanding at once. Adams shows love by expecting much, and she signs as his ‘ever affectionate Mother’ after naming his fault.

Key images

The river

The river that grows as it flows from its source stands for a mind that gains strength the farther it travels from home.

Cicero

Cicero stands for the person whom crisis makes great. He gives the boy a picture of what difficulty can produce.

Repeated words and ideas

Advantages and improvement. Words like ‘advantages’, ‘benifit’ and ‘improvements’ recur in the opening paragraphs. Adams keeps reminding her son that his privileges carry obligations.

Greatness. ‘Great characters’, ‘great virtues’, ‘great necessities’, ‘great good’: the repeated word ties ordinary effort to a large ideal.

Tensions and counterarguments

Comfort vs. challenge. John Quincy would rather have stayed home. His mother argues that the hard path is the one that builds character.

Temper vs. self-control. The boy’s impetuous temper struggles against the discipline his mother asks of him, and only he can win that fight.

Key quotes

“These are times in which a Genious would wish to live.”
Paragraph 6. The letter’s most famous line. Adams recasts a frightening war as a gift to anyone with ability, because it offers the challenges that bring greatness out.
“It is not in the still calm of life, or the repose of a pacific station, that great characters are formed.”
Paragraph 6. The central claim in negative form. Comfort and peace are named first so that the reader expects the opposite to be true.
“The Habits of a vigorous mind are formed in contending with difficulties.”
Paragraph 6. A compact maxim. Strength of mind is a habit, built through struggle the way a muscle is built through effort.
“Great necessities call out great virtues.”
Paragraph 7. The repetition of ‘great’ links the size of the challenge to the size of the virtue it produces.
“Some Author that I have met with compares a judicious traveller, to a river that increases its stream the farther it flows from its source”
Paragraph 5. The simile frames travel as natural growth. Adams does not name the author, so the comparison is offered as borrowed wisdom.
“If you indulge yourself in the practise of any foible or vice in youth, it will gain strength with your years and become your conquerer.”
Paragraph 10. A warning that turns a small habit into a future enemy. The military language suits a letter written in wartime.
How it ends

The conclusion of Letter to John Quincy Adams, explained

The letter has been building a picture of greatness, and the ending brings that picture down to one boy’s behavior. Adams says she cannot fulfill her duty if she closes without naming a failing that needs strict attention. The failing is his ‘impetuosity of temper’, for which she has often scolded him. She says two things about it that change how it reads. First, he must correct it himself; no one else can. Second, the same energy, properly directed, could produce great good. The temper is not a flaw to be crushed but a force to be steered, which fits the letter’s larger argument that strong qualities need the right pressure to become virtues. Then comes a warning: a foible indulged in youth will grow with the years and ‘become your conquerer’. In a letter written during a war for independence, the image of being conquered by your own habits is pointed. The final paragraph softens the correction with praise. His ‘strict and invoilable regard’ for truth gives her hope, and she asks him to add justice, fortitude and every manly virtue. The last sentence moves outward in widening circles: adorn a good citizen, honor his country, make his parents happy. Private character, public service and family love end up as one goal. She signs as his ‘ever affectionate Mother’, and the warmth of the signature after the hard advice is the letter’s last persuasive move.

Common misreadings

MythThe famous line reads ‘These are the times in which a genius would wish to live.’

ActuallyThat modernized wording is common in quotations. The text followed here, from Abigail Adams’s own copy of the letter, reads ‘These are times in which a Genious would wish to live.’

MythAdams wants her son to become a soldier.

ActuallyShe calls war a scourge to be deplored. What she wants is for him to grow in mind and character through the challenges of his age, and to become a good citizen and statesman.

MythMilo was one of Cicero’s enemies.

ActuallyAdams lists Milo among the tyrants Cicero opposed, but Cicero actually defended Milo in court. It is a small slip in Roman history, and it does not change her argument.

MythThe letter’s date is certain.

ActuallyAdams’s letterbook copy is dated January 19, 1780, which this page follows. The copy her son received seems to have been dated January 12, so some editions print that date.

AP practice a rhetorical analysis prompt in the exam's style

In 1780 Abigail Adams wrote to her twelve-year-old son, John Quincy Adams, who had gone to Europe with his father, a diplomat for the new United States. Read the letter carefully. Then write an essay that analyzes the rhetorical choices Adams makes to persuade her son that difficult times can form a great character.

What a strong response notices

  • The opening in paragraphs 3 and 4, which acknowledges the boy’s reluctance while firmly defending the decision to send him.
  • The comparison of a traveler to a growing river in paragraph 5, and the expectation that his improvement match his advantages.
  • The allusion to Cicero and his opponents in paragraph 6, which grounds the claim about adversity in history.
  • The maxims in paragraphs 6 and 7, such as ‘Great necessities call out great virtues’, and the contrast between calm and challenge.
  • The shift in paragraph 10 to his temper, and the closing paragraph’s movement from his virtue to his country and his parents.

Practice prompt written by StoryBites, not taken from a College Board exam. See the AP Language free-response guide for how answers are scored.

Test yourself

1. Why is John Quincy Adams in Europe when his mother writes?

2. What does Adams compare a judicious traveler to?

3. What is the main claim of paragraph 6?

4. What failing does Adams ask her son to correct?

5. Which quality does Adams praise in her son in the closing paragraph?

Flashcards flip, self-grade, and the deck remembers what you know

tap to flip
Answer

Explain it like I’m 12

During the American Revolution, Abigail Adams’s twelve-year-old son, John Quincy, sailed to Europe with his father, who was working for the new country. John Quincy did not want to go, but his mother made him. In this letter she tells him that hard times are exactly when great people are made, the way the Roman speaker Cicero became great by standing up to bad leaders. She tells him to learn all he can on his trip, and to work on controlling his temper. She ends by saying she is proud of his honesty and hopes he will make his country and his parents proud. He later became the sixth president.

Compare & connect

The American Crisis, Number 1

Thomas Paine

Paine’s pamphlet opens with ‘These are the times that try men’s souls’, written three years earlier in the same war. Both writers treat a dark moment as a test that will show who is great.

Hamlet

William Shakespeare

In Act 1, Polonius gives his son Laertes a list of advice as he leaves for France. Comparing the two parents shows how differently advice to a departing son can be framed.

The American Scholar

Ralph Waldo Emerson

Emerson also argues that action and experience, not books and quiet alone, make a mind great. His address gives Adams’s idea a fuller philosophical form.

Discussion and essay prompts:

💬 Discussion questions

  • What is Abigail Adams’s main argument in her letter to John Quincy Adams
  • What does these are times in which a genius would wish to live mean
  • Why does Abigail Adams mention Cicero
  • How does Letter to John Quincy Adams explore the theme of adversity forms character?
  • How does Letter to John Quincy Adams explore the theme of education through experience?
  • What is the central conflict in Letter to John Quincy Adams, and how does it shape the ending?

✎ Essay prompts

  1. Analyze how Abigail Adams develops the theme of adversity forms character in Letter to John Quincy Adams. Support your argument with specific evidence from the text.
  2. Examine the significance of the river in Letter to John Quincy Adams. What does it represent, and how does it deepen the work’s meaning?
  3. How does Abigail Adams use simile to shape the reader’s experience of Letter to John Quincy Adams?
  4. Some readers assume that the famous line reads ‘These are the times in which a genius would wish to live.’. Argue for or against this interpretation, using evidence from the text.

Key questions students ask

  • What is Abigail Adams’s main argument in her letter to John Quincy Adams
  • What does these are times in which a genius would wish to live mean
  • Why does Abigail Adams mention Cicero
  • What rhetorical strategies does Abigail Adams use in her letter to her son
  • What advice does Abigail Adams give John Quincy Adams
  • Why was John Quincy Adams in Europe in 1780

Analysis is original StoryBites commentary. The full text and quotations follow the letter as published in Adams Family Correspondence, volume 3, on Founders Online by the National Archives; the editors’ notes are not reproduced. The letter is in the public domain. An excerpt from the letter was the passage for the rhetorical analysis question on the 2014 AP English Language exam (College Board free-response questions, 2014).

Share this guide

Continue exploring

Follow a thread — every work connects to others through what they share.