AP English Literature · 2025, Set 2 · Question 3

A secret

An important character keeps a secret that changes how they stand with other characters: it may cause conflict, give comfort, shield someone from the truth, or let one person control another. Choose a work of fiction built around such a secret, and analyze how its effect shapes an interpretation of the work as a whole.

That is our summary. The exact wording, and the instructions, are in the College Board’s free-response questions (PDF).

37 books suggested 15 with a free StoryBites Edition 8 more that fit

The suggested list

Students may write about any work of literary merit; these are the books the College Board printed with the question. Linked titles open our study edition: summary, chapter guide, characters, themes and a quiz.

Also fits: books from our library

Not on this exam’s list, but each one answers the question well. Our suggestions, with the reason.

The Strange Case of Dr Jekyll and Mr Hyde Robert Louis Stevenson Jekyll hides that Hyde is himself, and his friend Utterson suspects blackmail because of the will. The truth only comes out in Jekyll’s own statement after his death, so students can show the secret shaping the whole structure. Fences August Wilson Troy Maxson hides his affair with Alberta until he has to tell Rose that Alberta is pregnant. Students can show how the secret ends the marriage and leaves Rose raising Raynell. The Crucible Arthur Miller John Proctor hides his affair with Abigail Williams, which drives her accusations. In court Elizabeth, who never lies, lies to protect his name and so condemns him, which students can use to show a secret turning on its keeper. Trifles Susan Glaspell Mrs Hale and Mrs Peters find Minnie Wright’s dead canary in her sewing box and hide it from the sheriff and county attorney. Students can show how the women’s shared secret protects Minnie and judges the men. Tess of the d'Urbervilles Thomas Hardy Tess hides her past with Alec, and the letter she pushes under Angel’s door slides beneath the carpet. When she confesses on their wedding night he leaves her, though he has just confessed his own past. The Mayor of Casterbridge Thomas Hardy Henchard hides that he once sold his wife at a fair, and later hides that Elizabeth-Jane is not his daughter, even telling her father Newson she has died. Students can trace each secret coming back on him. The Age of Innocence Edith Wharton May tells Ellen she is pregnant before she is sure, and Ellen leaves for Europe. Years later Newland learns May always knew what he had given up, so students can show a quiet secret controlling everyone. The Importance of Being Earnest Oscar Wilde Jack is Ernest in town and Algernon invents a sick friend called Bunbury so each can escape his duties. Students can show Wilde using double lives to mock a society that cares more about names than truth.

Writing it

  1. Pick the book you know best, not the one that sounds most impressive. You need specific moments, from memory.
  2. Name the character and the moment the prompt is about, then say what it shows about the work as a whole. That claim is your thesis.
  3. Build each paragraph on one moment and explain how it supports the claim. The rubric, decoded shows where the points are.