AP English Literature · 2024, Set 1 · Question 3

Indecision

A character delays, avoids or refuses a decision, and the delay costs something: a relationship, money, social standing, health or peace of mind, theirs or other people’s. Choose a work of fiction with such a character, and analyze how the impact of the indecision shapes an interpretation of the work as a whole.

That is our summary. The exact wording, and the instructions, are in the College Board’s free-response questions (PDF).

38 books suggested 11 with a free StoryBites Edition 7 more that fit

The suggested list

Students may write about any work of literary merit; these are the books the College Board printed with the question. Linked titles open our study edition: summary, chapter guide, characters, themes and a quiz.

Also fits: books from our library

Not on this exam’s list, but each one answers the question well. Our suggestions, with the reason.

Hamlet William Shakespeare Hamlet puts off revenge again and again, even sparing Claudius at prayer. Students can show the delay costing Polonius, Ophelia, Gertrude, Laertes and finally Hamlet himself. Ethan Frome Edith Wharton Ethan loves Mattie but cannot bring himself to leave Zeena or find another way out. His failure to choose ends in the sledding crash that leaves him and Mattie crippled and tied to the farm. Waiting for Godot Samuel Beckett Vladimir and Estragon wait each day for a man who never comes, talk of leaving or hanging themselves, and do neither. Both acts end with them agreeing to go and not moving, which students can treat as the play’s argument. The Cherry Orchard Anton Chekhov Ranevskaya and her brother Gaev ignore Lopakhin’s plan to save the estate and talk instead of acting, so it is sold at auction. Lopakhin also never proposes to Varya, so students can show indecision costing several characters. The Crucible Arthur Miller John Proctor knows Abigail told him the girls’ sickness had nothing to do with witchcraft, but he puts off telling the court. By the time he acts Elizabeth is accused, so students can show what his delay cost. The Catcher in the Rye J. D. Salinger Holden keeps saying he will call Jane Gallagher and never does, and he puts off going home for days. Students can show how avoiding every decision deepens his loneliness and his breakdown. The Glass Menagerie Tennessee Williams Tom Wingfield stays for years in a warehouse job he hates, dreaming of escape like his father, while his mother pushes him to find Laura a caller. When he finally leaves, his guilt about Laura follows him.

Writing it

  1. Pick the book you know best, not the one that sounds most impressive. You need specific moments, from memory.
  2. Name the character and the moment the prompt is about, then say what it shows about the work as a whole. That claim is your thesis.
  3. Build each paragraph on one moment and explain how it supports the claim. The rubric, decoded shows where the points are.