AP Language · speech · 10 min

Speech on Child Labor

Speaking to a women’s suffrage convention in 1905, Kelley makes the children working through the night in American mills the strongest reason why women need the vote.

⏱ 10 min to understand the speech 6 steps of reasoning · 6 rhetorical choices Public domain text
📖 Read the full text on this pageEvery paragraph numbered, so you can cite it
0% explored
The whole speech in 60 seconds

In the summer of 1905 the National American Woman Suffrage Association held its annual convention in Portland, Oregon. Florence Kelley, a social reformer who had spent years inspecting factories, stood up before a room of women who had been asking for the vote for decades. She did not tell them the vote was owed to them. She told them that at that very hour thousands of little girls were working through the night in textile mills, spinning the cloth the women in the room would buy, and that the law allowed it because the people who might have stopped it could not vote. The speech is short, and almost every sentence of it is a fact or a question.

The claim

Children as young as six are working long hours, often at night, because state legislatures refuse to protect them, and those legislatures would act differently if mothers could vote. Until women have the ballot, everyone who buys what children make shares in the wrong, so suffragists should join workingmen in the fight to free the children.

The rhetorical situation who, to whom, when, and why

SpeakerFlorence Kelley, general secretary of the National Consumers’ League, which campaigned for decent working conditions by organizing shoppers. She had been the chief factory inspector of Illinois in the 1890s, and at this convention she was one of the suffrage association’s officers. Her authority is that of someone who has seen the mills and read the statutes.
AudienceThe delegates at the National Suffrage Convention, mostly middle-class women committed to winning the vote. Kelley speaks to them as ‘we’ and points at what they wear and buy. A second audience came a few weeks later: readers of The Woman’s Journal, the suffrage weekly that printed the speech.
OccasionThe association’s 37th annual convention, held in Portland, Oregon, in the summer of 1905. Kelley spoke at an evening session (‘No one in this room to-night’, paragraph 10), and her first sentence answers a point another speaker had made the previous Saturday.
ExigenceThere was no federal child labor law. Each state set its own rules, and paragraphs 5 to 8 show how weak they were: Georgia set no limit at all, and New Jersey had just repealed a law that ended the working day at six in the evening.
PurposeTo show the delegates that the vote is not only a right to be won but a tool they need for urgent work, and to persuade them to make common cause with organized labor, whose men already had the ballot.
ContextThe Woman’s Journal of Boston printed the speech on July 22, 1905, under the heading ‘The Young Breadwinners’ Need of Women’s Enfranchisement.’ A federal child labor law passed in 1916 was struck down by the Supreme Court in 1918; lasting federal limits came only with the Fair Labor Standards Act of 1938. The speech was the passage for the rhetorical analysis question on the 2011 AP English Language exam.
Place

The National Suffrage Convention, Portland, Oregon

The 37th annual convention of the National American Woman Suffrage Association, in the summer of 1905. Kelley speaks in the evening, ‘in this room to-night’.

Place

Mills, coal-breakers and tenements

The places the speech takes its listeners to: the cotton mills of Georgia and the Carolinas, the coal-breakers of Pennsylvania, and the tenements where tiny children make artificial flowers under the sweating system.

What Speech on Child Labor says

Kelley opens by picking up a thought from an earlier speaker: how much good the suffrage movement might have done in its 37 years if all its energy had gone to the ends the ballot is for rather than to getting the ballot. She has been applying that thought to the young breadwinners. There are two million children under sixteen earning their bread in the country, she says, some as young as six or seven in the cotton mills of Georgia and eight to ten in the coal-breakers of Pennsylvania. No group of workers grows faster than girls between twelve and twenty. Tonight, while the audience sleeps, thousands of little girls will be working all night in textile mills, making cloth for the audience to buy. She then goes state by state. Alabama limits a child’s night work in the mills to eight hours, the best rule in the South; the Carolinas and Georgia set no limit, and in Georgia a girl of six may work eleven hours by day or by night. New Jersey is worse than Alabama: it has just repealed a law that stopped work at six in the evening, so boys and girls over fourteen may now work all night. Until the previous May, Pennsylvania let a thirteen-year-old work twelve hours at night. Kelley asks whether Georgia and New Jersey would have acted this way if mothers could vote, and says that until mothers in the industrial states are enfranchised, no one in the room can free her conscience. Children make the audience’s shoes, stockings, underwear, hats, trimmings, pins, artificial flowers and neckwear. Women do not want this, she says, but they are almost powerless. They still have the right of petition, and she will use it until the ballot is won. Her answer to the problem is an alliance: suffragists can win workingmen to their side by working with them to free the children. She closes by calling on the audience, for the children’s sake, for the Republic those children will one day vote in, and for the sake of their own cause, to enlist the workingmen voters in that task.

The line of reasoning how the argument moves

  1. Turns the convention’s own questionParagraph 1 starts from a remark another speaker made about what the movement might have achieved if it had not spent 37 years asking for the vote. Kelley applies it to working children, so her subject arrives as an answer to the audience’s own conversation.
  2. Sets out the scaleParagraphs 2 and 3 give the numbers: two million working children, some only six years old, and girls as the fastest-growing part of the work force. The facts establish that this is a national problem before she names a single state.
  3. Brings it into the roomParagraph 4 moves to ‘to-night while we sleep’ and ends on cloth ‘for us to buy’. The listeners are no longer observers of a distant evil; they are customers of it.
  4. Goes through the laws state by stateParagraphs 5 to 8 compare Alabama, the Carolinas, Georgia, New Jersey and Pennsylvania. The order surprises: a Southern state does better than New Jersey, so no one in the audience can treat this as a Southern problem.
  5. Links the laws to the voteParagraphs 9 and 10 ask whether those legislatures would have acted as they did if mothers could vote, then list the goods children make for ‘us’. The rhetorical questions carry the main claim, and the list makes every listener complicit.
  6. Offers a course of actionParagraphs 11 to 13 admit that women are almost powerless, name the power they do have (petition), and propose an alliance with workingmen. The speech ends with a call to act, not with a complaint.

The full text paragraphs numbered for citation

¶1On Saturday one of the speakers pointed out what gains our civilization might have made during the 37 years in which these conventions have been held annually, if there could have been devoted to the ends for which we desire the ballot, all that intelligence, energy and vitality which have been devoted to obtaining the right to cast the ballot. Ever since this thought was uttered, I have been applying it to the subject of the young breadwinners.

¶2We have, in this country, two million children under the age of sixteen years who are earning their bread. They vary in age from six and seven years (in the cotton mills of Georgia) and eight, nine and ten years (in the coal-breakers of Pennsylvania), to fourteen, fifteen and sixteen years in more enlightened States.

¶3No other portion of the wage-earning class increases so rapidly from decade to decade as the young girls from fourteen to twenty years. Men increase, women increase, youth increase, boys increase in the ranks of the breadwinners; but no contingent so doubles from census period to census period (both by per cent. and by count of heads), as does the contingent of girls between twelve and twenty years of age. They are in commerce, in offices, in manufacture.

¶4To-night while we sleep, several thousand little girls will be working in textile mills, all the night through, in the deafening noise of the spindles and the looms spinning and weaving cotton and woolen, silks and ribbons for us to buy.

¶5In Alabama the law provides that a child under sixteen years of age shall not work in a cotton mill at night longer than eight hours, and Alabama does better in this respect than any other Southern State. North and South Carolina and Georgia place no restriction upon the work of children at night; and while we sleep little white girls will be working to-night in the mills in those States, working eleven hours at night.

¶6In Georgia there is no restriction whatever! A girl of six or seven years, just tall enough to reach the bobbins, may work eleven hours by day or by night. And they will do so to-night, while we sleep.

¶7Nor is it only in the South that these things occur. Alabama does better than New Jersey. For Alabama limits the children’s work at night to eight hours, while New Jersey permits it all night long. Last year New Jersey took a long backward step. A good law was repealed which had required women and unions to stop work at six in the evening and at noon on Friday. Now, therefore, in New Jersey, boys and girls, after the 14th birthday, enjoy the pitiful privilege of working all night long.

¶8In Pennsylvania, until last May it was lawful for children, 13 years of age, to work twelve hours at night. A little girl, on her thirteenth birthday, could start away from her home at half past five in the afternoon, carrying her pail of midnight luncheon as happier people carry their midday luncheon, and could work in the mill from six at night until six in the morning, without violating any law of the Commonwealth.

¶9If the mothers and the teachers in Georgia could vote, would the Georgia Legislature have refused at every session for the last three years to stop the work in the mills of children under twelve years of age?

¶10Would the New Jersey Legislature have passed that shameful repeal bill enabling girls of fourteen years to work all night, if the mothers in New Jersey were enfranchised? Until the mothers in the great industrial States are enfranchised, we shall none of us be able to free our consciences from participation in this great evil. No one in this room to-night can feel free from such participation. The children make our shoes in the shoe factories; they knit our stockings, our knitted underwear in the knitting factories. They spin and weave our cotton underwear in the cotton mills. Children braid straw for our hats, they spin and weave the silk and velvet wherewith we trim our hats. They stamp buckles and metal ornaments of all kinds, as well as pins and hat-pins. Under the sweating system, tiny children make artificial flowers and neckwear for us to buy. They carry bundles of garments from the factories to the tenements, little beasts of burden, robbed of school life that they may work for us.

¶11We do not wish this. We prefer to have our work done by men and women. But we are almost powerless. Not wholly powerless, however, are citizens who enjoy the right of petition. For myself, I shall use this power in every possible way until the right to the ballot is granted, and then I shall continue to use both.

¶12What can we do to free our consciences? There is one line of action by which we can do much. We can enlist the workingmen on behalf of our enfranchisement just in proportion as we strive with them to free the children. No labor organization in this country ever fails to respond to an appeal for help in the freeing of the children.

¶13For the sake of the children, for the Republic in which these children will vote after we are dead, and for the sake of our cause, we should enlist the workingmen voters, with us, in this task of freeing the children from toil.

Text: The Woman’s Journal (Boston), July 22, 1905, p. 114, “The Young Breadwinners’ Need of Women’s Enfranchisement,” transcribed from the Internet Archive scan.

Paragraph by paragraph what each part does

  1. 1

    Paragraphs 1 to 3: The young breadwinners

    Kelley picks up an earlier speaker’s point about what 37 years of suffrage conventions might have achieved if their energy had gone to the ends of the ballot, and applies it to working children. There are two million breadwinners under sixteen, from six-year-olds in Georgia’s cotton mills to children in Pennsylvania’s coal-breakers. Girls from twelve to twenty are the fastest-growing group of workers in the country, in commerce, offices and manufacture.

    Why it mattersOpening on another speaker’s idea is a courteous way to change the subject, and it frames child labor as part of the convention’s own business. The figures come early and plainly, which builds the speaker’s authority before she asks for anything.

  2. 2

    Paragraphs 4 to 8: Tonight, while we sleep

    Kelley says that thousands of little girls will work all night in textile mills while the audience sleeps. She then compares the states. Alabama limits a child’s night work to eight hours; the Carolinas and Georgia set no limit, and in Georgia a girl of six may work eleven hours by day or night. New Jersey has repealed its limit, so children over fourteen may work all night, and until the previous May a thirteen-year-old in Pennsylvania could work twelve hours at night. The section ends on the picture of a little girl setting out at half past five in the afternoon with her midnight lunch pail.

    Why it mattersThe repeated ‘while we sleep’ sets the comfort of the listeners against the girls’ labor. The state-by-state comparison is evidence, but its order is also an argument: by showing New Jersey doing worse than Alabama, Kelley denies Northern listeners the comfort of blaming the South.

  3. 3

    Paragraphs 9 to 10: If the mothers could vote

    Kelley asks whether Georgia’s legislature would have refused for three years to stop mill work for children under twelve if mothers and teachers could vote, and whether New Jersey would have passed its repeal if mothers there were enfranchised. Until mothers in the industrial states can vote, she says, no one in the room can free her conscience. She then lists what children make for the audience: shoes, stockings, underwear, straw hats and their trimmings, buckles, pins, artificial flowers and neckwear.

    Why it mattersThe questions do the arguing, since the audience can only answer them one way. The long list of ordinary purchases turns a political problem into a personal one and makes the case that the women in the room already take part in the evil.

  4. 4

    Paragraphs 11 to 13: What we can do

    Kelley says women do not want their goods made by children but are almost powerless. Citizens who can petition are not wholly powerless, and she will petition until the ballot is won and then use both. She proposes that suffragists win the support of workingmen by working with them to free the children, since no labor organization refuses that appeal. She ends by asking the audience to enlist the workingmen voters, for the children, for the Republic, and for their own cause.

    Why it mattersThe close moves from guilt to action. Kelley offers a practical strategy, an alliance with men who already vote, and her final sentence ties three motives together so that helping children, serving the nation and winning the vote become one task.

Rhetorical choices what the writer does, and why it works

Statistics and specific detail

Paragraph 2 opens with ‘two million children’ and gives exact ages by state and industry; paragraphs 5 to 8 give hours, ages and the date of a repeal. The precision is the speech’s main source of ethos, the authority of someone who has inspected factories and read the statutes.

Anaphora and repetition

‘While we sleep’ returns in paragraphs 4, 5 and 6, and ‘to-night’ runs through the same passage. Each return sets the comfort of the listeners against the girls in the mills, so the contrast grows sharper every time.

Rhetorical questions

Paragraphs 9 and 10 ask whether Georgia and New Jersey would have acted as they did if mothers could vote. The questions carry the central claim of the speech without stating it, because the audience supplies the answer.

Pathos through a single image

Paragraph 8 follows one thirteen-year-old leaving home at half past five with ‘her pail of midnight luncheon as happier people carry their midday luncheon’. A single child with a lunch pail makes the statistics concrete, and the comparison with ‘happier people’ quietly includes the listeners.

Inclusive first person

Kelley says ‘we’, ‘us’ and ‘our’ throughout, from ‘for us to buy’ in paragraph 4 to ‘our shoes’ and ‘our hats’ in paragraph 10. The pronouns make the audience both the customers of child labor and the people able to end it.

Metaphor

In paragraph 10 the children who carry bundles from factories to tenements are ‘little beasts of burden, robbed of school life’. The image of animals used for hauling, and the word ‘robbed’, name what has been taken from them: their childhood and their schooling.

People & audiences

Florence Kelley

Speaker

A reformer and former factory inspector who led the National Consumers’ League. She uses the first person sparingly, mainly in paragraph 11, where she pledges to keep petitioning until women can vote.

The convention delegates

Immediate audience

The suffragists in the room, whom Kelley addresses as ‘we’. She asks them to see that the goods they buy are made by children and that the vote they want is the means to stop it.

The young breadwinners

Subject

The two million working children of paragraph 2, especially the girls in the night shifts of the textile mills. They never speak; Kelley gives them a voice through numbers and one sharply drawn little girl in paragraph 8.

The state legislatures

Opponents

Georgia’s, which refused for three years to stop mill work for children under twelve, and New Jersey’s, which repealed its limit on night work. Kelley never names a legislator; the institutions themselves are on trial.

The mothers

The missing voters

Kelley’s argument turns on the mothers of the industrial states, who cannot vote. She suggests that if they could, legislatures would not dare to treat their children this way.

The workingmen

Proposed allies

Organized labor, whose members already have the vote. In paragraphs 12 and 13 Kelley proposes that suffragists earn their support by joining them to free the children.

Big ideas in Speech on Child Labor

The vote as a toolShared guiltLost childhoodAlliance across movementsLaw and its failures

The vote as a tool

Kelley does not argue that women deserve the ballot as a matter of fairness. She argues that they need it to protect children, because legislatures answer to voters. The right matters for what it can do.

Shared guilt

The children make ‘our shoes’ and ‘our hats’. By naming everyday purchases, Kelley makes it impossible for her listeners to think of child labor as someone else’s problem.

Lost childhood

The children are ‘robbed of school life’ and work while others sleep. The speech measures the cost of child labor in hours, in schooling and in sleep.

Alliance across movements

Kelley ends by joining the suffrage cause to the labor cause. Women and workingmen want different things, but both can agree on freeing the children, and each can help the other.

Law and its failures

Every state Kelley names has a law, and every law fails the children in a different way. The speech shows that the problem is not ignorance but choices made by legislatures, and so it can be changed by changing who chooses them.

Key images

The midnight lunch pail

In paragraph 8 a thirteen-year-old carries her pail of midnight luncheon the way ‘happier people’ carry their midday luncheon. The pail stands for a childhood turned upside down, with night made into the working day.

Clothes and hats

Stockings, underwear, hats, ribbons and silk run through paragraphs 4 and 10. The goods on the listeners’ bodies stand for the hidden labor of children, carried into the convention hall itself.

Repeated words and ideas

Night. ‘To-night’, ‘at night’ and ‘all night long’ recur through paragraphs 4 to 10. Night work is the detail Kelley returns to most, because it shows how far the mills have gone and how comfortably the rest of the country sleeps.

Freeing. Paragraphs 10 to 13 repeat ‘free our consciences’, ‘free the children’ and ‘freeing the children from toil’. The word links the listeners’ relief to the children’s liberty: one comes only with the other.

Tensions and counterarguments

Reformers vs. legislatures. Georgia’s legislature refuses to act and New Jersey’s takes a backward step. Kelley’s answer is to change who elects them.

Comfort vs. conscience. The listeners sleep while girls work, and wear what children made. The speech sets out to disturb that comfort and turn it into action.

Powerless vs. not wholly powerless. Paragraph 11 admits that women are almost powerless, then corrects itself: petition is a real power. The speech moves from helplessness to a plan.

Key quotes

“We have, in this country, two million children under the age of sixteen years who are earning their bread.”
Paragraph 2. The plain statement of scale opens the argument. ‘Earning their bread’ is a phrase for adults, and applying it to children makes the point before she adds a word.
“To-night while we sleep, several thousand little girls will be working in textile mills, all the night through, in the deafening noise of the spindles and the looms spinning and weaving cotton and woolen, silks and ribbons for us to buy.”
Paragraph 4. The sentence moves from the listeners’ beds to the noise of the mill and back to the listeners as shoppers, so it begins and ends with ‘we’.
“Now, therefore, in New Jersey, boys and girls, after the 14th birthday, enjoy the pitiful privilege of working all night long.”
Paragraph 7. ‘Pitiful privilege’ is bitter irony: the repeal is described as if it granted children a right.
“If the mothers and the teachers in Georgia could vote, would the Georgia Legislature have refused at every session for the last three years to stop the work in the mills of children under twelve years of age?”
Paragraph 9. The first of the two rhetorical questions that carry the speech’s central claim. Naming mothers and teachers picks the voters who care most about children.
“They carry bundles of garments from the factories to the tenements, little beasts of burden, robbed of school life that they may work for us.”
Paragraph 10. The metaphor and the verb ‘robbed’ name the loss, and ‘for us’ places the blame back on the audience.
“We can enlist the workingmen on behalf of our enfranchisement just in proportion as we strive with them to free the children.”
Paragraph 12. The practical heart of the close: an exchange in which suffragists earn labor’s support by joining labor’s cause.
How it ends

The conclusion of Speech on Child Labor, explained

The last two paragraphs turn the speech from an accusation into a plan. Kelley has spent most of her time making the audience uncomfortable: the girls work while they sleep, and the children make what they wear. She has also admitted, in paragraph 11, that women are almost powerless. Paragraph 12 answers that problem with a strategy. Workingmen can already vote, and no labor organization ever refuses to help free the children, so suffragists who join that work will gain allies for their own enfranchisement. The bargain is plain and a little calculating, which is part of its force: Kelley is a practical reformer, not only a moral one. The final sentence gathers three reasons into one, ‘for the sake of the children, for the Republic in which these children will vote after we are dead, and for the sake of our cause’. The order runs from the most urgent to the most self-interested, and the middle phrase looks ahead to a future in which the working children of 1905 will be citizens. The speech ends on the phrase ‘freeing the children from toil’, so the last image the audience hears is not the vote but the children it is meant to help.

Common misreadings

MythKelley gave this speech in Philadelphia on July 22, 1905.

ActuallyJuly 22, 1905, is the date The Woman’s Journal, a Boston weekly, printed the speech. The paper’s note above the text says Kelley read it at the National Suffrage Convention in Portland, Oregon, which met there that summer. The Philadelphia attribution, repeated in many textbooks, has no support in that printing.

MythIt is a speech about child labor rather than about suffrage.

ActuallyIt is both, and the suffrage argument is the frame. Kelley was speaking to a suffrage convention, and the printed heading was ‘The Young Breadwinners’ Need of Women’s Enfranchisement’. Child labor is her evidence that women need the vote.

MythParagraph 7 says the repealed New Jersey law covered ‘women and minors’.

ActuallyThe 1905 page reads ‘women and unions’. That is very probably a misprint for ‘minors’, the word later reprints give, and this edition keeps the page as printed. Quote whichever text you use and say which it is.

AP practice a rhetorical analysis prompt in the exam's style

In 1905 the social reformer Florence Kelley addressed the annual convention of the National American Woman Suffrage Association. Read the speech carefully. Then write an essay that analyzes the rhetorical choices Kelley makes to persuade her audience that the fight for women’s votes and the fight against child labor are the same fight.

What a strong response notices

  • The opening in paragraph 1, which picks up another speaker’s point so that child labor arrives as part of the convention’s own business.
  • The statistics and state-by-state comparison in paragraphs 2 to 8, and the choice to show New Jersey doing worse than Alabama.
  • The repeated ‘while we sleep’ and ‘to-night’ in paragraphs 4 to 6, which set the listeners’ comfort against the girls’ labor.
  • The rhetorical questions of paragraphs 9 and 10, which carry the claim that mothers’ votes would change the laws.
  • The list of goods ‘for us to buy’ in paragraph 10 and the call to enlist workingmen in paragraphs 12 and 13, which turn guilt into a plan.

Practice prompt written by StoryBites, not taken from a College Board exam. See the AP Language free-response guide for how answers are scored.

Test yourself

1. How does Kelley open the speech?

2. Why does Kelley compare Alabama with New Jersey?

3. What does Kelley suggest would change if mothers could vote?

4. What is the effect of the list of goods in paragraph 10?

5. What course of action does Kelley propose at the end?

Flashcards flip, self-grade, and the deck remembers what you know

tap to flip
Answer

Explain it like I’m 12

In 1905 a lot of American children had jobs instead of going to school. Some were only six or seven and worked in cotton mills, sometimes all night. Florence Kelley spoke to a big meeting of women who were trying to win the right to vote. She told them about the children, state by state, and said the laws were bad because the people making them did not have to listen to mothers. She pointed out that children made the shoes and hats the women were wearing. She said women should team up with workingmen, who could already vote, to get the children out of the mills.

Compare & connect

On Women’s Right to Vote

Susan B. Anthony

Anthony argues that women are citizens and so already have the right to vote. Kelley, a generation later, argues from what the vote would let women do. Comparing them shows two different cases for the same reform.

Declaration of Sentiments

Elizabeth Cady Stanton

The 1848 document that began the organized suffrage movement Kelley was speaking to. Stanton lists wrongs done to women; Kelley lists wrongs done to children that women could stop.

A Modest Proposal

Jonathan Swift

Both writers make readers face what an economy does to poor children. Swift uses savage irony; Kelley uses plain facts and only a touch of irony, as in ‘pitiful privilege’.

Discussion and essay prompts:

💬 Discussion questions

  • What is the main argument of Florence Kelley’s speech on child labor
  • Where did Florence Kelley give her 1905 speech on child labor
  • What rhetorical strategies does Florence Kelley use
  • How does Speech on Child Labor explore the theme of the vote as a tool?
  • How does Speech on Child Labor explore the theme of shared guilt?
  • What is the central conflict in Speech on Child Labor, and how does it shape the ending?

✎ Essay prompts

  1. Analyze how Florence Kelley develops the theme of the vote as a tool in Speech on Child Labor. Support your argument with specific evidence from the text.
  2. Examine the significance of the midnight lunch pail in Speech on Child Labor. What does it represent, and how does it deepen the work’s meaning?
  3. How does Florence Kelley use statistics and specific detail to shape the reader’s experience of Speech on Child Labor?
  4. Some readers assume that kelley gave this speech in Philadelphia on July 22, 1905. Argue for or against this interpretation, using evidence from the text.

Key questions students ask

  • What is the main argument of Florence Kelley’s speech on child labor
  • Where did Florence Kelley give her 1905 speech on child labor
  • What rhetorical strategies does Florence Kelley use
  • Why does Kelley say while we sleep
  • How does Kelley connect child labor to women’s suffrage
  • Who was the audience for Florence Kelley’s child labor speech

Analysis is original StoryBites commentary. The full text and quotations follow The Woman’s Journal of July 22, 1905, which printed the speech as ‘The Young Breadwinners’ Need of Women’s Enfranchisement’, transcribed from page images of that issue. The speech is in the public domain.

Share this guide

Continue exploring

Follow a thread — every work connects to others through what they share.