AP Language · speech · 13 min

Lecture at Franklin Hall

In 1832 a Black widow who had worked as a servant since childhood stands before a Boston audience of men and women and asks why the free people of color of the North are kept in service, and who will speak for them.

⏱ 13 min to understand the speech 6 steps of reasoning · 6 rhetorical choices Public domain text

Free, all of it. No ads, no account, no paywall, no trial, nothing to cancel.

📖 Read the full text on this pageEvery paragraph numbered, so you can cite it
0% explored
The whole speech in 60 seconds

On September 21, 1832, Maria W. Stewart gave a lecture at Franklin Hall in Boston. American women almost never spoke in public to audiences of men and women then, and Stewart, a Black widow in her late twenties who had been a servant since childhood, was one of the first to do it. She raises the question herself in paragraph 3: who will go forward for the people of color, and “Shall it be a woman?” Her answer is yes. Then she argues that the free Black people of the North, though no one can buy or sell them, are held in a servitude of their own by prejudice. Their daughters can find work only as servants, their sons only as laborers, and endless labor starves the mind. The AP exam printed the middle of the lecture, from “Few white persons of either sex” to “I should indeed despair,” which is paragraphs 8 to 11 here. The full text shows what surrounds it: the call to speak, the plea to white women, and the hard challenge to Black men.

The claim

Prejudice, not a lack of ability or effort, keeps the free people of color in servitude. It shuts their daughters and sons out of every occupation but service and labor, and labor without education deadens the mind. Whites who proclaim equal rights should not wonder that Black Americans want them too, and Black men must make powerful efforts, including petitioning for the rights of citizens, to raise their children above servitude.

The rhetorical situation who, to whom, when, and why

SpeakerMaria W. Stewart, born Maria Miller in Hartford, Connecticut, in 1803. Orphaned at five, she was bound out as a servant in a clergyman’s family until she was fifteen. She married James W. Stewart in Boston in 1826 and was widowed in 1829. In 1831 the Liberator’s publishers, Garrison and Knapp, printed her essay Religion and the Pure Principles of Morality.
AudienceA mixed audience of women and men, Black and white, as the lecture itself shows. Stewart speaks to white listeners (“have you not a similar class among yourselves?”), to white women (“O, ye fairer sisters”) and to Black men (“My beloved brethren”). A wider audience read it in the Liberator of November 17, 1832, which printed it “by request.”
OccasionA public lecture at Franklin Hall in Boston on September 21, 1832. It was one of a handful of public addresses Stewart gave in Boston in 1832 and 1833, before her farewell address to the city in September 1833.
ExigenceMassachusetts had ended slavery in the 1780s, but free Black Bostonians were kept to service and manual labor. Employers would not hire Black girls for fear of losing their customers, and supporters of colonization, the plan to send free Black Americans to Africa, called them lazy and idle. A woman who spoke in public also risked scorn for doing it at all.
PurposeTo show that prejudice is the cause of the condition of free Black people, to answer the colonizationists’ charges, to win the sympathy of white listeners, and to rouse Black men to make the efforts, and the demands, that would raise their sons and daughters.
ContextStewart met opposition for speaking, and after her farewell address in 1833 she moved to New York, where she taught school. She later lived in Baltimore and Washington, where she was matron of the Freedmen’s Hospital when she reprinted her writings in 1879 as Meditations from the Pen of Mrs. Maria W. Stewart. She died that December.
Place

Franklin Hall, Boston

A public hall in the city where William Lloyd Garrison had begun the Liberator in January 1831 and where the New England Anti-Slavery Society was founded in January 1832. Massachusetts had no slavery, but free Black Bostonians were kept to the lowest work.

Time

September 21, 1832

A year of sharp argument over colonization in Boston; Garrison published his attack on it, Thoughts on African Colonization, that same year. Very few women had ever lectured to audiences of men and women, so Stewart’s appearance was itself part of her message.

What Lecture at Franklin Hall says

The lecture opens with a question from the Bible: why sit we here and die? If free Black Americans go to a foreign land they will die there, and if they stay they will die, so they should plead their cause before the whites and take whatever comes. Stewart says she heard a spiritual question, who will take away the reproach cast on the people of color, and whether it should be a woman, and her heart answered yes. She has heard much about Southern slavery, she says, but the condition of free Black people is little better, and no chains are so galling as the chains of ignorance. She wishes she had received an early education. She has asked women who run businesses whether they would hire Black girls with good references. They say they would have no objection, but it is not the custom, and they would lose their customers. Such is the force of prejudice, she says: no matter how fine their character and talents, Black girls cannot rise above service. If free Black people devoted themselves to moral and intellectual improvement, prejudice would fade. In the passage the exam printed, Stewart says few white people with any other prospects would spend their lives in servile labor, and that she would rather die than believe she could never rise above it. She is a true born American, ready to die for speaking. She answers the colonizationists’ charge that Black people are lazy and idle, and the sneer that they are “a ragged set, crying for liberty”: whites have proclaimed equal rights so loudly that Black people have caught the flame. Hard labor deadens the mind and sours the temper, and as servants they are respected only until they aspire to more. In the last part she tells white women to imagine their own lives of endless toil, and pleads for pity. Then she turns to Black men. Advocates of freedom will speak in vain unless they make mighty efforts. She describes the young, the middle-aged and the old trapped in poverty, and asks whether they have petitioned the legislature for the rights of free citizens.

The line of reasoning how the argument moves

  1. Opens with a choiceParagraph 2 borrows the dilemma of four starving men in the Bible: leave and die, stay and die, or plead and perhaps live. Stewart rejects both emigration and silence and chooses to speak to the whites.
  2. Claims the right to speakParagraph 3 answers the objection to a woman speaking before anyone can raise it. The question “Shall it be a woman?” comes from a spiritual voice, and her reply puts God’s will above custom.
  3. Redefines servitudeParagraphs 4 to 6 argue that free Black people in the North live in a condition “but little better” than slavery. Her evidence is concrete: shopkeepers who will not hire Black girls because of the custom. The cause is prejudice, not character.
  4. Makes it personalParagraph 8 moves from the general to Stewart herself. She would rather die than accept a servant’s life forever, and she claims her place as “a true born American” whose blood is her listeners’ blood.
  5. Answers the accusersParagraphs 9 to 11 take the colonizationists’ charges one by one. Black people are not idle, and if they are ragged and crying for liberty, they learned the cry from whites. Hard labor, not nature, explains whatever faults the accusers see.
  6. Turns to two audiencesParagraphs 12 to 14 address white women, asking them to imagine Black women’s labor, and then Black men, asking them to make the mighty efforts that the Pilgrims made. The lecture ends with a question, not a promise.

The full text paragraphs numbered for citation

¶1Delivered at the Franklin Hall, Boston, September 21st, 1832.

¶2Why sit we here and die? If we say we will go to a foreign land, the famine and the pestilence are there, and there we shall die. If we sit here, we shall die. Come, let us plead our cause before the whites: if they save us alive, we shall live—and if they kill us, we shall but die.

¶3Methinks I heard a spiritual interrogation—‘Who shall go forward, and take off the reproach that is cast upon the people of color? Shall it be a woman?’ And my heart made this reply—‘If it is thy will, be it even so, Lord Jesus!’

¶4I have heard much respecting the horrors of slavery; but may Heaven forbid that the generality of my color throughout these United States should experience any more of its horrors than to be a servant of servants, or hewers of wood and drawers of water! Tell us no more of southern slavery; for with few exceptions, although I may be very erroneous in my opinion, yet I consider our condition but little better than that. Yet, after all, methinks there are no chains so galling as the chains of ignorance—no fetters so binding as those that bind the soul, and exclude it from the vast field of useful and scientific knowledge. O, had I received the advantages of early education, my ideas would, ere now, have expanded far and wide; but, alas! I possess nothing but moral capability—no teachings but the teachings of the Holy Spirit.

¶5I have asked several individuals of my sex, who transact business for themselves, if, providing our girls were to give them the most satisfactory references, they would not be willing to grant them an equal opportunity with others? Their reply has been—for their own part, they had no objection; but as it was not the custom, were they to take them into their employ, they would be in danger of losing the public patronage.

¶6And such is the powerful force of prejudice.—Let our girls possess what amiable qualities of soul they may—let their characters be fair and spotless as innocence itself—let their natural taste and ingenuity be what they may—it is impossible for scarce an individual of them to rise above the condition of servants. Ah! why is this cruel and unfeeling distinction? Is it merely because God has made our complexion to vary? If it be, O shame to soft, relenting humanity! ‘Tell it not in Gath! publish it not in the streets of Askelon!’ Yet, after all, methinks were the American free people of color to turn their attention more assiduously to moral worth and intellectual improvement, this would be the result:—prejudice would gradually diminish, and the whites would be compelled to say,—Unloose those fetters!

¶7Though black their skins as shades of night, / Their hearts are pure—their souls are white.

¶8Few white persons of either sex, who are calculated for any thing else, are willing to spend their lives and bury their talents in performing mean, servile labor. And such is the horrible idea that I entertain respecting a life of servitude, that if I conceived of their being no possibility of my rising above the condition of a servant, I would gladly hail death as a welcome messenger. O, horrible idea, indeed! to possess noble souls aspiring after high and honorable acquirements, yet confined by the chains of ignorance and poverty to lives of continual drudgery and toil. Neither do I know of any who have enriched themselves by spending their lives as house-domestics, washing windows, shaking carpets, brushing boots, or tending upon gentlemen’s tables. I can but die for expressing my sentiments; and I am as willing to die by the sword as the pestilence—for I am a true born American—your blood flows in my veins, and your spirit fires my breast.

¶9I observed a piece in the Liberator a few months since, stating that the colonizationists had published a work respecting us, asserting that we were lazy and idle. I confute them on that point. Take us generally as a people, we are neither lazy nor idle; and considering how little we have to excite or stimulate us, I am almost astonished that there are so many industrious and ambitious ones to be found—although I acknowledge, with extreme sorrow, that there are some who never were and never will be serviceable to society. And have you not a similar class among yourselves?

¶10Again—It was asserted that we were ‘a ragged set, crying for liberty.’ I reply to it, the whites have so long and so loudly proclaimed the theme of equal rights and privileges, that our souls have caught the flame also, ragged as we are. As far as our merit deserves, we feel a common desire to rise above the condition of servants and drudges. I have learnt, by bitter experience, that continual hard labor deadens the energies of the soul, and benumbs the faculties of the mind: the ideas become confined, the mind barren, and, like the scorching sands of Arabia, produces nothing—or like the uncultivated soil, brings forth thorns and thistles.

¶11Again, continual hard labor irritates our tempers and sours our dispositions; the whole system becomes worn out with toil and fatigue; nature herself becomes almost exhausted, and we care but little whether we live or die. It is true that the free people of color throughout these United States are neither bought nor sold, nor under the lash of the cruel driver; many obtain a comfortable support; but few, if any, have an opportunity of becoming rich and independent; and the employments we most pursue are as unprofitable to us as the spider’s web or the floating bubbles that vanish into air. As servants, we are respected; but let us presume to aspire any higher, our employer regards us no longer. And were it not that the King eternal has declared that Ethiopia shall stretch forth her hands unto God, I should indeed despair.

¶12I do not consider it derogatory, my friends, for persons to live out to service. There are many whose inclination leads them to aspire no higher;—and I would highly commend the performance of almost any thing for an honest livelihood; but where constitutional strength is wanting, labor of this kind, in its mildest form, is painful. And doubtless many are the prayers that have ascended to Heaven from Afric’s daughters for strength to perform their work. Oh, many are the tears that have been shed for the want of that strength! Most of our color have dragged out a miserable existence of servitude from the cradle to the grave. And what literary acquirements can be made, or useful knowledge derived, from either maps, books or charts, by those who continually drudge from Monday morning until Sunday noon? O, ye fairer sisters, whose hands are never soiled, whose nerves and muscles are never strained, go learn by experience! Had we had the opportunity that you have had, to improve our moral and mental faculties, what would have hindered our intellects from being as bright, and our manners from being as dignified as yours? Had it been our lot to have been nursed in the lap of affluence and ease, and to have basked beneath the smiles and sunshine of fortune, should we not have naturally supposed that we were never made to toil? And why are not our forms as delicate, and our constitutions as slender, as yours? Is not the workmanship as curious and complete? Have pity upon us—have pity upon us, O ye who have hearts to feel for others’ woes; for the hand of God has touched us. Owing to the disadvantages under which we labor, there are many flowers among us that are

¶13‘—— born to bloom unseen, / And waste their fragrance on the desert air.’

¶14My beloved brethren, as Christ has died in vain for those who will not accept of offered mercy, so will it be in vain for the advocates of freedom to spend their breath in our behalf, unless with united hearts and souls you make some mighty efforts to raise your sons and daughters from the horrible state of servitude and degradation in which they are placed. It is upon you that woman depends; she can do but little besides using her influence; and it is for her sake and yours that I have come forward and made myself a hissing and a reproach amongst the people; for I am also one of the wretched and miserable daughters of the descendants of fallen Africa. Do you ask,—Why are you wretched and miserable? I reply, look at many of the most worthy and interesting of us doomed to spend our lives in gentlemen’s kitchens. Look at our young men, smart, active and energetic, with souls filled with ambitious fire; if they look forward, alas! what are their prospects? They can be nothing but the humblest laborers, on account of their dark complexions; hence many of them lose their ambition, and become worthless. Look at our middle-aged men, clad in their rusty plaids and coats;—in winter, every cent they earn goes to buy their wood and pay their rents; their poor wives also toil beyond their strength to help support their families. Look at our aged sires, whose heads are whitened with the frosts of seventy winters, with their old wood-saws on their backs. Alas, what keeps us so? Prejudice, ignorance and poverty. But ah! methinks our oppression is soon to come to an end; yea, before the majesty of heaven, our groans and cries have reached the ears of the Lord of Sabaoth. As the prayers and tears of christians will avail the finally impenitent nothing; neither will the prayers and tears of the friends of humanity avail us any thing, unless we possess a spirit of virtuous emulation within our breasts. Did the pilgrims, when they first landed on these shores, quietly compose themselves, and say, ‘The Britons have all the money and all the power, and we must continue their servants forever’? Did they sluggishly sigh and say, ‘Our lot is hard—the Indians own the soil, and we cannot cultivate it’? No—they first made powerful efforts to raise themselves, and then God raised up those illustrious patriots, Washington and Lafayette, to assist and defend them. And, my brethren, have you made a powerful effort? Have you prayed the legislature for mercy’s sake to grant you all the rights and privileges of free citizens, that your daughters may rise to that degree of respectability which true merit deserves, and your sons above the servile situations which most of them fill?

Text: The Liberator (Boston), November 17, 1832, p. 183, “Lecture, Delivered at the Franklin Hall, Boston, September 21st, 1832,” transcribed from the Internet Archive scan.

Paragraph by paragraph what each part does

  1. 1

    Paragraphs 1 to 3: Why sit we here and die?

    After the line that dates the lecture, Stewart opens with a biblical question. If free Black Americans go to a foreign land, famine and disease will kill them there; if they stay, they will die here. So they should plead their cause before the whites: if the whites save them they will live, and if not they will only die. She then says she heard a spiritual question, who would go forward to take away the reproach cast on the people of color, and whether it should be a woman. Her heart replied that if it was God’s will, so be it.

    Why it mattersThe “foreign land” points at the colonization movement, which wanted free Black Americans to leave for Africa. Stewart refuses that road in her first breath. The second paragraph justifies her presence on the platform, making a woman’s public voice a matter of obedience to God rather than defiance of men.

  2. 2

    Paragraphs 4 to 7: Chains of ignorance, the force of prejudice

    Stewart says she hopes free Black people will never know more of slavery’s horrors than being servants, yet she considers their condition little better than Southern slavery. No chains, she says, gall like the chains of ignorance, and she laments her own lack of early education. She has asked women in business whether they would hire Black girls with good references; they had no objection, but the custom would cost them their customers. However good the girls’ characters and talents, they cannot rise above service. She believes that moral and intellectual improvement would wear prejudice down, and quotes a couplet about pure hearts under dark skin.

    Why it mattersThis section moves the argument about slavery north. The anecdote of the shopkeepers is Stewart’s strongest evidence, because it shows prejudice working through polite people who claim to have “no objection.” The repeated “let” clauses in paragraph 6 pile up virtues to show that virtue alone cannot open the door.

  3. 3

    Paragraphs 8 to 11: The life of a servant (the exam passage)

    Few white people with other prospects, Stewart says, would spend their lives in servile labor, and she would rather die than think she could never rise above a servant. No one has grown wealthy washing windows and brushing boots. She is willing to die for speaking, for she is a true born American. She answers the colonizationists who called Black people lazy and idle, and the charge that they were a ragged set crying for liberty: whites proclaimed equal rights so loudly that Black people caught the flame. Continual hard labor deadens the mind, sours the temper and exhausts the body. Free Black people are not sold or whipped, but they cannot become independent, and they are respected only as long as they stay servants.

    Why it mattersThis is the passage the exam printed, and it holds the core of the argument. Stewart uses the accusers’ own words and turns them around, especially in “ragged as we are,” and she grounds her claims in “bitter experience.” The closing appeal to Ethiopia stretching forth her hands keeps her from despair and places the cause in God’s hands.

  4. 4

    Paragraphs 12 to 13: To the fairer sisters

    Stewart says service is not shameful and honest work deserves praise, but where strength is lacking such labor is painful, and many Black women have prayed and wept for the strength to do it. What learning can be gained by those who drudge from Monday morning to Sunday noon? She tells white women, whose hands are never soiled, to learn by experience, and asks what would have kept Black women’s minds from being as bright as theirs if they had had the same chances. She pleads for pity, and quotes a line about flowers born to bloom unseen.

    Why it mattersThe shift in address is sharp: from argument to an appeal to women as women. Stewart’s questions ask white women to imagine themselves in her place. The flowers that waste their fragrance on the desert air stand for talent that no one ever sees.

  5. 5

    Paragraph 14: To my beloved brethren

    Stewart tells Black men that friends of freedom will speak in vain unless they make mighty efforts to raise their sons and daughters. Women depend on them, and she has come forward for their sake, making herself a hissing and a reproach. She describes young men with no prospects but laboring, middle-aged men spending every cent on wood and rent, and old men still carrying wood-saws. Prejudice, ignorance and poverty keep them so. The Pilgrims did not sit still, she says, and asks whether the men have petitioned the legislature for the rights of free citizens.

    Why it mattersThe ending turns from pity to responsibility. Stewart gives Black men the same treatment she gave white listeners, praise and challenge together, and she closes with questions they must answer by acting.

Rhetorical choices what the writer does, and why it works

Biblical allusion

Stewart’s lecture is built from Scripture. The opening borrows the four starving men at the gate of Samaria in 2 Kings 7, “Tell it not in Gath” is David’s lament in 2 Samuel, and “Ethiopia shall stretch forth her hands unto God” is Psalm 68. The allusions give a woman without schooling the authority of the one book every listener respected.

Anaphora

Repeated openings drive her longest passages: “Let our girls … let their characters … let their natural taste” in paragraph 6, and “Look at our young men … Look at our middle-aged men … Look at our aged sires” in paragraph 14. The repetition makes a list feel like a weight that keeps growing.

Refutation

Paragraphs 9 and 10 quote the accusers and answer them. She does not deny that her people are “ragged”; she turns the word into evidence against the whites, whose talk of equal rights set Black souls on fire.

Hypophora

Stewart asks questions and answers them herself: “Do you ask,—Why are you wretched and miserable? I reply, look at many of the most worthy.” The device lets her stage a conversation with her audience and keep control of the answers.

Simile

The mind worn down by labor is “like the scorching sands of Arabia” and “like the uncultivated soil,” and their work is as unprofitable “as the spider’s web or the floating bubbles that vanish into air.” Each image describes effort that produces nothing that lasts.

Apostrophe

She turns to speak directly to one group after another: “O, ye fairer sisters” in paragraph 12, “My beloved brethren” in paragraph 14, and in paragraph 6 humanity itself, which she calls on to feel ashamed. Each shift of address brings a new audience into the lecture.

People & audiences

Maria W. Stewart

Speaker

A free Black widow and former servant who speaks from “bitter experience.” She presents herself as called by God, unschooled but unafraid, and ready to die for her words.

The white listeners

Audience

Bostonians who proclaim equal rights while keeping Black people in service. Stewart reasons with them, reminds them of their own idle class, and claims kinship in “your blood flows in my veins.”

The fairer sisters

White women

Women whose hands are never soiled. Stewart asks them to imagine a life of drudgery and to pity Black women, whose minds would be as bright as theirs with the same chances.

The beloved brethren

Black men

The men of her own community, on whom she says women depend. The lecture ends by challenging them to make mighty efforts and to petition for their rights.

Our girls and young men

The next generation

The daughters who cannot be hired outside service and the sons who can be nothing but laborers. Their blocked futures are the lecture’s central evidence.

The colonizationists

Opponents

Supporters of sending free Black Americans to Africa, who called them lazy, idle and ragged. Stewart quotes their charges in order to answer them.

Big ideas in Lecture at Franklin Hall

Prejudice as a second slaveryEducation and the mindA woman’s voiceEqual rights for all who hear of themEffort and faith

Prejudice as a second slavery

Stewart argues that the free people of color are not bought or sold but are held almost as firmly by custom. The chains she describes are made of hiring practices, poverty and ignorance.

Education and the mind

The chains of ignorance are the most galling of all, and hard labor deadens the faculties. For Stewart, the right to develop the mind is the right that matters most, and the one prejudice most denies.

A woman’s voice

The lecture begins with “Shall it be a woman?” and its last paragraph explains why a woman has come forward. Stewart defends her right to speak by grounding it in God’s will and in women’s dependence on men’s action.

Equal rights for all who hear of them

Whites cannot preach equal rights and expect Black listeners not to take them seriously. “Our souls have caught the flame also” turns American ideals into a claim.

Effort and faith

Stewart relies on God, who will answer the groans of the oppressed, but she insists that prayer is not enough. Like the Pilgrims, her people must first make powerful efforts to raise themselves.

Key images

Chains and fetters

Stewart borrows the language of slavery for the free North. The chains of ignorance and the fetters on the soul show that bondage can survive the end of legal slavery.

Flowers born to bloom unseen

Adapting a famous line from Thomas Gray’s “Elegy Written in a Country Churchyard,” Stewart makes the unseen flowers stand for the talents of Black women and men that servitude keeps from ever being noticed.

Repeated words and ideas

Servants. The word “servant” and its relatives return in almost every paragraph, from “a servant of servants” to “the servile situations which most of them fill.” The repetition shows how completely one kind of work defines a whole people’s future.

Death. “We shall but die,” “I would gladly hail death,” “I can but die for expressing my sentiments”: death returns as the price Stewart is willing to pay, which makes her courage part of her argument.

Tensions and counterarguments

Principle vs. practice. White Americans proclaim equal rights while refusing to hire Black girls or let Black men rise above labor. Stewart sets the words and the practice side by side.

Speaker vs. custom. A woman speaking in public to men and women broke the custom of her time. Stewart addresses it directly and expects to become “a hissing and a reproach” for doing it.

Key quotes

“Methinks I heard a spiritual interrogation—‘Who shall go forward, and take off the reproach that is cast upon the people of color? Shall it be a woman?’”
Paragraph 3. Stewart answers the objection to her speaking before anyone can make it. Putting the question in a spiritual voice makes her lecture an act of obedience.
“Yet, after all, methinks there are no chains so galling as the chains of ignorance—no fetters so binding as those that bind the soul, and exclude it from the vast field of useful and scientific knowledge.”
Paragraph 4. The language of slavery applied to the mind. For Stewart, being kept from knowledge is a bondage the free North shares with the South.
“I can but die for expressing my sentiments; and I am as willing to die by the sword as the pestilence—for I am a true born American—your blood flows in my veins, and your spirit fires my breast.”
Paragraph 8. Stewart claims the nation as her own. “Your blood” can be read as a claim of shared birth and of shared ancestry, and either way it denies her listeners the right to treat her as a stranger.
“I reply to it, the whites have so long and so loudly proclaimed the theme of equal rights and privileges, that our souls have caught the flame also, ragged as we are.”
Paragraph 10. The insult “a ragged set, crying for liberty” is turned back on those who used it: Black people learned to cry for liberty from the whites themselves.
“As servants, we are respected; but let us presume to aspire any higher, our employer regards us no longer.”
Paragraph 11. Two balanced clauses state the trap exactly. Respect depends on staying in place, and ambition ends it.
“O, ye fairer sisters, whose hands are never soiled, whose nerves and muscles are never strained, go learn by experience!”
Paragraph 12. A direct address to white women, built on parallel “whose” clauses. The command asks them to imagine a life they have never had to live.
How it ends

The conclusion of Lecture at Franklin Hall, explained

The last paragraph is the longest, and it is addressed to the men of Stewart’s own community. She opens with a comparison: just as Christ died in vain for anyone who refuses his mercy, the friends of freedom will speak in vain unless Black men make mighty efforts for their sons and daughters. Then she explains why she, a woman, has come forward. Woman depends on men, she says, and can do little but use her influence, so it is for women’s sake that she has made herself “a hissing and a reproach,” a phrase from the prophet Jeremiah that names exactly what a woman speaker could expect. The paragraph then becomes a set of portraits introduced by “Look at”: the worthy women in gentlemen’s kitchens, the young men with nothing ahead of them but laboring, the middle-aged men spending every cent on wood and rent, the old men of seventy still carrying wood-saws. Her diagnosis is three words long: “Prejudice, ignorance and poverty.” She hopes God has heard their groans, using the name “Lord of Sabaoth,” which the Letter of James uses for the God who hears the cries of unpaid laborers, but she warns that prayers are useless without effort. The Pilgrims did not accept that the Britons had all the money and power; they worked, and God sent Washington and Lafayette. The lecture ends on two questions. Have you made a powerful effort? Have you petitioned the legislature for the rights of free citizens? Stewart leaves the answer to her listeners, which makes the ending a demand rather than a conclusion.

Common misreadings

MythStewart is describing slavery in the South.

ActuallyShe sets Southern slavery aside in paragraph 4 and describes the free people of color of the North, whose condition she calls “but little better” than slavery.

MythShe looks down on servants and domestic work.

ActuallyIn paragraph 12 she says it is not “derogatory” to live out to service and praises any honest livelihood. Her objection is to being confined to service by prejudice, with no chance to rise.

MythThe lecture is addressed only to white listeners.

ActuallyShe speaks in turn to whites, to white women, and to Black men, and her last paragraph is a challenge to her own community.

MythThe exam passage is the whole lecture.

ActuallyThe exam printed paragraphs 8 to 11 of 14. The full lecture adds the opening dilemma, the question “Shall it be a woman?”, the story of the shopkeepers, and the closing appeals.

AP practice a rhetorical analysis prompt in the exam's style

In September 1832 Maria W. Stewart, a free Black woman and former servant, lectured at Franklin Hall in Boston to an audience of women and men, Black and white. Read the lecture carefully. Then write an essay that analyzes the rhetorical choices Stewart makes to argue that prejudice, not a lack of ability, keeps free Black Americans in servitude.

What a strong response notices

  • The opening dilemma in paragraph 2 and the question “Shall it be a woman?” in paragraph 3, which establish her right to speak.
  • The anecdote of the shopkeepers in paragraph 5 and the repeated “let” clauses in paragraph 6, which show prejudice at work.
  • The personal claims in paragraph 8, from preferring death to servitude to “a true born American.”
  • The refutation of the colonizationists in paragraphs 9 and 10, especially the turn in “ragged as we are,” and the similes of barren labor in paragraphs 10 and 11.
  • The shifts of address to “ye fairer sisters” in paragraph 12 and “my beloved brethren” in paragraph 14, and the closing questions.

Practice prompt written by StoryBites, not taken from a College Board exam. See the AP Language free-response guide for how answers are scored.

Test yourself

1. Which group does Stewart mainly describe?

2. What did the businesswomen tell Stewart when she asked about hiring Black girls?

3. How does Stewart answer the charge that Black people are “a ragged set, crying for liberty”?

4. Whom does Stewart address as “ye fairer sisters”?

5. What does Stewart ask Black men at the end of the lecture?

Flashcards flip, self-grade, and the deck remembers what you know

tap to flip
Answer

Report a mistake on this card

Explain it like I’m 12

In 1832, women almost never gave speeches to crowds of men and women. Maria Stewart, a Black woman in Boston who had worked as a servant since she was a little girl, did it anyway. She said that Black people in the North were free on paper, but prejudice kept them stuck: shop owners wouldn’t hire Black girls for anything except cleaning, and Black men could only find hard labor. She said hard work with no chance to learn wears out your mind. She asked white women to imagine living that way, and she told Black men to work hard and demand their rights as citizens.

Compare & connect

Ain’t I a Woman?

Sojourner Truth

Nineteen years later another Black woman stood before a mostly white audience and used her own life of labor as evidence. Both answer claims about what Black women are and can do, from experience no one else in the room had.

What to the Slave Is the Fourth of July?

Frederick Douglass

Douglass, like Stewart, takes America’s language of liberty and turns it on the white audience who proclaim it. Comparing them shows two ways of handling the gap between principle and practice.

Declaration of Sentiments

Elizabeth Cady Stanton

In 1848 the women at Seneca Falls listed the ways women were shut out of education and profitable work. Stewart made a version of that complaint sixteen years earlier, for Black women in particular.

Discussion and essay prompts:

💬 Discussion questions

  • What is Maria Stewart’s argument in her Franklin Hall lecture
  • Why was Maria Stewart’s 1832 lecture important
  • What rhetorical strategies does Maria Stewart use
  • How does Lecture at Franklin Hall explore the theme of prejudice as a second slavery?
  • How does Lecture at Franklin Hall explore the theme of education and the mind?
  • What is the central conflict in Lecture at Franklin Hall, and how does it shape the ending?

✎ Essay prompts

  1. Analyze how Maria W. Stewart develops the theme of prejudice as a second slavery in Lecture at Franklin Hall. Support your argument with specific evidence from the text.
  2. Examine the significance of chains and fetters in Lecture at Franklin Hall. What does it represent, and how does it deepen the work’s meaning?
  3. How does Maria W. Stewart use biblical allusion to shape the reader’s experience of Lecture at Franklin Hall?
  4. Some readers assume that stewart is describing slavery in the South. Argue for or against this interpretation, using evidence from the text.

Key questions students ask

  • What is Maria Stewart’s argument in her Franklin Hall lecture
  • Why was Maria Stewart’s 1832 lecture important
  • What rhetorical strategies does Maria Stewart use
  • How does Stewart answer the colonizationists
  • Who is Stewart’s audience in the lecture
  • What does Stewart mean by the chains of ignorance

Analysis is original StoryBites commentary. The full text and quotations follow the lecture’s first printing, in the Liberator (Boston) of November 17, 1832, page 183, transcribed line by line from the Internet Archive’s scan of that issue. The 1879 printing in Meditations from the Pen of Mrs. Maria W. Stewart was collated as a check; it is a revised text, reading for example “Why sit ye here” and “must pursue,” and this edition does not follow it. The 1835 Productions of Mrs. Maria W. Stewart was not consulted. The exam’s text agrees with the Liberator in wording except that it reads “there being” where the Liberator prints “their being” and capitalizes “King Eternal”; its punctuation differs throughout, with semicolons and periods where the Liberator has dashes (“Again. It was asserted” for “Again—It was asserted”). The lecture is in the public domain. An excerpt from the lecture was the passage for the rhetorical analysis question on the 2005 Form B AP English Language exam (College Board free-response questions, 2005 Form B).

Share this guide

Continue exploring

Follow a thread — every work connects to others through what they share.