The Reigate Puzzle

Sent to the Surrey countryside to recover from exhaustion, Holmes reads a murder from a torn scrap of paper written by two hands, and fakes a fit to catch the killers.

⏱ 10 min to understand 4 themes · 3 symbols · 6 quotes Public domain text Take notes
📖 Read the full storyThe complete public-domain text, then come back to check what you caught
0% explored
Story in 60 seconds

Holmes has collapsed after outwitting the cleverest swindler in Europe, and Watson takes him to a friend’s house near Reigate for a quiet week. Within a day a local coachman is shot dead, apparently by a burglar, and all the police have is a corner of paper in the dead man’s fingers. Holmes looks at the handwriting and his illness seems to vanish. Then, in front of everyone, he falls to the ground in a fit.

What happens in The Reigate Puzzle

In April 1887 Holmes breaks down in a hotel in Lyons after two months of nonstop work on a vast European fraud. Watson brings him home and then to Reigate in Surrey to stay with Colonel Hayter, an old army patient. The Colonel mentions that the house of a local magnate, old Acton, was burgled last week, though the thieves took only odd items such as a volume of Pope’s Homer and a ball of twine. The next morning the butler brings news of murder at the Cunninghams’, the other great house nearby: William Kirwan, the coachman, has been shot dead. Inspector Forrester arrives to ask for Holmes’s help. Old Mr. Cunningham and his son Alec say they saw a burglar wrestling with William, firing, and escaping over the hedge. The only clue is a scrap of paper torn from a larger sheet, found between the dead man’s finger and thumb, with the words ‘at quarter to twelve’, ‘learn what’ and ‘maybe’. Holmes studies it with fierce interest and goes off with the Inspector, returning in high spirits. At the Cunninghams’ house, just as the Inspector is about to mention the paper, Holmes collapses in what looks like a nervous fit. Recovering, he asks old Cunningham to sign a reward notice and seems to make a slip by writing ‘quarter to one’; Cunningham corrects it to ‘twelve’. Holmes then insists on looking over the bedrooms. In Mr. Cunningham’s room he deliberately knocks over a table of oranges and a water jug, lets Watson take the blame, and slips away. A moment later the others hear him shouting for help and find father and son trying to strangle him in Alec’s dressing room. Holmes has them arrested for murder and produces the rest of the torn note. Back at the Colonel’s, with Acton present, he explains. The scrap was written by two people taking turns, one young and one old, both of the same family. There was no powder burn on William, so the shot was not fired in a struggle, and there were no footprints in the damp ditch where the ‘burglar’ supposedly fled. The Cunninghams had raided Acton’s library to find a document in their lawsuit with him. William had followed them and was blackmailing them, so they lured him out with a note and shot him. The faint and the overturned table were tricks: one to change the subject, the other to search Alec’s dressing gown. The full note invites William to the east gate at quarter to twelve, mentioning someone called Annie Morrison. Holmes declares his country rest a success.

Where and when The Reigate Puzzle happens

Place

Colonel Hayter’s house near Reigate

A bachelor household in Surrey with a gun room full of Eastern weapons, chosen as a quiet place for Holmes to recover.

Place

The Cunninghams’ house

A fine old Queen Anne house with a kitchen passage, two staircases, and the bedrooms and dressing room where Holmes is attacked.

Place

The garden and the ditch

The hard ground by the kitchen door where William fell, and the damp ditch by the road that should have held the escaping burglar’s bootmarks.

Time

April 1887

Days after Holmes’s triumph over a great swindler, when Europe is ringing with his name and he is sunk in depression.

Timeline the story arc, beat by beat

  1. The opening
    Holmes breaks down

    Exhausted after a great European case, Holmes is taken by Watson to rest with Colonel Hayter near Reigate.

  2. The background
    An odd burglary

    The Colonel mentions that thieves broke into Acton’s library and took only worthless odds and ends.

  3. The crime
    Murder at the Cunninghams’

    The coachman William Kirwan is shot dead, and a scrap of paper is found in his hand naming the hour of his death.

  4. The ruse
    A sudden fit

    Holmes collapses just as the Inspector is about to mention the paper, then tricks old Cunningham into writing the word twelve.

  5. The search
    Oranges on the carpet

    Holmes knocks over a table of fruit, blames Watson, and slips away to search Alec’s dressing gown.

  6. The climax
    Caught by the throat

    Father and son attack Holmes for the missing paper, and the Inspector arrests them for murder.

  7. The solution
    Two hands, one note

    Holmes shows the note was written in turns by a father and son, explains the blackmail motive, and calls his holiday a success.

Characters and how they connect

Sherlock Holmes

Consulting detective

A man too ill to rest who is cured by a puzzle, and who here wins as much by acting, faking a fit and a mistake, as by reasoning.

Dr. Watson

Holmes’s friend and the story’s teller

A doctor who tries to keep his patient away from crime, takes the blame for the spilled oranges without understanding why, and is fooled by the fit like everyone else.

Colonel Hayter

Their host

An old soldier and former patient of Watson’s whose idle mention of a burglary sets the case in motion.

Inspector Forrester

County police officer

A keen young detective who does good groundwork but assumes the local gentry cannot be suspects.

Mr. Cunningham

Justice of the peace and local magnate

An elderly squire and magistrate who helps write the note that lures his coachman to his death.

Alec Cunningham

His son

A dashing, mocking young man who fires the fatal shot, tears the note from the dead man’s hand, and is the real leader of the plot.

William Kirwan

The Cunninghams’ coachman

A servant thought loyal who had secretly watched his masters raid Acton’s house and was blackmailing them.

Mr. Acton

A neighbouring landowner

The Cunninghams’ opponent in a long lawsuit over half their estate, whose library they burgled for a paper.

Character Relationships who connects to whom, and the themes that bind them

Most connected Mr. Cunningham Where the most relationships meet.

Family

Mr. Cunningham Alec Cunningham

familyfather and accomplice

Friendship / ally

Colonel Hayter Dr. Watson

friendshipold patient and host

Connection

William Kirwan Mr. Cunningham

blackmailblackmails his master

Mr. Cunningham Mr. Acton

conflictrivals in a lawsuit

Inspector Forrester Sherlock Holmes

clientasks for help

Alec Cunningham William Kirwan

murderlures and shoots

Family Friendship / ally Connection

Themes in The Reigate Puzzle what the story is really about

Work as a cureRespectability hiding crimeGreed and propertyDeception as a tool

Work as a cure

Holmes is near collapse at the start, yet the moment he sees the handwriting his colour returns, and he leaves Reigate saying he feels invigorated. Rest does nothing for him and a puzzle does everything.

Respectability hiding crime

The Inspector never suspects the Cunninghams because they are county magnates, and Holmes’s refusal to hold such prejudices is what solves the case.

Greed and property

A lawsuit over half an estate leads to burglary, then blackmail, then murder, each step following from the one before.

Deception as a tool

The killers fake a burglary to cover their crime, and Holmes fakes illness and error to expose them, so trickery appears on both sides of the law.

Symbols & motifs

The torn scrap of paper

A corner of a note left in a dead man’s grip carries the killers’ handwriting, their family likeness and their guilt, a small fragment that holds the whole crime.

The worthless loot from Acton’s

A ball of twine and a single volume of Homer look like a clumsy thief’s grab, but their very oddness shows the burglars were after something else.

The spilled oranges

A comic mess on the carpet is really a planned distraction, a sign that Holmes is in full control while seeming at his weakest.

Recurring motifs

Illness. Holmes’s real breakdown, his staged fit, William’s deaf and feeble mother and Watson’s professional worry keep sickness in view, and Holmes turns everyone’s pity for him into a weapon.

Writing and signatures. The torn note, the reward notice Cunningham corrects, and the twenty-three further points Holmes finds in the script make handwriting the heart of the investigation.

Father and son. The two Cunninghams write in alternate words, tell matching lies and attack Holmes together, a partnership in which the son leads.

Conflicts

Person vs. person

Holmes against the Cunninghams, a battle of bluffs that ends in a real struggle for the paper.

Person vs. person

The Cunninghams against Acton in a ruinous lawsuit, and against William, who has caught them out.

Person vs. self

Holmes’s exhausted body and low spirits against his need to work, a struggle Watson tries and fails to manage.

Literary devices

The deduction chain
Holmes reasons in steps. If the burglar fled at once after the shot, he could not have torn the note from William’s hand, and by the time old Cunningham came down, servants were there, so Alec must have taken it. The note itself is in two hands taking turns: the strong hand wrote its words first and left gaps, since ‘quarter’ is squeezed between ‘at’ and ‘to’, so the strong writer was the leader. The strong hand is young and the shaky one old, and shared quirks such as the Greek e show they are related. There was no powder burn, so the shot came from more than four yards, not in a struggle. There were no bootmarks in the damp ditch where the man supposedly escaped, so there was no burglar at all. The Acton burglary and the lawsuit supply a motive, and Holmes tricks old Cunningham into writing ‘twelve’ to compare with the note.
Facsimile of evidence
Watson reproduces the torn scrap and later the whole note on the page, so readers can test Holmes’s handwriting deductions for themselves.
Unreliable surface
Watson reports Holmes’s fit, his slip over the time and the spilled fruit as signs of illness, and only the explanation reveals each as a deliberate move.
Irony
Watson brings Holmes to the country to keep him away from crime, and the quiet parish produces a murder within a day, which turns out to be the best medicine he could have had.
Delayed explanation
Holmes keeps his reasoning hidden until the arrest is made, then lays it out in order at the Colonel’s table, the classic shape of the Holmes story.

Important quotes

“at a time when Europe was ringing with his name and when his room was literally ankle-deep with congratulatory telegrams I found him a prey to the blackest depression.”
Watson describes Holmes in Lyons at the height of his fame and the depth of his exhaustion.
“I have usually found that there was method in his madness.”
Watson defends Holmes to the doubtful Inspector, who replies that some might find madness in his method.
“It is of the highest importance in the art of detection to be able to recognize, out of a number of facts, which are incidental and which vital.”
Holmes opens his explanation with the principle that led him straight to the scrap of paper.
“Now, I make a point of never having any prejudices, and of following docilely wherever fact may lead me”
Holmes explains why he suspected the Cunninghams when the Inspector would not.
“there cannot be the least doubt in the world that it has been written by two persons doing alternate words.”
Holmes reveals the central clue in the handwriting of the torn note.
“Tut, man, look at their faces!”
Holmes, half strangled, telling the bewildered Inspector to make the arrest.
Ending explained

The ending of The Reigate Puzzle, explained

The story ends at the Colonel’s house with Holmes, a little shaken and helping himself to brandy, explaining everything to Watson, the Colonel and Mr. Acton. He reveals that his fit was a performance. The Inspector had been about to mention the scrap of paper in front of the Cunninghams, which would have warned them to destroy the rest of it, so Holmes fell to the ground to change the subject. Watson admits, as a doctor, that it was admirably done. The slip in the reward notice, writing ‘quarter to one’, was also planned, to make old Cunningham write the word ‘twelve’ for comparison. Knocking over the oranges gave him a moment to search Alec’s dressing gown, where he found the missing part of the note. Old Cunningham confessed the motive. William had secretly followed his masters on their raid on Acton’s library and was blackmailing them. Alec saw that the county’s burglary scare gave him a perfect cover, so father and son wrote a note in turns to lure William out at quarter to twelve and shot him. The full note promises William that he will learn something of great service to him and to an Annie Morrison. Holmes admits he does not know how she fits in, which leaves a small loose thread. He ends by joking that the quiet rest in the country has done him good. The joke carries a real point: the case shows that Holmes is cured not by fresh air but by work, which is both his strength and, as his breakdown at the start shows, his danger. The story first ran in The Strand as The Reigate Squire, and later editions call it The Reigate Squires or The Reigate Puzzle.

Common misreadings

MythHolmes’s fit at the Cunninghams’ house was a relapse of his illness.

ActuallyIt was faked, to stop the Inspector from mentioning the torn paper in front of the killers.

MythHolmes made a careless mistake on the reward notice.

ActuallyHe wrote the wrong time on purpose so that old Cunningham would correct it in his own hand, giving Holmes a sample of the word twelve.

MythA burglar killed William Kirwan.

ActuallyThere was no burglar. Alec Cunningham shot William, who was blackmailing him and his father, and the burglary was invented to cover it.

Test yourself

1. Why are Holmes and Watson staying near Reigate?

2. What does Holmes deduce from the torn note?

3. Why does Holmes write ‘quarter to one’ on the reward notice?

4. What two clues show there was no burglar?

5. Why was William killed?

Explain it like I’m 12

Sherlock Holmes has worked so hard that he gets sick, so Watson takes him to the countryside to rest. But a coachman is shot, and two rich neighbours, a father and son, say a burglar did it. The only clue is a torn bit of paper in the dead man’s hand. Holmes sees that two people wrote it, taking turns with each word, and that they were an old man and a young man from the same family. To catch them, Holmes pretends to faint, pretends to make a mistake, and knocks over some oranges so he can sneak off and find the rest of the note in the son’s pocket. The father and son attack him, and the police arrest them.

Flashcards flip, self-grade, and the deck remembers what you know

tap to flip
Answer

Compare & connect the story universe

The Adventure of the Copper Beeches

Arthur Conan Doyle

Holmes warns there that the smiling countryside can hide worse sin than London’s alleys, and in Reigate a respected country family turns out to be the killers.

The Purloined Letter

Edgar Allan Poe

Dupin arranges a disturbance to draw his opponent’s eyes away and recovers a paper, just as Holmes upsets the oranges to search the dressing gown.

The Adventure of the Speckled Band

Arthur Conan Doyle

Another old landed family turns to murder to protect its money, and Holmes again has to look past a respectable surface and a story about outsiders.

Discussion & essay prompts for class, or your next paper

💬 Discussion questions

  • Who killed William Kirwan in The Reigate Puzzle
  • Why did Holmes fake a fit in The Reigate Squires
  • How did Holmes know two people wrote the note
  • How does The Reigate Puzzle explore the theme of work as a cure?
  • How does The Reigate Puzzle explore the theme of respectability hiding crime?
  • What is the central conflict in The Reigate Puzzle, and how does it shape the ending?

✎ Essay prompts

  1. Analyze how Arthur Conan Doyle develops the theme of work as a cure in The Reigate Puzzle. Support your argument with specific evidence from the text.
  2. Examine the significance of the torn scrap of paper in The Reigate Puzzle. What does it represent, and how does it deepen the work’s meaning?
  3. How does Arthur Conan Doyle use the deduction chain to shape the reader’s experience of The Reigate Puzzle?
  4. Some readers assume that holmes’s fit at the Cunninghams’ house was a relapse of his illness. Argue for or against this interpretation, using evidence from the text.

Key questions students ask

  • Who killed William Kirwan in The Reigate Puzzle
  • Why did Holmes fake a fit in The Reigate Squires
  • How did Holmes know two people wrote the note
  • Why did the Cunninghams burgle Mr Acton’s house
  • Why did Holmes knock over the oranges
  • Why is Holmes ill at the start of The Reigate Puzzle

Analysis is original StoryBites commentary. The text and the quotations follow the Standard Ebooks edition of The Memoirs of Sherlock Holmes (1894), which uses the title The Reigate Puzzle. The story first appeared in The Strand Magazine in June 1893. It is in the public domain.

Share this story

Continue exploring

Follow a thread — every work connects to others through what they share.
This StoryBites Editioneverything for this work, in one place