The Republic
On a festival night in the port of Athens, Socrates is asked what justice is and whether it pays, and to answer he builds an ideal city ruled by philosophers.
📖 Read the full bookThe complete public-domain novel, paired with the StoryBites version of every chapterWould you still be good if you could never be caught? Glaucon puts the question with a story about a shepherd who finds a ring that makes him invisible, and Socrates spends the rest of a long night answering it. His answer grows into a whole imagined city: soldiers who own nothing, a myth told to keep every citizen content with their place, women trained beside men, children raised in common and rulers who are philosophers. Along the way come some of the most famous images in Western thought, the sun, the divided line and the prisoners in the cave, and a fierce attack on the poets, Homer included. The Republic looks like a book about politics and keeps turning out to be a book about the soul, and its questions about power, education and happiness still start arguments in every classroom that reads it.
What happens in The Republic
Socrates tells how he went down to the Piraeus, the port of Athens, for a new festival and was kept there by Polemarchus, son of the old and wealthy Cephalus. At Cephalus’s house the talk turns to justice. Cephalus suggests it means telling the truth and paying what you owe, Polemarchus that it means helping friends and harming enemies, and the sophist Thrasymachus that it is simply the interest of the stronger, so that injustice on a large scale pays best. Socrates silences Thrasymachus without convincing him. Plato’s brothers Glaucon and Adeimantus then raise the real challenge: using the story of Gyges’ ring, they ask Socrates to prove that justice is worth having for its own sake, even if a just man were thought unjust and tortured for it. Since a city is easier to read than a soul, Socrates builds one in words. It has three classes, rulers, auxiliaries and producers, each told a myth that god mixed gold, silver or iron and brass into them; its guardians are raised on censored stories and music, and live without property. Justice in the city turns out to be each class doing its own work, and justice in the person is the same order among the soul’s three parts, with reason ruling, spirit as its ally and appetite obeying. Pressed to explain himself, Socrates rides three waves of objection: women may be guardians, the guardians will have no private families, and the city can only exist if philosophers become kings. That leads to what a philosopher knows, explained through the sun, the divided line and the cave, and to the long education that turns the rulers toward the Form of the Good. Socrates then traces how the ideal city decays through timocracy, oligarchy and democracy into tyranny, and shows that the tyrannical soul is the most enslaved and miserable of all, while the just person is the happiest. In Book X he banishes imitative poetry, argues that the soul is immortal, and ends with the myth of Er, a soldier who saw the dead choose their next lives.
Where and when The Republic happens
The house of Cephalus in the Piraeus
The home of a wealthy family in the port of Athens, where a group of friends gathers on a festival evening and the whole conversation takes place.
The city in speech
The ideal city Socrates and his friends found in words, with its three classes and philosopher rulers; by Book IX Glaucon doubts it exists anywhere on earth.
The meadow of judgment in the myth of Er
The place where souls are judged, return from journeys of a thousand years, and choose their next lives before the spindle of Necessity.
A festival in Socrates’ lifetime
The talk is set on the day of the first festival in Athens for the Thracian goddess Bendis; Plato wrote it decades later, after Socrates had been executed in 399 BC.
Chapter by chapter summary + why it matters
- 1
Book I: What Is Justice? Cephalus, Polemarchus and Thrasymachus
Socrates tells how he went down to the Piraeus with Glaucon for the new festival of Bendis and was made to stay by Polemarchus. At the house of Polemarchus’s father Cephalus, the old man says the best thing wealth gives is the chance to die owing nothing to gods or men, and Socrates turns this into a definition: justice is telling the truth and paying back what you owe. A single case, returning weapons to a friend who has gone mad, breaks it. Polemarchus, the heir of the argument, defends the poet Simonides: justice is helping friends and harming enemies. Socrates argues that harming anyone makes them worse, so a just man can harm no one. Then Thrasymachus bursts in, declares that justice is the interest of the stronger and that injustice on a large scale pays better than justice. Socrates answers with arguments from the crafts, from the need for justice even in a band of thieves, and from the proper work of the soul, until Thrasymachus blushes and gives way. Socrates closes by admitting that they still have not found what justice is.
Why it mattersBook I reads like one of Plato’s short early dialogues that end in puzzlement. Its three speakers stand for three ideas of justice, inherited custom, popular morality and raw power, and because Thrasymachus is silenced rather than persuaded, the real argument has to begin again in Book II.
Quiz Book I: What Is Justice? Cephalus, Polemarchus and Thrasymachus 5 questions
1. How does Socrates break Cephalus’s idea that justice is telling the truth and paying back what you owe?
No one would say it is right to hand weapons back to a friend who is out of his mind, so paying what you owe cannot be the whole of justice.
2. Which definition does Polemarchus take from the poet Simonides?
Polemarchus reads Simonides as saying we owe good to friends and harm to enemies; the other answers belong to Thrasymachus, Socrates and Glaucon.
3. What does Thrasymachus first claim when he bursts into the discussion?
He says every government makes laws for its own advantage, so what is called just is whatever serves those in power.
4. Why, according to Socrates, can a just man never harm anyone?
Socrates argues that to harm a man is to make him less just, and a just person can no more make others unjust than a musician can make them unmusical by music.
5. How does Book I end?
Socrates compares himself to a greedy diner who tasted every dish without enjoying any: he has argued about justice without finding its nature.
- 2
Book II: Gyges’ Ring and the First City
Glaucon is not satisfied. He sorts good things into three kinds and asks Socrates to prove that justice is good for its own sake and not only for its rewards. To sharpen the challenge he restates Thrasymachus: people make laws as a compromise, because they fear suffering wrong more than they enjoy doing it, and anyone given the shepherd Gyges’ ring, which makes its wearer invisible, would steal, seduce and kill as Gyges did when he took the throne of Lydia. He then sets a perfectly unjust man with a spotless name beside a perfectly just man thought wicked, who is scourged, racked and at last impaled. Adeimantus adds that parents and poets praise justice only for what it brings, and say the gods can be bought off with sacrifices. Socrates proposes to look for justice first in a city, as large letters are easier to read than small. He founds a simple city of farmers and craftsmen, which Glaucon calls a city of pigs, then a luxurious one that needs more land, and so war and an army of guardians, gentle to friends and fierce to enemies like good dogs. Their education starts with stories, and Socrates begins to censor them: god must be shown as good, the cause of good only, never changing shape and never lying.
Why it mattersGlaucon’s challenge is the hinge of the whole work: from here on Socrates must show that justice is worth having even if no one ever sees it. Looking for justice in a city in order to find it in a soul becomes the method of the rest of the book.
Quiz Book II: Gyges’ Ring and the First City 5 questions
1. What does Glaucon think the story of Gyges’ ring proves?
Glaucon argues that the just and the unjust man would behave alike if both wore the ring, so people are just only because they cannot safely be unjust.
2. According to Glaucon’s version of the popular view, where does justice come from?
He presents justice as a middle point between doing wrong unpunished, the best, and suffering wrong without revenge, the worst.
3. What does Adeimantus add to his brother’s challenge?
Adeimantus says no one praises justice for itself; even the poets promise rewards and teach that the gods can be won over by sacrifices.
4. Why does Socrates decide to look for justice in a city before looking in a person?
Socrates compares the city to the same letters written large, which a short-sighted reader can study before turning to the small print of the soul.
5. What does Glaucon call the first, simple city Socrates describes?
Glaucon mocks its plain diet, and his demand for luxuries is what brings in wealth, war and the need for guardians.
- 3
Book III: Guardians, Music and the Noble Lie
Socrates goes on censoring the stories the guardians will hear: nothing that makes death frightening, no heroes weeping or gods laughing out of control, nothing that teaches greed or disrespect. He turns from what stories say to how they say it, separating plain narration from imitation, and decides the guardians should imitate only good men, so the poet who can imitate anything is to be anointed with myrrh, crowned with wool and sent away to another city. Music is cut back to the simple modes and rhythms that build courage and self-control, and training of the body stays plain, with doctors and judges for real need, not for pampering. The rulers will be the best of the older guardians, tested from childhood to see who holds firm to the city’s good; the rest become auxiliaries. All the citizens are to be told one royal lie: that they were formed inside the earth, that they are all brothers, and that god mixed gold into the rulers, silver into the auxiliaries, and brass and iron into the farmers and craftsmen, with children moved up or down by the metal in them. The guardians will live in common camps, with no private property and no gold or silver.
Why it mattersPlato treats stories and music as the strongest forces shaping a child’s character, which is why he controls them so tightly. The myth of the metals is the most troubling idea in the book, since the city’s harmony rests on a story its founders know to be false.
Quiz Book III: Guardians, Music and the Noble Lie 5 questions
1. Why does Socrates forbid stories in which heroes weep and dread death?
Soldiers raised on tales of a terrible underworld and wailing heroes would choose defeat and slavery over death.
2. What happens to the poet who can imitate anything?
Socrates treats him as a wonderful being but says the city has no place for him, because its guardians should imitate only good men.
3. In the myth of the metals, what has god mixed into those fit to rule?
Gold marks the rulers, silver the auxiliaries, and brass and iron the farmers and craftsmen.
4. Can a child be moved out of the class of their parents?
A golden parent may have a child of brass or iron, who must be moved down, and a craftsman’s child with gold in them is raised to be a guardian.
5. How will the guardians live?
Socrates fears that guardians who owned land and money would become masters of the citizens instead of their allies.
- 4
Book IV: The Four Virtues and the Three Parts of the Soul
Adeimantus objects that the guardians, who own nothing, will not be happy. Socrates answers that they are founding the city for the happiness of the whole, not of one class, just as a painter does not color a statue’s eyes purple because eyes are the finest part. The city must avoid both wealth and poverty, stay one city, and above all protect its education. With the city founded, they look for its four virtues. Wisdom lives in the rulers; courage in the auxiliaries, whose right belief about what to fear holds like wool dyed fast; temperance in the agreement of all the classes about who should rule; and justice in each class doing its own work and not meddling in the others’. Socrates then shows that the soul has matching parts, because a thirsty man can want to drink and refuse at the same moment: reason, spirit and appetite. The story of Leontius, who stared at corpses while furious at his own eyes, shows spirit fighting appetite on reason’s side. A just person is one whose reason rules, with spirit as its ally and appetite obeying, and injustice is civil war in the soul, as disease is in the body.
Why it mattersHere Socrates gives his answer to Book I: justice is an inner order of the soul, and just actions are the ones that keep that order. Asking whether such justice pays now sounds like asking whether health pays.
Quiz Book IV: The Four Virtues and the Three Parts of the Soul 5 questions
1. How does Socrates answer Adeimantus’s complaint that the guardians will not be happy?
Like a painter who colors each part of a statue to suit the whole figure, the founders give each class what makes the whole city best.
2. Where does Socrates find temperance in the city?
Unlike wisdom and courage, which belong to one class, temperance runs through the whole city like a harmony.
3. What does the thirsty man who refuses to drink show?
One thing cannot both pull toward and away from the same object at once, so the desire to drink and the force that forbids it must be different parts.
4. What does the story of Leontius illustrate?
Leontius rages at his own eyes for wanting to look at the bodies, showing a part of the soul distinct from desire.
5. What is justice in the soul, according to Book IV?
Justice in the person mirrors justice in the city: reason rules, spirit supports it, and appetite obeys.
- 5
Book V: The Three Waves and the Philosopher-King
As Socrates begins on the corrupt kinds of city, Polemarchus whispers to Adeimantus, and the company demands that he explain his passing remark that friends will hold wives and children in common. He faces three waves of objection. First, women with the right nature will be trained and serve as guardians beside men, because the difference that matters for a task is ability, no more than baldness decides who may be a cobbler, though Socrates still calls women weaker on the whole. Second, the guardians will have no private families: unions are arranged at festivals by rigged lots, children are raised in common nurseries, and the whole class treats each other as kin, so the city feels joy and pain like one body. He adds rules for war, among them that Greeks should not enslave Greeks. Third and largest, can such a city exist? Only if philosophers become kings, or kings become philosophers. To defend this Socrates separates the true philosopher, who loves the whole of truth, from the lovers of sights and sounds, and knowledge, which is of what truly is, from opinion, which wanders between being and not-being.
Why it mattersThe three waves carry the city furthest from Athenian custom, and Plato has Socrates expect to be laughed at. The line between knowledge and opinion at the end of the book prepares the ground for the sun, the line and the cave.
Quiz Book V: The Three Waves and the Philosopher-King 5 questions
1. What is the first wave Socrates must survive?
He argues that women and men should share the same education and duties when they share the same abilities.
2. Why does Socrates bring up bald men and long-haired men?
Being bald does not stop a man from being a cobbler, and in the same way the difference between the sexes does not decide who can guard the city.
3. What is the second wave?
Socrates believes that if no guardian can say my child or my house, the class will share one set of joys and griefs.
4. What does Socrates say must happen before the ideal city can exist?
This third and greatest wave is the claim that cities will never have rest from their evils until political power and wisdom meet in one.
5. How does Socrates distinguish knowledge from opinion?
The lovers of sights and sounds know only many beautiful things, while the philosopher grasps beauty itself.
- 6
Book VI: The Ship of State, the Sun and the Divided Line
Socrates lists the philosopher’s nature: love of truth, quickness, good memory, courage and self-control. Adeimantus objects that in real life philosophers are either useless or wicked. Socrates answers with a ship whose quarrelling sailors push aside the half-deaf, short-sighted owner and call the true pilot a star-gazer and a good-for-nothing, which is how cities treat philosophers. He adds that the most gifted natures are the ones most easily corrupted by the crowd and by sophists, who only study the moods of a great strong beast. The rulers must reach the greatest study of all, the Form of the Good. Socrates declines to say what the Good is, but offers its child, the sun: as the sun gives visible things light to be seen by and makes them grow, the Good makes the Forms knowable and gives them their being. He then divides a line into four parts, from shadows and reflections, to visible things, to mathematical reasoning from assumptions, to the dialectic that rises to a first principle, and names four matching states of mind: perception of shadows, faith, understanding and reason.
Why it mattersThe defense of the philosopher reads in part as a defense of Socrates, whom Athens treated as a useless star-gazer and later put to death. The sun and the line are the first two steps of a three-part picture that the cave completes.
Quiz Book VI: The Ship of State, the Sun and the Divided Line 5 questions
1. In the parable of the ship, who stands for the true philosopher?
The real navigator studies the seasons and the stars, and the sailors who want to seize the helm dismiss him as useless.
2. Why, according to Socrates, are the most gifted natures most at risk?
A strong plant in the wrong soil grows wild; flattered by the crowd, the natural philosopher can become the city’s greatest danger.
3. In the analogy of the sun, what does the sun correspond to?
Socrates calls the sun the child of the Good: it plays the same role in the visible world that the Good plays in the world of thought.
4. What does the Good give the Forms, as the sun gives visible things light and growth?
The Good is the source both of the truth of what is known and of its existence, while being greater than existence itself.
5. What is the highest section of the divided line?
Mathematics reasons down from assumptions it does not question, while dialectic climbs past them to the unassumed beginning of everything.
- 7
Book VII: The Cave and the Education of the Rulers
Socrates offers a picture of our nature: prisoners chained from childhood in an underground den, who see only the shadows of objects carried along a wall in front of a fire. One is freed, dragged up the steep way into daylight, and slowly learns to see reflections, then things, then the sun itself, and pities those below. If he went back down, his eyes would fail in the dark, the prisoners would laugh at him, and they would kill anyone who tried to free them. Education, Socrates says, is not putting sight into blind eyes but turning the whole soul toward the light. The founders must compel the philosophers to return and rule, which is fair because the city raised them. Socrates lays out their studies, arithmetic, plane and solid geometry, astronomy and harmonics, each chosen because it draws the mind from what changes toward what is, all leading to dialectic. The chosen students bring the sciences together from 20, study dialectic from 30, serve fifteen years in the cave as officials, and at 50 the best see the Good and take turns ruling. The quickest way to begin such a city is to send everyone over ten into the country and raise the children in its laws.
Why it mattersThe cave gathers the sun and the line into one story about education and its cost. The prisoners’ wish to kill their liberator points straight at the trial of Socrates, and the demand that philosophers go back down answers the charge that they are useless.
Quiz Book VII: The Cave and the Education of the Rulers 5 questions
1. What do the prisoners in the cave take for reality?
Chained so they cannot turn their heads, they have never seen anything but shadows, so they believe the shadows are the real things.
2. What would the prisoners do to someone who tried to free them and lead them up?
Having seen the returning man stumble in the dark, they would think the climb ruins the eyes and would kill anyone who tried it on them.
3. What does Socrates say education really is?
The power to learn is already in the soul; education turns it away from shadows and toward what is real.
4. Why must the philosophers go back down into the cave to rule?
Socrates says the law aims at the happiness of the whole city, and the best rulers are those least eager to rule.
5. Which study crowns the rulers’ education?
The mathematical sciences are a prelude; dialectic alone rises past assumptions to the Good itself.
- 8
Book VIII: How the City Falls, from Honor to Tyranny
Socrates returns to the corrupt constitutions, each with its matching kind of person. Even the best city must decay, because its rulers will one day misjudge the right times for breeding, which the Muses explain in a riddle of numbers, and strife between the metals produces timocracy, the rule of honor-loving soldiers like that of Sparta and Crete. The timocratic man, ambitious and spirited, grows up hearing his mother complain that his quiet father has no place in government; Adeimantus remarks that his love of winning sounds like Glaucon. Love of money turns timocracy into oligarchy, where property decides who rules and the city splits into two, the rich and the poor, with drones, beggars and criminals in between. When the poor win, democracy follows: offices given by lot, everyone free to live as he likes, a charming form of government dispensing a sort of equality to equals and unequals alike, and a democratic man who treats every desire as equal. At last the excess of freedom turns into slavery. The people’s champion asks for a bodyguard, sheds his fellow citizens’ blood like the man in the old tale who tastes human flesh and becomes a wolf, and rules as a tyrant who must stir up wars and get rid of the bravest and wisest.
Why it mattersEach decline follows a change in which part of the soul rules: reason, then spirit and honor, then the necessary appetites and money, then every appetite at once. Plato’s harshest portrait is of democracy, the constitution of the Athens that executed Socrates.
Quiz Book VIII: How the City Falls, from Honor to Tyranny 5 questions
1. Which constitution comes first when the ideal city begins to decay?
The soldiers’ love of honor and victory takes over from reason, as in the Spartan and Cretan constitutions.
2. What decides who rules in an oligarchy?
Oligarchy sets a property qualification for office, so a skilled pilot could be kept from the helm because he is poor.
3. How does Socrates describe democracy?
Its freedom and variety attract people, but it treats everyone and every desire as equal, whatever their worth.
4. What tale does Socrates use for the moment the people’s champion becomes a tyrant?
Once the champion has shed his fellow citizens’ blood, he cannot go back, and he becomes a wolf among men.
5. Why, according to Socrates, does tyranny grow out of democracy?
Freedom pushed to its extreme becomes disorder, and the people hand power to a protector who becomes their master.
- 9
Book IX: The Tyrannical Soul and the Happiness of the Just
Talking first with Adeimantus, Socrates describes the lawless desires that wake in sleep when reason is lulled, which in most people are held down. In the tyrannical man a master passion, like a great winged drone, takes over the soul; he spends, borrows, steals and even strikes his own parents to feed it. The tyrant who actually rules a city is the most wretched of all, the most enslaved, fearful and friendless man alive. With Glaucon as judge, Socrates gives three proofs that the just life is happiest: the tyrannical soul, like the tyrannized city, is a slave; the philosopher, who knows the pleasures of gain and honor as well as his own, is the best judge of pleasure; and only the philosopher’s pleasures are true and pure, while the rest are like grey seen against black. A playful sum shows the king living 729 times more pleasantly than the tyrant. Socrates ends with an image of the soul as a man, a lion and a many-headed beast inside one human shape: injustice feeds the beast and starves the man. The wise person will live by the city they have founded, which may exist nowhere on earth.
Why it mattersBook IX answers Glaucon’s challenge from Book II directly: the man with Gyges’ ring would only feed the beast in himself and become its slave. The closing image of a city laid up in heaven suggests the ideal city matters most as a pattern for ordering one’s own soul.
Quiz Book IX: The Tyrannical Soul and the Happiness of the Just 5 questions
1. When do the lawless desires show themselves in most people?
Socrates says even decent people have wild desires that surface in dreams, while the tyrannical man acts them out awake.
2. Why does Socrates call the actual tyrant the most miserable of men?
Ruled by his own passions and surrounded by enemies, the tyrant cannot travel, trust anyone or do as he likes.
3. Why is the philosopher the best judge of which life is most pleasant?
The lover of gain and the lover of honor have never known the pleasure of learning, but the philosopher knows theirs as well as his own.
4. In the image of the soul as man, lion and many-headed beast, what does the just person do?
Like a good farmer, the inner man tends the gentle heads of the beast and keeps the wild ones from growing.
5. Where does Socrates say the ideal city may be found?
Whether or not it ever exists on earth, anyone who wishes can look at it and set their own soul in order.
- 10
Book X: The Quarrel with Poetry and the Myth of Er
Socrates returns to poetry. Imitation, he argues, stands three removes from the truth: god makes the one Form of a bed, the carpenter makes a bed, and the painter makes only the look of a bed, so Homer, who never gave a city laws or trained followers, imitates what he does not understand. Worse, tragedy and epic feed and water the passions that reason should control, making us enjoy grief we would be ashamed of in our own lives. Only hymns to the gods and praises of famous men may stay, though Socrates admits an ancient quarrel between philosophy and poetry and invites poetry’s lovers to defend her in prose. He argues that the soul is immortal, since its own evil, injustice, cannot destroy it, and now restores the rewards that justice earns from gods and men. He ends with the tale of Er, a soldier who revived on his funeral pyre. Er saw souls judged and repaid tenfold over a thousand years, the spindle of Necessity and the three Fates, and the dead choosing new lives by lot: the first chooser, good only by habit, seizes a great tyranny in haste, and Odysseus, cured of ambition, picks the quiet life of a private man. After drinking from the river of Unmindfulness they are born again, and Socrates urges his friends to hold to justice always.
Why it mattersPlato banishes imitative poetry in a book full of myths and images, an irony he seems to accept by inviting a defense. The myth of Er puts the weight on choice: a good life must be chosen with understanding, and the blame lies with the chooser, not with god.
Quiz Book X: The Quarrel with Poetry and the Myth of Er 5 questions
1. Why is a painting of a bed three removes from the truth?
God makes the Form, the craftsman makes a copy of it, and the painter makes only an appearance of the copy.
2. Which poetry may remain in the city?
Everything else lets pleasure and pain rule in place of law and reason, so it is sent away unless someone can defend it.
3. What does Socrates say tragic and epic poetry does to our emotions?
Enjoying a hero’s grief in the theater, he argues, weakens our control over our own grief in life.
4. In the myth of Er, why does the first soul to choose pick a great tyranny?
Coming from a pleasant life in heaven, he had never been tested, and he only saw afterward that the life included eating his own children.
5. Which life does the soul of Odysseus choose?
Cured of ambition by his past labors, he searches for the life everyone else ignored and says he would have chosen it even with the first lot.
Characters and how they connect
Socrates
Narrator and questioner
The Athenian philosopher who tells the whole conversation the day after it happened. He refutes the first definitions of justice, then builds the ideal city, the images of the sun, line and cave, and the myth of Er to show that the just life is the happiest.
Glaucon
Chief partner in the argument
Plato’s brother, bold and ambitious, who revives Thrasymachus’s case with the ring of Gyges and refuses an easy answer. He calls the first city a city of pigs and follows Socrates through the sun, the line, the cave and the myth of Er.
Adeimantus
Glaucon’s brother
The more practical brother, who adds that people praise justice only for its rewards and keeps pressing awkward objections: that the guardians will be unhappy, that real philosophers are useless or wicked. He is Socrates’ partner for democracy and tyranny.
Thrasymachus
Sophist and challenger
A teacher of rhetoric from Chalcedon who storms into Book I claiming that justice is the interest of the stronger. His defeat is grudging, and his view sets the challenge the rest of the book must answer.
Cephalus
Aged host
A wealthy old man nearing death, at whose house the talk takes place. His comfortable view of justice as honesty and paying debts opens the inquiry before he leaves to tend the sacrifice.
Polemarchus
Heir of the argument
Cephalus’s son, who brings Socrates to the house and defends the poet Simonides’ view that justice means helping friends and harming enemies. In Book V his whisper to Adeimantus forces Socrates to explain the three waves.
Er
Messenger from the dead
A soldier from Pamphylia, killed in battle, who revives on his funeral pyre and reports how the dead are judged and choose their next lives. His story gives the book its closing image of justice and choice.
Character Relationships who connects to whom, and the themes that bind them
Family
Connection
Themes in The Republic what the novel is really about
What justice is
The book tries one definition after another: honesty and paying debts, helping friends and harming enemies, the interest of the stronger, a bargain made out of fear. Socrates’ own answer is that justice is each part of a city, or of a soul, doing its own work.
Whether justice pays
Glaucon and Adeimantus ask Socrates to prove that justice is good in itself, even with no reward and a bad name. Socrates answers that justice is the health of the soul, that the tyrant is the most miserable of men, and only at the very end brings back the rewards of justice.
The city and the soul
The ideal city is the soul written large. Its rulers, auxiliaries and producers match reason, spirit and appetite, and every corrupt city in Books VIII and IX has a matching corrupt person.
Knowledge, opinion and education
Most people, like the prisoners in the cave, live among shadows and opinions. Real education turns the whole soul from the changing world toward the Forms and the Good, which is why the rulers study for fifty years.
Freedom, power and tyranny
From Thrasymachus’s praise of the tyrant to the fall of democracy into tyranny, Plato asks what unchecked power does to those who hold it. His answer is that the man who can do anything he likes is ruled by his own desires and is the least free of all.
Art and truth
Socrates censors stories for children, sends the imitative poet away, and in Book X calls art a copy of a copy that feeds the passions. Yet he keeps telling myths himself, and leaves poetry a chance to defend herself.
Symbols & motifs
The ring of Gyges
A ring that makes its wearer invisible stands for power without consequences. It turns the question about justice into a test: would you still be good if no one could ever see what you did?
The metals
Gold, silver, and brass and iron in the citizens’ souls stand for the natural fitness that decides each person’s work. The myth makes a social order feel like a fact of nature.
The sun
The sun, which lets us see and makes things grow, stands for the Form of the Good, the source of truth and being in the world of thought.
The cave
The dark den of shadows stands for ordinary life ruled by opinion, and the climb into sunlight for the painful work of education. The return into the cave stands for the philosopher’s duty to rule.
The ship of state
A ship seized by quarrelling sailors who mock the true pilot stands for a city that prefers flattering speakers to people who know how to govern.
Recurring motifs
Going down and coming up. The book opens with Socrates going down to the Piraeus, and descents recur: Gyges climbs down into the earth, the freed prisoner must go back into the cave, and Er returns from the dead.
Comparisons with crafts. Doctors, pilots, shepherds, cobblers and musicians keep appearing, because Socrates treats ruling and living well as skills that call for real knowledge.
Light, sight and shadow. From the sun to the cave’s fire and shadows to the painter’s appearances, seeing clearly stands for knowing, and darkness for opinion and illusion.
Important quotes
“I proclaim that justice is nothing else than the interest of the stronger.”
“wherever any one thinks that he can safely be unjust, there he is unjust.”
“Citizens, we shall say to them in our tale, you are brothers, yet God has framed you differently. Some of you have the power of command, and in the composition of these he has mingled gold, wherefore also they have the greatest honour; others he has made of silver, to be auxiliaries; others again who are to be husbandmen and craftsmen he has composed of brass and iron”
“Until philosophers are kings, or the kings and princes of this world have the spirit and power of philosophy, and political greatness and wisdom meet in one, and those commoner natures who pursue either to the exclusion of the other are compelled to stand aside, cities will never have rest from their evils”
“here they have been from their childhood, and have their legs and necks chained so that they cannot move, and can only see before them, being prevented by the chains from turning round their heads.”
“The excess of liberty, whether in States or individuals, seems only to pass into excess of slavery.”
The ending of The Republic, explained
The Republic ends not with a law or a definition but with a story about choosing a life. In Book X Socrates first finishes his case against imitative poetry, which copies appearances and stirs up the passions, and then argues that the soul is immortal, since nothing destroys it, not even its own evil, injustice. Only now, after proving that justice is best in itself, does he give back the rewards he set aside in Book II: the just are honored by gods and men in life and repaid after death. The myth of Er shows how. Er, a soldier killed in battle, revives on his funeral pyre and reports that the dead are judged, that the just travel through heaven and the unjust beneath the earth for a thousand years, and that every soul must then choose its next life from lots laid before the Fates. The first chooser, who had been good only by habit and never studied philosophy, grabs a great tyranny without looking and then wails when he sees he is fated to devour his own children. Odysseus, choosing last and cured of ambition, gladly takes the quiet life of a private man that everyone else passed over. The lesson is that the blame lies with the chooser and not with god, and that philosophy matters because it teaches a person to tell a good life from a bad one. Socrates closes by urging Glaucon to hold always to justice and wisdom, so that it will go well with them both in this life and in the journey of a thousand years.
Common misreadings
MythThe title means the book argues for a republic in the modern sense.
ActuallyThe Greek title, Politeia, means something like constitution or way of governing. The ideal city is ruled by philosopher-kings, and the book is sharply critical of democracy.
MythThe Republic is Plato speaking directly in his own voice.
ActuallyPlato never appears. Socrates narrates and argues with others, and scholars still debate how far Socrates’ views here are Plato’s own.
MythThe ideal city is a practical blueprint Plato wanted to build.
ActuallySocrates builds the city in words to find justice in the soul, and in Book IX agrees that it may exist nowhere on earth but serves as a pattern laid up in heaven, though Books V and VII do discuss how it might come about.
MythPlato bans all art and poetry from the city.
ActuallyHe keeps hymns to the gods and praises of good men, and invites poetry’s lovers to defend her. His target is imitative poetry that copies appearances and feeds the passions.
Test yourself
1. Who narrates The Republic?
Socrates tells the whole conversation in the first person, beginning with his walk down to the Piraeus; Plato never appears.
2. What question drives the whole dialogue?
Book I asks what justice is, and Glaucon and Adeimantus make Socrates prove that it is better than injustice even with no rewards.
3. Why does Socrates build an imaginary city?
Like large letters that are easier to read, justice in a city is meant to show what justice is in a single person.
4. What does Socrates finally say justice is?
The definitions of Book I are rejected; in Book IV justice becomes the right order of the three classes and the three parts of the soul.
5. Who should rule the ideal city?
Socrates argues that cities will have no rest from their evils until philosophers become kings, or kings become philosophers.
Plus a quiz on each part: 10 more, 50 questions, in the chapter guide and at the end of each part in the reader.
Flashcards flip, self-grade, and the deck remembers what you know
Nice work.
One night some friends ask Socrates a big question: what does it mean to be fair and good, and is it worth it? A tough guest named Thrasymachus says being good is for suckers, because the strong make the rules. Two brothers, Glaucon and Adeimantus, push harder: if you had a magic ring that made you invisible, why would you ever follow the rules? To answer, Socrates imagines a perfect city where everyone does the job they are best at: wise rulers, brave guards and workers. He says a person is like that city inside, with a thinking part, a feisty part and a wanting part, and you are good and happy when your thinking part is in charge. Along the way he tells famous stories, like people chained in a cave who think shadows are real, and explains that the best rulers would be people who love wisdom. He ends with a story about souls choosing their next lives, to show that choosing well is what matters most.
Compare & connect the story universe
Apology
Plato’s account of Socrates’ trial shows the city executing the questioner, the fate the cave allegory warns will meet anyone who tries to free the prisoners.
The Allegory of the Cave
Our edition of the cave passage from Book VII studies on its own the image that sits at the center of The Republic.
1984
Orwell’s state uses lies, censorship and fixed classes to keep power, a dark mirror of the noble lie and controlled stories of Plato’s city.
Antigone
A Greek tragedy about whether the ruler’s law or a higher justice should be obeyed, the question Thrasymachus and Socrates argue about.
Animal Farm
Orwell’s fable traces how a revolution in the name of equality decays into tyranny, much as Book VIII traces democracy turning into tyranny.
Discussion & essay prompts for class, or your next paper
💬 Discussion questions
- What is justice according to Plato’s Republic
- What does the ring of Gyges show in The Republic
- What is the noble lie in Plato’s Republic
- How does The Republic explore the theme of what justice is?
- How does The Republic explore the theme of whether justice pays?
- What is the central conflict in The Republic, and how does it shape the ending?
✎ Essay prompts
- Analyze how Plato develops the theme of what justice is in The Republic. Support your argument with specific evidence from the text.
- Examine the significance of the ring of Gyges in The Republic. What does it represent, and how does it deepen the work’s meaning?
- How does Plato use narrated dialogue to shape the reader’s experience of The Republic?
- Some readers assume that the title means the book argues for a republic in the modern sense. Argue for or against this interpretation, using evidence from the text.
Key questions students ask
- What is justice according to Plato’s Republic
- What does the ring of Gyges show in The Republic
- What is the noble lie in Plato’s Republic
- What are the three parts of the soul in The Republic
- Why should philosophers rule in Plato’s Republic
- Why does Plato banish the poets in The Republic
Analysis is original StoryBites commentary. The full text and quotations follow Benjamin Jowett’s English translation of Plato’s Republic (third edition), as transcribed by Project Gutenberg (eBook #1497). Plato’s dialogue, written about 375 BC, and Jowett’s translation are in the public domain.