AP Language · letter · 11 min

Letter to His Son

A famous statesman writes from Bath to his fourteen-year-old son, who is traveling abroad with a tutor, and tries to make fatherly advice sound like the advice of a friend.

⏱ 11 min to understand the letter 6 steps of reasoning · 7 rhetorical choices Public domain text

Free, all of it. No ads, no account, no paywall, no trial, nothing to cancel.

📖 Read the full text on this pageEvery paragraph numbered, so you can cite it
0% explored
The whole letter in 60 seconds

In October 1746 Philip Dormer Stanhope, fourth Earl of Chesterfield, was at the spa town of Bath recovering his health. His son Philip, fourteen, had just set out across Europe with a tutor, and Chesterfield wrote to him often, at times twice in a week. This letter begins with a confession most parents never make out loud: he doubts that his advice will do any good, because he knows how young people receive advice from their elders. Then he gives the advice anyway, and the way he does it is the lesson. He calls himself a friend rather than a parent, mentions that the boy depends on him for every shilling while claiming not to mention it, and argues that hard study is the road to pleasure, not a duty. The exam printed only the opening two paragraphs, paragraphs 3 and 4 in our text, which end with ‘disgrace or ridicule’. The full letter goes on to quote Alexander Pope and Cicero, compare knowledge to grain stored against a bad harvest, and tell the boy to study people as closely as books.

The claim

The son should give his whole attention to whatever he learns and learn it thoroughly, because excelling is the greatest pleasure and a smattering brings only ridicule. Knowledge laid up in youth, from books and from close study of people, is what will support him later, and his father’s kindness will follow his merit.

The rhetorical situation who, to whom, when, and why

SpeakerLord Chesterfield, 52, a leading politician, diplomat and wit. In 1746 he was finishing a term as Lord Lieutenant of Ireland, and within weeks of this letter he became one of the King’s two Secretaries of State. He writes from Bath, where he had gone to recover his health.
AudienceHis son, Philip Stanhope, born in 1732. The boy’s mother was a woman named du Bouchet whom Chesterfield had known at The Hague; they never married, so Philip could not inherit his father’s title and depended entirely on him. Earlier in 1746 he had been at Westminster School in London.
OccasionPhilip had left England with his tutor, the Reverend Walter Harte, and was on his way to Lausanne in Switzerland. A letter from him written at Schaffhausen arrived just as Chesterfield finished this one, as the postscript says.
ExigenceChesterfield had planned the boy’s education in detail and feared it would be wasted. Five days later he wrote again, complaining that he had found in his son ‘laziness, inattention, and indifference’.
PurposeTo get a teenager to take advice seriously: to give his full attention to his studies, to learn things thoroughly, and to begin studying people as well as books.
ContextThe letters were private. After Philip died in 1768 and Chesterfield in 1773, Philip’s widow, Eugenia Stanhope, whose marriage Chesterfield had learned of only after his son’s death, published them in 1774. They sold widely and made Chesterfield a byword for polished, worldly advice.
Place

Bath, England

A fashionable spa town where the wealthy went to drink and bathe in the mineral waters. Chesterfield was there for his health, which colors his remarks about old age and about books being all he has left.

Time

October 4, 1746 (Old Style)

‘O. S.’ means Old Style: Britain still used the Julian calendar, eleven days behind the Continent, until 1752. Philip, in Switzerland, would have dated the same day October 15.

What Letter to His Son says

Chesterfield opens by admitting that, though he spends so much of his time writing to his son, he often doubts that it does any good. He knows that advice is unwelcome, that those who need it most like it least, and that young people put a parent’s advice down to the sourness, bossiness or chatter of old age. Still, he hopes that the boy’s reason, too young to produce much on its own but strong enough to recognize plain truth, will tell him that his father can have no interest but his son’s. He says he does not mean to dictate as a parent but to advise as a friend, and to be the guide of the boy’s pleasures, not their censor; his own experience can clear the thorns that scratched him when he was young. He then says he will not even hint that the boy is entirely dependent on him for money, or that his kindness will be measured only by the boy’s merit, because he trusts his son to do right for its own sake and out of gratitude. In the second paragraph he recommends attention and application, not as duties but as the way to pleasure: nothing is more pleasant than to excel others of your age, and nothing more humiliating than to be excelled, especially for a boy whose education everyone knows has cost so much care. But the aim is also to master the thing itself, since knowing a little of anything brings only disgrace or ridicule. The rest of the letter, which the exam did not print, quotes Pope’s couplet about a little knowledge being dangerous and says a smattering makes a coxcomb. Chesterfield asks what he would have done without learning at his own age: drunk away his evenings, gossiped himself into ridicule, or hanged himself from boredom. His books are now all he has left, as Cicero said learning would be. He tells the boy to hoard knowledge like grain in a good year, adds that knowledge of the world matters even more than knowledge of books, and urges him to look into people and find each one’s ruling passion. He ends by wishing the boy would read the letter twice, doubting he will finish it once, and in a postscript notes that the boy forgot the month when dating his last letter.

The line of reasoning how the argument moves

  1. Admits the problemParagraph 3 opens with doubt: advice is unwelcome, and a parent’s advice is blamed on old age. Naming the son’s objections first takes them away from him.
  2. Appeals to the boy’s reasonChesterfield flatters the boy’s reason as strong enough to judge plain truths, then argues that a father can have no interest but his son’s, so the advice deserves weighing.
  3. Recasts his roleHe offers himself as friend and guide, not parent and censor, and frames his experience as a path cleared of thorns.
  4. Reminds while denyingHe says he will not hint at the boy’s dependence on him or at kindness measured by merit, and in saying so states both plainly.
  5. Ties study to pleasure and prideParagraph 4 makes attention the road to the pleasure of excelling and the escape from the shame of being excelled, then raises the standard to mastering the thing itself.
  6. Widens the caseParagraphs 5 to 12, beyond the exam excerpt, add Pope, Cicero, his own old age, the granary analogy and the knowledge of the world, then end with a joke at his own expense.

The full text paragraphs numbered for citation

¶1Bath, October the 4th, O. S. 1746.

¶2Dear Boy,

¶3Though I employ so much of my time in writing to you, I confess, I have often my doubts, whether it is to any purpose. I know how unwelcome advice generally is; I know that those who want it most, like it and follow it least; and I know, too, that the advice of parents, more particularly, is ascribed to the moroseness, the imperiousness, or the garrulity of old-age. But then, on the other hand, I flatter myself, that as your own reason, (though too young as yet to suggest much to you of itself) is, however, strong enough to enable you, both to judge of, and receive plain truths: I flatter myself (I say) that your own reason, young as it is, must tell you, that I can have no interest but yours in the advice I give you; and that, consequently, you will at least weigh and consider it well: in which case, some of it will, I hope, have its effect. Do not think that I mean to dictate as a parent; I only mean to advise as a friend, and an indulgent one too: and do not apprehend that I mean to check your pleasures; of which, on the contrary, I only desire to be the guide, not the censor. Let my experience supply your want of it, and clear your way, in the progress of your youth, of those thorns and briars, which scratched and disfigured me in the course of mine. I do not, therefore, so much as hint to you, how absolutely dependent you are upon me; that you neither have, nor can have, a shilling in the world but from me; and that, as I have no womanish weakness for your person, your merit must, and will, be the only measure of my kindness. I say, I do not hint these things to you, because I am convinced that you will act right, upon more noble and generous principles: I mean, for the sake of doing right, and out of affection and gratitude to me.

¶4I have so often recommended, to you, attention and application to whatever you learn, that I do not mention them now as duties; but I point them out to you, as conducive, nay, absolutely necessary to your pleasures; for can there be a greater pleasure, than to be universally allowed to excel those of one’s own age and manner of life? And, consequently, can there be any thing more mortifying than to be excelled by them? In this latter case, your shame and regret must be greater than any body’s, because every body knows the uncommon care which has been taken of your education, and the opportunities you have had of knowing more than others of your age. I do not confine the application which I recommend, singly to the view and emulation of excelling others (though that is a very sensible pleasure and a very warrantable pride;) but I mean likewise to excel in the thing itself: for, in my mind, one may as well not know a thing at all, as know it but imperfectly. To know a little of any thing, gives neither satisfaction nor credit; but often brings disgrace or ridicule.

¶5Mr. Pope says, very truly,

¶6“A little knowledge is a dang’rous thing;

¶7Drink deep, or taste not the Castalian spring.”

¶8And what is called a smattering of every thing, infallibly constitutes a coxcomb. I have often, of late, reflected what an unhappy man I must now have been, if I had not acquired in my youth some fund and taste of learning. What could I have done with myself, at this age, without them? I must, as many ignorant people do, have destroyed my health and faculties by sotting away the evenings; or, by wasting them frivolously in the tattle of women’s company, must have exposed myself to the ridicule and contempt of those very women; or, lastly, I must have hanged myself, as a man once did, for weariness of putting on and pulling off his shoes and stockings every day. My books, and only my books, are now left me; and I daily find what Cicero says of learning to be true: “Hæc studia (says he) adolescentiam alunt, senectutem oblectant, secundas res ornant, adversis perfugium, ac solatium præbent, delectant domi, non impediunt foris, pernoctant nobiscum, peregrinantur, rusticantur.”

¶9I do not mean, by this, to exclude conversation out of the pleasures of an advanced age; on the contrary, it is a very great and a very rational pleasure, at all ages; but the conversation of the ignorant is no conversation, and gives even them no pleasure: they tire of their own sterility, and have not matter enough to furnish them with words to keep up a conversation.

¶10Let me, therefore, most earnestly recommend to you, to hoard up, while you can, a great stock of knowledge; for though, during the dissipation of your youth, you may not have occasion to spend much of it; yet, you may depend upon it, that a time will come, when you will want it to maintain you. Public granaries are filled in plentiful years; not that it is known that the next, or the second, or third year will prove a scarce one; but because it is known, that, sooner or later, such a year will come, in which the grain will be wanted.

¶11I will say no more to you upon this subject; you have Mr. Harte with you to enforce it; you have Reason to assent to the truth of it; so that, in short, “you have Moses and the Prophets; if you will not believe them, neither will you believe, though one rose from the dead.”—Do not imagine that the knowledge, which I so much recommend to you, is confined to books, pleasing, useful, and necessary as that knowledge is: but I comprehend in it the great knowledge of the world, still more necessary than that of books. In truth, they assist one another reciprocally; and no man will have either perfectly, who has not both. The knowledge of the world is only to be acquired in the world, and not in a closet. Books alone will never teach it you; but they will suggest many things to your observation, which might otherwise escape you; and your own observations upon mankind, when compared with those which you will find in books, will help you to fix the true point.

¶12To know mankind well, requires full as much attention and application as to know books, and, it may be, more sagacity and discernment. I am, at this time, acquainted with many elderly people, who have all passed their whole lives in the great world, but with such levity and inattention, that they know no more of it now, than they did at fifteen. Do not flatter yourself, therefore, with the thoughts that you can acquire this knowledge in the frivolous chit-chat of idle companies: no, you must go much deeper than that. You must look into people, as well as at them. Almost all people are born with all the passions, to a certain degree; but almost every man has one prevailing one, to which the others are subordinate. Search every one for that ruling passion; pry into the recesses of his heart, and observe the different workings of the same passion in different people. And, when you have found out the prevailing passion of any man, remember never to trust him, where that passion is concerned. Work upon him by it, if you please; but be upon your guard yourself against it, whatever professions he may make you.

¶13I would desire you to read this letter twice over, but that I much doubt whether you will read once to the end of it. I will trouble you no longer now; but we will have more upon this subject hereafter. Adieu.

¶14Chesterfield.

¶15I have this moment received your letter from Schaffhausen: in the date of it you forgot the month.

Text: Lord Chesterfield to Philip Stanhope, Bath, October 4, 1746 (O.S.), Letter LXXX in Letters to His Son, vol. 1 (London: J. Dodsley, 1774), via the Internet Archive.

Paragraph by paragraph what each part does

  1. 1

    Paragraphs 1 to 3: A friend, not a parent

    Chesterfield dates the letter from Bath and opens with ‘Dear Boy’. He admits he doubts that his many letters do any good, since advice is unwelcome and a parent’s advice is blamed on old age. He hopes the boy’s reason will see that his father has no interest but his son’s, insists he advises as an indulgent friend and wants to guide the boy’s pleasures, not forbid them, and then, while saying he will not hint at it, reminds the boy that every shilling comes from him and that kindness will follow merit.

    Why it mattersThis is the first paragraph the exam printed, and almost every sentence is built to disarm resistance. The triple ‘I know’ lists the son’s likely objections before the son can raise them, which is a classic way to win a reluctant listener: the father appears to be on the boy’s side, judging advice as harshly as any teenager would. The compliment to the boy’s reason is carefully measured. His reason is ‘too young as yet to suggest much to you of itself’ but strong enough to ‘receive plain truths’, so the praise also places the boy as a receiver, not a source, of wisdom. The pairs of roles (parent and friend, censor and guide) let Chesterfield redefine his authority as friendship without giving any of it up. The paragraph turns at ‘I do not, therefore, so much as hint’. Saying you will not say something, and then saying it, is called paralipsis, and here it carries the paragraph’s hardest message: the boy has no money but his father’s, and his father’s love is not unconditional. The closing appeal to ‘affection and gratitude to me’ shows how closely Chesterfield ties doing right to pleasing him.

  2. 2

    Paragraph 4: Excel in the thing itself

    Chesterfield recommends attention and application again, but now as the way to pleasure. He asks whether any pleasure is greater than being acknowledged to excel others of one’s age, or anything more humiliating than being excelled by them, and says the boy’s shame would be the greater because everyone knows how much care has gone into his education. He then adds a higher aim: to excel in the subject itself, since knowing a thing imperfectly is no better than not knowing it.

    Why it mattersThe second paragraph the exam printed changes the motive for study. Chesterfield knows that ‘duty’ will not move a fourteen-year-old, so he moves the argument onto ground the boy already cares about: pleasure and pride. The two rhetorical questions are a matched pair, the pleasure of excelling and the mortification of being excelled, and the second one does more work than the first, because it reminds the boy that everyone is watching an expensively educated boy. The words ‘universally allowed’ matter: excellence counts when others grant it, which shows how much Chesterfield values reputation. Then he corrects himself and raises the bar. Excelling others is ‘a very warrantable pride’, but he also wants mastery for its own sake. The paragraph ends in two balanced, quotable maxims, built as antitheses (know it well or not at all; neither satisfaction nor credit, but disgrace or ridicule). The final word, ‘ridicule’, is the thing Chesterfield fears most for his son, and it returns throughout his letters.

  3. 3

    Paragraphs 5 to 10: Learning laid up for old age

    Chesterfield quotes Pope’s couplet that a little knowledge is dangerous and says a smattering makes a coxcomb. He imagines what he would be now without learning: a drunkard, a gossip mocked by the very women he gossiped with, or a man who hanged himself from boredom with dressing every day. His books are all he has left, and he quotes Cicero’s praise of the studies that feed youth and delight old age. Conversation is a pleasure at every age, but not with the ignorant. He tells the boy to hoard knowledge now, as public granaries store grain in good years against the bad year that is sure to come.

    Why it mattersThe exam excerpt stops just before these paragraphs, but they finish the argument the excerpt begins. Pope and Cicero bring in authorities the boy was trained to respect; Chesterfield quotes Pope from memory, since the poem actually reads ‘A little learning’, but the point survives. The most striking move is personal. A powerful public man, writing from a health resort, tells his son that ‘My books, and only my books, are now left me’, and the comic list of alternatives (sotting, tattle, hanging himself over his shoes and stockings) makes the confession bearable. The granary analogy then turns all of this into practical sense. Its language is economic: hoard, stock, spend, maintain, wanted. That echoes the shilling of paragraph 3, and it shows how Chesterfield thinks of learning, as capital a young man saves now and lives on later.

  4. 4

    Paragraphs 11 and 12: Books and the world

    Chesterfield says he will say no more, since the boy has his tutor, Mr. Harte, and his own reason to persuade him, and borrows the words of Luke’s Gospel: if he will not believe Moses and the Prophets, he would not believe one risen from the dead. Then he widens the subject. The knowledge he means is not only from books but the knowledge of the world, which is even more necessary and can be learned only in the world. Many elderly people, he says, have lived among great affairs and know no more than they did at fifteen. The boy must look into people, find each person’s ruling passion, never trust a man where that passion is involved, and use it if he likes.

    Why it mattersParagraph 11 opens with another promise to stop that is immediately broken, and the biblical allusion is a joke at his own expense: if Harte and Reason fail, one more letter from a father will not help. The dash after the quotation marks the real turn of the letter. Book learning and worldly knowledge ‘assist one another reciprocally’, but the second is ‘still more necessary’. Here the reader meets the side of Chesterfield that made his letters famous and disliked. ‘You must look into people, as well as at them’ is good advice for anyone. The next step, to find a man’s ‘ruling passion’ (a phrase from Pope) and ‘work upon him by it’ while guarding against him, is advice for managing people. It reveals a man who sees society as a contest of interests, in which knowledge is a means of influence.

  5. 5

    Paragraphs 13 to 15: Read it twice

    Chesterfield says he would ask the boy to read the letter twice, except that he doubts the boy will read it once to the end. He promises more on the subject later, says ‘Adieu’, and signs ‘Chesterfield’. A postscript says that the boy’s letter from Schaffhausen has just arrived, and that he forgot to put the month in the date.

    Why it mattersThe close returns to the doubt of the opening, now as a joke, which frames the whole letter. The postscript is small but telling. The father who has just preached attention catches his son in an act of inattention, a missing month, and corrects it at once. It is the letter’s lesson in miniature.

Rhetorical choices what the writer does, and why it works

Anaphora

Paragraph 3 begins three clauses with ‘I know’. The repetition builds a list of reasons why advice fails, and it makes the father sound frank and self-aware before he asks for anything.

Procatalepsis (answering objections in advance)

Chesterfield states the boy’s likely complaints, that parental advice comes from moroseness, imperiousness or garrulity, before the boy can make them. An objection already named is harder to use.

Paralipsis

‘I do not, therefore, so much as hint to you, how absolutely dependent you are upon me’ mentions the boy’s dependence in the act of refusing to mention it. The device lets Chesterfield deliver a warning while keeping the tone of a friend. He repeats the move in paragraph 11, ‘I will say no more’, and then says a great deal more.

Antithesis

The letter is full of balanced opposites: parent and friend, guide and censor, to excel and to be excelled, satisfaction and credit against disgrace and ridicule, looking into people and looking at them. The balance makes each piece of advice sound like a settled truth.

Rhetorical questions

Paragraph 4 asks whether any pleasure is greater than excelling, or anything more mortifying than being excelled. The questions expect only one answer and lead the boy to supply it himself.

Analogy

Paragraph 10 compares learning to grain stored in public granaries during plentiful years against a scarce year that will certainly come. Youth is the harvest, age is the lean year, and the comparison makes study look like prudence rather than drudgery.

Allusion

Chesterfield draws on Pope’s Essay on Criticism, Cicero’s praise of literature, and the parable of the rich man and Lazarus in Luke 16. The allusions are themselves a display of the learning he recommends, and they place his advice beside authorities the boy was taught to honor.

People & audiences

Lord Chesterfield

Writer and father

A worldly statesman in middle age who presents himself as his son’s indulgent friend while keeping firm control. His doubts, jokes and confessions are all used to make the advice land.

Philip Stanhope

Recipient, aged 14

Chesterfield’s son, traveling to Lausanne with a tutor. He never speaks in the letter, but his imagined objections and his forgotten month shape it.

Mr. Harte

Tutor

The Reverend Walter Harte, an Oxford scholar who accompanied Philip on his travels. Chesterfield names him as one of two forces, with the boy’s own Reason, that should enforce the advice.

Alexander Pope

Poet quoted

The leading English poet of the age. His couplet about a little knowledge being dangerous supports Chesterfield’s attack on the smattering.

Cicero

Roman orator quoted

The Roman statesman whose praise of literature, that it feeds youth, delights old age and stays with us at home and abroad, Chesterfield quotes in Latin as proof from his own experience.

Big ideas in Letter to His Son

Excellence and thoroughnessReputation and ridiculePleasure as a motiveLove with conditionsKnowledge of books and of the worldYouth and age

Excellence and thoroughness

Chesterfield wants his son to excel others and to master each subject completely. A little knowledge, he says, is worse than none, because it invites ridicule.

Reputation and ridicule

Much of the letter turns on how others will see the boy: ‘universally allowed’ to excel, watched by ‘every body’ who knows his education, at risk of disgrace. Chesterfield treats reputation as something a young man builds deliberately.

Pleasure as a motive

Instead of preaching duty, Chesterfield argues that study leads to pleasure: the pleasure of excelling now and of books and conversation in old age. He meets a teenager on his own ground.

Love with conditions

The father is affectionate but insists that merit will be ‘the only measure of my kindness’. His love is real, and it is also an instrument of control.

Knowledge of books and of the world

Learning matters, but knowing people matters more, and each kind of knowledge corrects the other. The letter moves from the schoolroom to society.

Youth and age

The letter is written by an aging man to a boy. What youth stores up, age lives on, and the father’s experience is offered as a path already cleared.

Key images

Thorns and briars

The obstacles that ‘scratched and disfigured’ Chesterfield in his own youth. They stand for the mistakes his experience can spare his son.

The granary

Grain stored in a good year stands for knowledge stored in youth. It turns education into foresight.

The shilling

The one coin named in the letter stands for the boy’s total dependence on his father, and for the power that sits under the friendly tone.

Repeated words and ideas

Attention. ‘Attention and application’ in paragraph 4, ‘inattention’ in paragraph 12, and the forgotten month in the postscript. Attention is the habit Chesterfield is trying to build.

Ridicule. Disgrace and ridicule end paragraph 4, the coxcomb follows, and the gossip who is laughed at appears in paragraph 8. Being laughed at is the fate the letter warns against.

The language of money. Shilling, hoard, stock, spend, maintain. Chesterfield speaks of learning as savings, which suits both his practical mind and the boy’s dependence on him.

Tensions and counterarguments

Father vs. son. The father needs a teenager to take advice that teenagers dislike. The whole opening is an attempt to avoid open resistance.

Friendship vs. authority. Chesterfield claims to advise as a friend but holds all the money and sets the conditions of his kindness. The letter tries to keep both roles at once.

Books vs. the world. Learning from books is necessary, but knowledge of people is ‘still more necessary’. The letter weighs the two and decides that each needs the other.

Key quotes

“I know how unwelcome advice generally is; I know that those who want it most, like it and follow it least; and I know, too, that the advice of parents, more particularly, is ascribed to the moroseness, the imperiousness, or the garrulity of old-age.”
Paragraph 3. The triple ‘I know’ names the son’s objections before he can make them, so the father seems to share the boy’s view of advice.
“Do not think that I mean to dictate as a parent; I only mean to advise as a friend, and an indulgent one too: and do not apprehend that I mean to check your pleasures; of which, on the contrary, I only desire to be the guide, not the censor.”
Paragraph 3. Two pairs of roles, parent against friend and censor against guide, recast authority as friendship.
“I do not, therefore, so much as hint to you, how absolutely dependent you are upon me; that you neither have, nor can have, a shilling in the world but from me; and that, as I have no womanish weakness for your person, your merit must, and will, be the only measure of my kindness.”
Paragraph 3. Paralipsis: the warning is delivered in the act of declining to deliver it. ‘Womanish weakness’ shows the period’s view of tenderness as soft and female.
“for, in my mind, one may as well not know a thing at all, as know it but imperfectly. To know a little of any thing, gives neither satisfaction nor credit; but often brings disgrace or ridicule.”
Paragraph 4. The last sentences of the exam excerpt, built as balanced maxims. ‘Ridicule’ is the fear behind much of the letter.
“Public granaries are filled in plentiful years; not that it is known that the next, or the second, or third year will prove a scarce one; but because it is known, that, sooner or later, such a year will come, in which the grain will be wanted.”
Paragraph 10. The analogy makes study a kind of saving: youth is the good harvest, and age is the lean year that is sure to come.
“You must look into people, as well as at them.”
Paragraph 12. The shortest sentence in the letter and its neatest antithesis, the step from book learning to the knowledge of the world.
How it ends

The conclusion of Letter to His Son, explained

After two pages of instruction Chesterfield ends with a joke against himself: he would ask the boy to read the letter twice, ‘but that I much doubt whether you will read once to the end of it.’ This brings back the doubt of the first sentence, so the letter closes the way it opened, with a father who knows how sons treat long letters. The joke is also a last act of persuasion. A boy who laughs at it has, after all, read to the end. ‘I will trouble you no longer now; but we will have more upon this subject hereafter’ is half apology and half promise, and the promise was kept: five days later Chesterfield wrote again, scolding the boy for laziness and inattention. ‘Adieu’ is French, the language of polite Europe and of Lausanne, where the boy was heading. The signature is not ‘your father’ but ‘Chesterfield’, his title, which is how a peer signed but also a reminder of rank. Then comes the postscript. The boy’s letter from Schaffhausen has just arrived, and he forgot the month in the date. After a letter about attention, the father catches a small inattention and corrects it at once. For a student, the postscript is worth a sentence in an essay, because it shows in one line the habits the letter values: precision, watchfulness and a father who reads every word.

Common misreadings

MythChesterfield wrote the letter to be published as a guide for young men.

ActuallyIt was a private letter. It was printed in 1774, after both father and son had died, when Philip’s widow published the collection.

MythThe exam passage is the whole letter.

ActuallyThe exam printed only the first two paragraphs, which end with ‘disgrace or ridicule’. The letter continues with Pope, Cicero, the granary analogy and the knowledge of the world.

Myth‘Dear Boy’ means the son was a small child.

ActuallyPhilip was fourteen and traveling abroad with a tutor. ‘Dear Boy’ was Chesterfield’s usual greeting to him in these years.

MythWhen Chesterfield says he will not hint at the boy’s dependence, he is reassuring him.

ActuallyIt is paralipsis. By saying what he will not mention, he mentions it clearly: the boy has no money but his father’s, and kindness depends on merit.

MythChesterfield cares only about book learning.

ActuallyHe values books highly but calls knowledge of the world ‘still more necessary’, and much of the letter is about studying people.

AP practice a rhetorical analysis prompt in the exam's style

In October 1746 Lord Chesterfield, a British statesman, wrote from Bath to his fourteen-year-old son, Philip, who was traveling to Switzerland with a tutor. Read paragraphs 1 to 4 of the letter carefully. Then write an essay that analyzes how Chesterfield tries to make his son receive his advice, and what those choices show about the kind of man he hopes his son will become.

What a strong response notices

  • The triple ‘I know’ in paragraph 3, which names the boy’s objections to parental advice before he can raise them.
  • The measured compliment to the boy’s reason and the argument that a father ‘can have no interest but yours’.
  • The paired roles in paragraph 3 (parent and friend, censor and guide) and the image of thorns and briars.
  • The paralipsis ‘I do not, therefore, so much as hint’, which states the boy’s financial dependence and the condition on his father’s kindness.
  • The shift in paragraph 4 from duty to pleasure, the paired rhetorical questions, and the closing maxims about knowing a thing imperfectly.

Practice prompt written by StoryBites, not taken from a College Board exam. See the AP Language free-response guide for how answers are scored.

Test yourself

1. Where was Chesterfield when he wrote the letter, and where was his son?

2. How does Chesterfield describe the role he wants to play?

3. What device is Chesterfield using when he says he does ‘not, therefore, so much as hint’ that the boy depends on him?

4. Why does Chesterfield say the boy’s shame would be greater than anyone else’s if he were excelled?

5. What does the granary analogy in paragraph 10 suggest?

Flashcards flip, self-grade, and the deck remembers what you know

tap to flip
Answer

Report a mistake on this card

Explain it like I’m 12

Lord Chesterfield was an important British politician. In 1746 his fourteen-year-old son was traveling in Europe with a tutor, and Chesterfield wrote him letters full of advice. In this one he admits that kids usually ignore their parents’ advice, then tries to get around that by saying he is talking as a friend, not a bossy parent. He tells his son to pay attention and learn things properly, because it feels great to be the best and terrible to be beaten, and knowing only a little makes you look silly. He also says that learning is like saving grain for a bad year, and that understanding people matters as much as reading books.

Compare & connect

Letter to John Quincy Adams

Abigail Adams

Another parent writes to a son of about the same age who is traveling in Europe. Abigail Adams argues from duty and from the hard times of the Revolution, while Chesterfield argues from pleasure, pride and reputation, so the two letters show different values in the same situation.

Hamlet

William Shakespeare

Polonius’s advice to his son Laertes in Act 1, Scene 3, before Laertes leaves for France, is the most famous fatherly send-off in English. Like Chesterfield, Polonius mixes sound sense with worldly calculation.

The American Scholar

Ralph Waldo Emerson

Emerson also weighs books against experience of the world. Where Chesterfield wants knowledge as a means of influence, Emerson wants the scholar to think for himself.

Discussion and essay prompts:

💬 Discussion questions

  • What is Lord Chesterfield’s main advice to his son in the letter of October 4, 1746
  • How does Chesterfield try to make his advice welcome
  • What does the letter show about Chesterfield’s values
  • How does Letter to His Son explore the theme of excellence and thoroughness?
  • How does Letter to His Son explore the theme of reputation and ridicule?
  • What is the central conflict in Letter to His Son, and how does it shape the ending?

✎ Essay prompts

  1. Analyze how Lord Chesterfield develops the theme of excellence and thoroughness in Letter to His Son. Support your argument with specific evidence from the text.
  2. Examine the significance of thorns and briars in Letter to His Son. What does it represent, and how does it deepen the work’s meaning?
  3. How does Lord Chesterfield use anaphora to shape the reader’s experience of Letter to His Son?
  4. Some readers assume that chesterfield wrote the letter to be published as a guide for young men. Argue for or against this interpretation, using evidence from the text.

Key questions students ask

  • What is Lord Chesterfield’s main advice to his son in the letter of October 4, 1746
  • How does Chesterfield try to make his advice welcome
  • What does the letter show about Chesterfield’s values
  • What is paralipsis in Chesterfield’s letter
  • Who was Philip Stanhope and how old was he in 1746
  • What part of Chesterfield’s letter was on the AP English Language exam

Analysis is original StoryBites commentary. The full text and quotations follow the first edition of Chesterfield’s letters to his son, published by Eugenia Stanhope (London: J. Dodsley, 1774), volume 1, Letter LXXX, transcribed from the page images of the Internet Archive copy and checked against John Bradshaw’s edition of 1892; neither edition’s notes are reproduced. The exam printed the first two paragraphs from a later, modernized text: it reads ‘anything’, ‘anybody’s’, ‘everybody’ and ‘old age’ where the 1774 edition has ‘any thing’, ‘any body’s’, ‘every body’ and ‘old-age’, drops the parentheses around ‘though too young as yet to suggest much to you of itself’, and differs in about a dozen commas, colons and semicolons, but the words are the same. The letter is in the public domain. An excerpt from the letter was the passage for the rhetorical analysis question on the 2004 AP English Language exam (College Board free-response questions, 2004).

Share this guide

Continue exploring

Follow a thread — every work connects to others through what they share.